430 likes | 591 Views
Human noroviruses : Challenges in Prevention and Control. Dr. Kristen Gibson Assistant Professor, Department of Food Science University of Arkansas AFDO Conference. Norovirus Transmission. Some history…. Discovered in 1972 by EM
E N D
Human noroviruses: Challenges in Prevention and Control Dr. Kristen Gibson Assistant Professor, Department of Food Science University of Arkansas AFDO Conference
Some history… • Discovered in 1972 by EM • Infectious stool filtrate derived from outbreak in an elementary school in Norwalk, OH (1968) • Originally called “Norwalk virus” • Prototype strain of the noroviruses
Common Misnomers for Norovirus • Stomach Flu • “24-hour” Flu • Winter Vomiting Disease • Cruise Ship Virus • Norovirus is commonly • referred to as the “flu”: • seasonal component • rapid onset
Over 90% of diarrheal illness outbreaks on cruise ships are due to norovirus.
Virus Structure and Function • Viruses are small, intracellular parasites that cannot reproduce by themselves. • An infectious virus particle is referred to as a virion. • A virion consists of the nucleic acid and an outer shell of protein, referred to as a capsid. • A virion may be enveloped or non-enveloped. • Most viral host ranges are narrow.
Foodborne viruses of human health concern are: • Non-enveloped • Small (25-100 nm) • Resistant to environmental degradation
Norovirus • Single-stranded RNA, non-enveloped viruses • 5 genogroups (GI, GII, GIII, GIV, GV) and 31 genetic clusters • Human = GI, GII, and GIV CDC, 2006. Norovirus: Technical Fact Sheet; Hutsonet al. 2004
80% Glass et al., 2009
Norovirus • Single-stranded RNA, non-enveloped viruses • 5 genogroups (GI, GII, GIII, GIV, GV) and 31 genetic clusters • Human = GI, GII, and GIV • Clinical Symptoms • 24-48 hr incubation • Vomiting, watery diarrhea, stomach cramps, nausea, and general malaise • Self-limiting (24-60 hrs) • No known chronic sequelae • Complications include volume depletion and dehydration • Potential for chronic infections in immunocompromised and physically stressed individuals CDC, 2006. Norovirus: Technical Fact Sheet; Hutsonet al. 2004
Norovirus • Routes • Fecal-oral route (food, water, person-person) • Environmental and fomite contamination • Aerosolization of vomitus (hotel carpet, reusable grocery bags) • Ease of transmission • ID = 19 to 100 virions • High rate of secondary transmission • Immunity • Strain-specific, lasting only a few months • Population immunity plays role in formation of novel variants CDC, 2006. Norovirus:Technical Fact Sheet
U.S. Foodborne Outbreaks 2009-2010 • Norovirus caused 49% (233) of lab confirmed single etiology outbreaks reported. • 34% due to an unknown etiology • Most common food commodity associated with NoV outbreaks are leafy vegetables. • NoV caused the most outbreaks from 1998 to 2008 Source: www.foodqualitynews.com www.cdc.gov
Food safety issue? • Highly contagious • Prolific shedding • Constantly evolving • Limited immunity • Moderately virulent Large pool of susceptible hosts
Food safety issue? • Persistence and Environmental Stability • Resistant to common chemical disinfectants • Thermo-tolerant • Survives for weeks on surfaces and for months in water Numerous NoV outbreaks each year are due to transmission via contaminated surfaces.
Food as a Vehicle for Norovirus Transmission • Primary transmission • Contamination of foods in the “raw” material stage before harvest • Bivalve mollusks such as oysters • Application of contaminated water and sewage sludge to fruit and vegetable crops • Leafy vegetables, green onions, etc.
Food as a Vehicle for Norovirus Transmission • Primary transmission • Contamination of foods in the “raw” material stage before harvest • Bivalve mollusks such as oysters • Application of contaminated water and sewage sludge to fruit and vegetable crops • Leafy vegetables, green onions, etc. • Secondary transmission • Occurs during processing, storage, distribution, and final preparation • Field workers • Infected food handlers • Contaminated surfaces or equipment
Critical Control Points • Hand hygiene • Hand sanitizers (NOT a replacement for…) • Hand washing • Appropriate sanitizers and disinfectants • Concentration • Contact time • Tools for application and cleaning • Spray, foam, impregnated wipes • Reusable or disposable cloths
Cleaning Cloths? Cellulose Cotton Cellulose Cotton Microfiber Nonwoven Cloth Cotton Terry Towel
Primary Questions • What is the virus removal efficiency of each cloth? • Do the cloths transfer virus back to the surface? If so, what level of virus is transferred?
Cleaning Cloth Study • Two surfaces • Stainless steel • Solid surface (e.g., formica) • 5 cleaning cloths • Cotton-cellulose blend (2) • Microfiber • Non-woven • Terry bar towel • 4 NoV surrogates and NoV GI.1
Cleaning Cloth Study • Virus Removal • 100,000 to 1,000,000 viruses on surface • 700 viruses from solid surface across all cloths • 1,400 viruses from stainless steel across all cloths
Cleaning Cloth Study: Virus Transfer Two log difference in virus transfer between cellulose/cotton and terry towel cloths.
Cleaning Cloth Study • Use of appropriate cleaning tools is a CRITICAL step in controlling transmission • Reusable cloths may be reservoirs for transmission of pathogens • First study to look at virus removal and transfer by cleaning cloths…WHY?
Outbreaks associated with food or restaurant settings have significantly higher attack rates (>50%) than outbreaks in other settings.
How to Address Food Safety and Norovirus • Shift the approach used for monitoring and control strategies • Proactive vs. Reactive • Understand the characteristics of norovirus • Optimization of methods for the detection of norovirus in foodstuffs • Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points (HACCP) • Better characterize risk posed by individual microbial contaminants • Investigate priority contaminants (i.e., norovirus) • Selection of appropriate treatment technology • Outbreak Surveillance • Passive vs. Active