1 / 6

Managing Overconfidence

Managing Overconfidence. Douglas J. Collins, FCAS, MAAA doug.collins@towersperrin.com Tillinghast London (Tel: 44 (0)207 170 2162) CAE Zurich – 23 April 2004. Many factors contribute to errors (and bias!) in pricing and underwriting.

Download Presentation

Managing Overconfidence

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Managing Overconfidence Douglas J. Collins, FCAS, MAAA doug.collins@towersperrin.com Tillinghast London (Tel: 44 (0)207 170 2162) CAE Zurich – 23 April 2004

  2. Many factors contribute to errors (and bias!) in pricing and underwriting Common Sources of Pricing and Underwriting Error/Bias (Micro) Systemic Sources of Pricing and Underwriting Error/Bias (Macro) • Inadequate internal [historical] data upon which to develop estimates (e.g., old, incomplete or inaccurate data; inadequate/inappropriate sample) • Inability to collect and synthesize all relevant sources of data within the organization • Lack of reliable information about external market conditions and trends (e.g., inflation, tort costs) • Excessive concern for “competitive pressures” • Lack of adequate oversight over pricing decisions • Lack of “metaknowledge” — reinforces inherent overconfidence when making estimates, forecasts and predictions • Long feedback loop • No skin in the game

  3. The results of a recent Tillinghast “Confidence Quiz” illustrate the prevalence of overconfidence Tillinghast Confidence Quiz The Quiz Raw Scores of Online Respondents • Objective: To test respondents understanding of the limits of their knowledge • Respondents were asked to answer ten questions related to their general knowledge of the global property/casualty industry • For each answer, respondents were asked to provide a range that offered a 90% confidence interval that they would answer correctly • Ideally (i.e., if “well calibrated”), respondents should have gotten nine out of ten questions correct Number of Respondents Note: based on 374 respondents as of 4/5/04.Profile of respondents: 86% work in P/C industry; 73% are actuaries.

  4. 1. Pricing and Underwriting Process Elements • Data required • Actuarial methods employed • Underwriting policies and rules • Decision authorities and reporting • Quality assurance 3. Formal Retrospective Performance Testing • Data accurate and adequate? • Pricing methods sufficiently robust? • Policies and rules effective? • Decision authorities appropriate? • Variances between projected and actual experience within tolerances? 1. Define/Refine Process 3. MeasurePerformance 2. ImplementProcess The best way to manage overconfidence is to implement a control cycle for pricing and underwriting The Control Cycle: Retrospective Test of Pricing/Underwriting • A control cycle for P/C pricing and underwriting entails identifying, testing and validating all of the assumptions that underlie the projection of future loss costs used to price and underwrite the business

  5. While improving pricing/underwriting requires a sustained commitment over time, three near-term steps will jump start the process Retrospective Analysis • Analyze relevant sample of pricing and underwriting results to identify/pinpoint specific causes and sources of error Process Design/Refinement • Define (or refine) and institutionalize an ongoing process of continuous improvement (i.e., control cycle) for pricing and underwriting • Incorporate insights from retrospective analysis to address key challenges and deficiencies Case-study Training • Develop/institute case-study oriented training modules for underwriters and pricing actuaries to provide practical experience and rapid feedback • Base training materials on past business where results are already known

  6. Managing overconfidence in pricing and underwriting

More Related