340 likes | 462 Views
WHAT MADE THE YISHUV VIABLE?. INSTITUTIONS. YISHUV . THE JEWISH COMMUNITY IN MANDATORY PALESTINE 1922-1948 GREW FROM ABOUT 80,000 TO 650,000 LABOR ZIONISM REVISIONIST ZIONISM GENERAL ZIONISM. WHY DID THE FIRST ALIYA FAIL?. JEWS PREFERRED AMERICA IT HAD HIGHER WAGES
E N D
WHAT MADE THE YISHUV VIABLE? INSTITUTIONS
YISHUV • THE JEWISH COMMUNITY IN MANDATORY PALESTINE 1922-1948 • GREW FROM ABOUT 80,000 TO 650,000 • LABOR ZIONISM • REVISIONIST ZIONISM • GENERAL ZIONISM
WHY DID THE FIRST ALIYA FAIL? • JEWS PREFERRED AMERICA • IT HAD HIGHER WAGES • IT ATTRACTED MORE JEWS • JEWISH IMMIGRANTS LIVED IN CITIES • ARAB LABOR WAS MORE COST-EFFECTIVE THAN JEWISH LABOR • POLITICS DID NOT MAKE SOCIETY
WHY DID THE SECOND ALIYA SUCCEED? • A CONVENTIONAL EXPLANATION LOOKS TO THE JEWISH AGENCY “VIRTUAL GOVERNMENT” • BUT THERE WAS NO HOMOGENOUS ZIONIST MOVEMENT • A DEEPER LOOK FOCUSES ON LABOR ZIONISM
WHAT WAS THE 2ND ALIYA? • MOVEMENT OF ZIONIST IMMIGRANTS FROM 1905-1915 • LED THE “YISHUV” INTO STATEHOOD • PROMINENT AND DOMINANT LEADERS: DAVID BENGURION, YITZHAK BEN ZVI, • “SOCIALISTS” WHO PUT POLITICS IN COMMAND
POLITICAL ICONOGRAPHY THEODOR HERZL
CHAIM WEIZMANN • PRESIDENT OF ISRAEL WITH US PRESIDENT HARRY TRUMAN
BERL KATZNELSON • LABOR ZIONIST IDEOLOGIST
INNOVATIONS OF LABOR ZIONISM • HISTADRUT • KIBBUTZIM & JEWISH NATIONAL FUND • HAGANA • HEBREW
HISTADRUT • GENERAL ORGANIZATION OF JEWISH WORKERS IN ERETZ YISRAEL FOUNDED IN HAIFA IN 1920. • GENERAL SECRETARY WAS DAVID BEN-GURION • CLASSICAL ZIONISM WAS MIDDLE CLASS BUT IN PALESTINE IT WAS COLECTIVIST • HISTADRUT PIONEERED A DUAL ECONOMY EMPLOYED STRIKES, POLITICAL POWER OVER JEWISH AGENCY SPENDING, AND INVESTMENT OF ITS OWN RESOURCES (HEVRAT OVDIM AND SOLEL BONEH) • CONTROL OF HISTADRUT ENSURED THAT MANY NEW IMMIGRANTS WERE TIED TO LABOR.
HISTADRUT AS A POLITICAL CENTER • HISTADRUT WAS THE NUCLEUS OF THE STATE BECAUSE • IT WAS AN ARENA FOR POLITICAL COMPETITION • IT HELD RESOURCES FOR DISTRIBUTION • IT CONTROLLED ITS OWN MILITARY FORCE • IT COULD DISCIPLINE OTHER SECTIONS OF THE YISHUV
THE KIBBUTZ • THE KIBBUTZ WAS A COLLECTIVE FARM • MEMBERS LIVED COMMUNALLY • MEMBERS SHARED THE PROFITS • MEMBERS HAD NO INDIVIDUAL PROPERTY
ICONOGRAPHY OF THE KIBBUTZ • HAPPY HEALTHY KIBBUTZNIKS
WHAT ABOUT THE JEWISH NATIONAL FUND? • BOUGHT LAND USING DONATIONS FROM ABROAD • HELD LAND AS A “CORPORATION” • MADE “SOCIALIST” I.E., NON-MARKET DECISIONS ABOUT PURCHASE AND USE • NEVER SOLD LAND
WHY WAS IT IMPORTANT? • THE KIBBUTZ PROVIDED THE ZIONISM WITH TERRITORIAL EXTENSION • BY REPLACING FOR-PROFIT AGRICULTURE THE KIBBUTZ ALSO CREATED JEWISH PEASANTS • THE KIBBUTZ PROVIDED THE IMAGE OF A HEROIC ZIONIST PIONEER AND PROVIDED THE MANPOWER FOR THE NUCLEUS OF THE PROTO-ARMY.
WHAT WAS HAGANA? • A MILITIA ATTACHED TO HISTADRUT • 1907 BEN GURION AND BEN TZVI FOUNDED THE BAR GIORA AND BY 1914 FIELDED FOUR SQUADS • 1920 ACHDUT HAAVODA PARTY ORGANIZED DIRECTLY UNDER THE POLITICAL CONTROL OF THE HISTADRUT LEADERSHIP • HAGANA EMERGED FROM THE REALITY OF RURAL SELF-HELP BUT ITS STRUCTURE DERIVED FROM EUROPEAN SOCIALIST VIEWS OF THE STATE • 1936 HAGANA HAD 3,000 MEN AT ARMS AND A CLEAR “DUAL POWER” IN PALESTINE EXISTED.
THE ICONOGRAPHY OF HAGANA • THE SOLITARY GUARDIANS
HEBREW • YIDDISH WAS THE COMMON LANGUAGE OF EUROPEAN JEWS • HEBREW CREATED A COMMON CULTURE • HEBREW ALSO FORCED THEM TO CUT TIES WITH THEIR PAST • BIBLICAL (CLASSICAL) HEBREW HAD TO BE MADE VERNACULAR (NATIONAL)
THIRD ALIYA • BETWEEN 1920 AND 1925 • SECOND GENERATION OF PRE-STATE LEADERS • STILL ONLY ABOUT 35,000 JEWS CAME IN THAT WAVE.
LARGE-SCALE IMMIGRATION IN THE LATE 20s AND 30s • INCREASED IMMIGRATION TO PALESTINE BECAUSE: • 1924 CLOSURE OF THE US • GROWTH OF STATE-SPONSORED ANTI-SEMITISM IN EUROPE • 60,000 CAME IN THE FOURTH ALIYA AND 190,000 JEWS CAME BETWEEN 1932 AND 1936
REINFORCEMENT OF LABOR ZIONISM • HISTADRUT WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR MOST OF THE ABSORPTION OF JEWISH IMMIGRANTS • MOST WERE URBAN RESIDENTS WHO DEPENDED ON THE DUAL ECONOMY FOR EVEN MINIMAL SURVIVAL