1 / 64

INVE Aquafeed Experts Customized Products and Services for Aqua Feedmills

REPLACING FISH MEAL AND FISH OIL IN AQUAFEEDS: aquaculture escaping from the fish trap Peter Coutteau, PhD INVE Aquafeed Experts INVE Aquaculture Belgium. INVE Aquafeed Experts Customized Products and Services for Aqua Feedmills. Complementarity at your service.

dory
Download Presentation

INVE Aquafeed Experts Customized Products and Services for Aqua Feedmills

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. REPLACING FISH MEAL AND FISH OIL IN AQUAFEEDS: aquaculture escaping from the fish trapPeter Coutteau, PhD INVE Aquafeed ExpertsINVE AquacultureBelgium AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  2. INVE Aquafeed ExpertsCustomized Products and Services for Aqua Feedmills Complementarity at your service AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007 INVE_AquaFeed_Experts@inve.be

  3. Finfish & shellfish production 2003 capture fisheries and aquaculture (FAO 2006) AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  4. Fish meal/oil : aquaculture in the fish trap ? AQUACULTURE ? INDUSTRIAL FISHERIES FISH M/O AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  5. Aquaculture escaping from the fish (meal/oil) trap • Fishmeal/oil supply & use: current & future • Critical issues to reduce FM/FO use : • Feed performance & cost-efficiency • Sustainability • Consumer demands • Environmental impact AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  6. World production of fish meal & fish oil(data from Shepherd J.- IFFO, 2006) *2005 expected AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  7. Price of fish meal/oil(data from IFFO) 1999-2006: + 350-400% AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  8. Global production of commodities (USDA 2006 –http://www.fas.usda.gov; IFFO 2006) AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  9. Global production of commodities (USDA 2006 –http://www.fas.usda.gov; IFFO 2006) + 15-30 mmt Rendered products (Tacon, 2006) AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  10. Price of soybean meal/oil Source: Oilseed and Products, World Markets and Trade, USDA FAS Cotton Oilseeds Tobacco and Seeds Div June 2005. (2006 Soya & Oilseed Bluebook page 320 www.soyatech.com) AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  11. Global estimate aquafeed market 2012Tacon et al. (FAO-2006) +6%/YR AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  12. Global estimate aquafeed market 2012Tacon et al. (FAO-2006) +5.3% Avg expected growth %/YR 2005-2012 +7.0% +7.4% +7.7% +4.9% AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  13. Estimated global use of fish meal for 2006 in aquafeeds per species group Total FM use in 2006: 3.01 mmt = 59% of total production (IFFO & FAO) AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  14. Estimated global use of fish oil for 2006 in aquafeeds per species group Total FO use in 2006: 0.78 mmt = 87% of total production (IFFO & FAO) AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  15. Estimated % of fish meal consumed by aquaculture – historical data (data from FAO-Tacon et al., 2006; IFFO 2006) AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  16. Estimated % of fish oil consumed by aquaculture – historical data (data from FAO-Tacon et al., 2006; IFFO 2006) AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  17. Projections FM/FO use for 2012 AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  18. Aquaculture escaping from the fish (meal/oil) trap • Fishmeal/oil supply & use: current & future • Critical issues to reduce FM/FO use • Feed performance & cost-efficiency • Sustainability • Consumer demands • Environmental impact AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  19. Stabilization of formula cost through FM/FO replacement Assumptions for simplified simulation • CP/CF 48/20 • High FM/FO control (44%FM+11%FO) = 2/3 CP + ¾ CF from FM/FO • Basal requirements for seabass • Standard raw materials AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  20. AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  21. Reduced dependence on bottleneck raw materials Formulative flexibility to switch to alternatives • Least-cost formulation for best performance • Restrictions: NUTRIENTS > INGREDIENTS • Specific nutritional requirements • Nutrient interactions & availability • Quantify/Cost “functional” properties (binding, attractant) • Practical implications feedmill • Purchase & stock raw materials • Flexibility processing conditions • Standardize feed quality & cost/performance AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  22. Why feed fish/shrimp with fish ? • Fish (meal/oil) is (was?) a cost-efficient source of • NUTRIENTS • Essential amino acids • Highly digestible protein & fat • Essential fatty acids • Liposoluble vitamins • Phospholipids • Cholesterol • Trace & macro minerals • ATTRACTANT -PALATIBILITY AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  23. the essentials from fishmeal ? • SOLUTIONS • Supplementation of critical nutrients • Digestible protein/fat • Amino acid balance • Vitamins • Macro & trace minerals • Phospholipids & essential fatty acids • Blend of selected attractants • Balanced formulation • Selected fat/protein sources • Raw material knowledge • Formulative know-how • 4. Finishing (feed, feeding regime) PROBLEMS • Nutritional imbalance • Low palatability/attractiveness • Alternative protein/fat sources • Low nutrient density • Anti-nutritional factors • Cost • End user/legal acceptance • Final product quality ? AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  24. the essentials from fishmeal ? • SOLUTIONS • Nutritional supplementation • Digestible protein/fat • Amino acid balance • Vitamins • Macro & trace minerals • Phospholipids & essential fatty acids • Blend of selected attractants • Balanced formulation • Selected fat/protein sources • Raw material knowledge • Formulative know-how • 4. Finishing (feed, feeding regime) PROBLEMS FM/FO > VEG. INGR. • Nutritional imbalance • High carbohydrate • Amino acid disbalance • Liposoluble vitamins • Minerals • Lipid nutrition (fa, chol, PL) • Low palatability/attractiveness • Alternative protein/fat sources • Low nutrient density • Anti-nutritional factors • Cost • End user/legal acceptance • Final product quality ? AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  25. Supplementation critical nutrients ? ? ? AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  26. the essentials from fishmeal ? • SOLUTIONS • Supplementation of critical nutrients • Digestible protein/fat • Amino acid balance • Vitamins • Macro & trace minerals • Phospholipids & essential fatty acids • Blend of selected attractants • Balanced formulation • Selected fat/protein sources • Raw material knowledge • Formulative know-how • 4. Finishing (feed, feeding regime) PROBLEMS • Nutritional imbalance • Low palatability/attractiveness • Alternative protein/fat sources • Low nutrient density • Anti-nutritional factors • Cost • End user/legal acceptance • Final product quality ? AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  27. the essentials from fishmeal ? • SOLUTIONS • Supplementation of critical nutrients • Digestible protein/fat • Amino acid balance • Vitamins • Macro & trace minerals • Phospholipids & essential fatty acids • Blend of selected attractants • Balanced formulation • Selected fat/protein sources • Raw material knowledge • Formulative know-how • 4. Finishing (feed, feeding regime) PROBLEMS • Nutritional imbalance • Low palatability/attractiveness • Alternative protein/fat sources • Low nutrient density & dig • Anti-nutritional factors • Cost • End user/legal acceptance • Final product quality ? AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  28. Active field of research... eg EU • Researching Alternatives to Fish Oils in Aquaculture (RAFOA – 3.61 M €): www.rafoa.stir.ac.uk • Perspectives of Plant Protein use in Aquaculture (PEPPA; 2.56 M €): www.st-pee.inra.fr /ici/stpee/nut/peppa • Fish Oil and Meal Replacement (FORM) : thematic network: www.formnetwork.net AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  29. AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  30. European seabass (Kaushik et al., 2004) • FM  RapeseedM/SoybM/CGL/WGL + LYS • No FO replacement • Seabass 190 -> 330 g; 84 d AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  31. Gilthead Seabream (Sitja-Babadilla et al. 2005) • FM  RapeseedM/Lupin/CGL/WGL + AA mix • No FO replacement • Seabream 17 -> 200 g; 6 M AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  32. Turbot (Fournier et al. 2004) • FM  lupin/corngl/wheat gl + FSol+ AA mix • No FO replacement • Turbot 26-> 130 g; 84 d AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  33. Grouper (Millamena, 2002) • FM > Meatmeal/Bloodmeal • Grouper 6 g; 60 d AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  34. Litopenaeus vannamei(Amaya et al. 2007) • FM (9-0%)  SoybM/corngl • Animal protein : PoultryBM 16% (29% CP) • Ponds 0.1 ha; stocking 35/m2; aeration 30-60 hp/ha; 126 d • FM18 at harvest : 87% SR - 19.6 g - 5.8 MT/ha – FCR 1.24 – 1.11 g/wk AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  35. Atlantic salmon(Espe et al., 2006) • FM corngl/wheatgl + AA mix + FSol • no FO replacement • Salmon 330 –> 760 g; 85 d AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  36. Commercial feed formulation(vs nutritional research studies) • Reference feed = current practical feed formulation • not 100% FM protein/fat • “dynamic” formula • “non-nutritional complications” of FM/FO replacement • Cost-efficiency ! • Availability • Legal use • Acceptable for the end-user • Acceptable product quality & processing cost • Multi-factor variation (vs single factor/nutrient nutritional research) AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  37. Commercial farm conditions(vs nutritional research studies) • Main criterium: ECONOMICS over entire production cycle (vs window of growth) • Economic FCR • Time to harvest • Output per fixed production cost • Environmental conditions sub-optimal and variable (vs optimal and stable) • Evaluation parameters less precise & difficult stats (vs high statistical power) AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  38. Commercial farm conditions(vs nutritional research studies) • Interactions between feed quality and other production parameters/effects • Physical feed quality (eg water stability) • Feed availability/application • Natural feed organisms in (semi) extensive farms • Disease outbreaks & stress • Environmental conditions affecting nutritional requirements • ... AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  39. Applied R&D programme“FM/FO replacement in aquafeed”INVE Aquaculture – Caditec Testing AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  40. Effect of fishmeal replacement on performance of Gilthead seabream Data from 10 feeding trials using standard feedmill ingredients AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  41. Growth performance effect FM/FO replacement AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  42. Feed performance effect FM/FO replacement AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  43. Effect of nutritional supplementation on performance of low fish meal/fish oil diets AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007 ITECH Test Center Cadiz, 2002

  44. Effect of nutritional supplementation on performance of low fish meal/fish oil diets AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007 ITECH Test Center Cadiz, 2002

  45. L€ast €ost formulation • Example : screening for cost-efficient nutritional compensation @ 21% FM (CP67) = 30% dietary protein from FM @ 60% dietary fat from FM/FO • Seabream final GO stage 180 -> 300 g; 70 d AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  46. Seabream performance on FM30100%= performance FM60 AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  47. Seabream performance vs formula cost AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  48. Aquaculture escaping from the fish (meal/oil) trap • Fishmeal/oil supply & use: current & future • Critical issues to reduce FM/FO use • Feed performance & cost-efficiency • Sustainability • Consumer demands • Environmental impact AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  49. AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

  50. www.terram.cl AQUAFEED HORIZONS, VICTAM INTERNATIONAL, Utrecht, Netherlands; May 9-10, 2007

More Related