340 likes | 496 Views
International survey of the active management of the 3 rd stage of labor: Results from Ethiopia,Tanzania & Uganda. 9 July, 2008 AED, Washington, DC Holley Stewart. Acknowledgements. USAID Bureaus for Global Health, for Africa and for East Africa Africa’s Health in 2010 and SARA at AED
E N D
International survey of the active management of the 3rd stage of labor:Results from Ethiopia,Tanzania & Uganda 9 July, 2008AED, Washington, DC Holley Stewart
Acknowledgements • USAID Bureaus for Global Health, for Africa and for East Africa • Africa’s Health in 2010 and SARA at AED • Prevention of Postpartum Hemorrhage Initiative (POPPHI) at PATH-DC • East Central and Southern African Health Community Secretariat (ECSA) • Ministries of Health Ethiopia, Tanzania, and Uganda
The Lifetime Risk of Maternal Death in Africa is Staggering 1:2,800 1:94 1:16 1:160 The chance of a woman dying as a result of pregnancy is 150 x greater in SSA than it is in the US Source: WHO, UNICEF and UNFPA. Maternal Mortality in 2000; Lancet Neonatal Survival Series, 2005
Causes of maternal deaths in Africa Khan S et al. WHO analysis of causes of maternal death: a systematic review. The Lancet, 2006, 367: 1066-1074. 4
What is AMTSL: The ICM/FIGO 2003 Joint Statement • Prophylactic administration of a uterotonic drug • Controlled cord traction (CCT) • Uterine Massage
Benefits of AMTSL • Uterine atony accounts for 70-90% of all PPH cases • AMTSL reduces: • incidence of PPH by 60% • quantity of blood loss—thereby decreasing incidence and severity of anemia • emergencies and related cost, transport • the use of blood transfusion Active Management Physiologic Management OR and 95% CI Bristol Trial 50/846 (5.9%) 152/849 (17.9%) 3.13 (2.3-4.2) Hinchingbrooke Trial 51/748 (6.8%) 126/764 (16.5%) 2.42 (1.78-3.3)
Rationale and Objectivesfor Survey Part of a global effort to provide stakeholders with information that: • Describes current practices regarding AMTSL and identifies major barriers to its use • Can be used for the development of interventions to improve adoption and implementation of the practice of AMTSL • Can inform advocacy for promotion of skilled birth attendance
Components of the survey re: Use of AMTSL Historical Precedent, Influence of Leader, WHO, In-service training National guidelines Policy AMTSL protocol In hospital Expected behavior in hospital Presence In Pre-service training “Champions” for Use of AMTSL Woman receives AMTSL (per ICM/ FIGO Statement) Implementation Motivation to use Know- ledge Skills in AMTSL Provider Proper storage Logistics Sufficient availability of oxytocics, needles, syringe on site Amount procured Transport issues Procure- ment at hospital level Uterotonics included on Essential Drug List (oxytocin= drug of choice)
Specific research questions: • Is AMTSL formally promoted in the Standard Treatment Guidelines (STGs) in each country? • For what proportion of deliveries is AMTSL used at a national level? • How is the need for AMTSL drugs quantified at national and facility levels? • What drug is used? • At the facility level, is enough oxytocin available to allow for routine use of AMTSL? • What are the major barriers to correct use of AMTSL?
To achieve objectives, 5 types of data collection are required • Observation of deliveries • Structured interviews (national level data) • Assessment visits (pharmaceutical storage sites) • Document review • Structured interviews (health professionals responsible for delivery in selected facilities, community leaders, TBAs & women who recently delivered)
METHODS – Selection Criteria • Nationally representative sample of (public) facility-based, vaginal deliveries • Facilities (minimum of 2-3 deliveries a day) • Difficult to select health centers or hospitals with low volume of deliveries • Sample size: 23-30 facilities and ~200 deliveries • Samples were weighted for analysis • Thus far, there have been very few visits to private facilities [in Uganda only] • Health care providers responsible for managing deliveries • Consent
Policy: National level Essential Drug List (EDL), Standard Treatment Guidelines (STG) and Curriculum
Two definitions of uterotonic drug use: • CORRECT USE: Strict ICM/FIGO definition based on use of oxytocin (drug of choice), plus timing within 1 minute of delivery of fetus • ADEQUATE USE: Less strict ICM/FIGO definition based on use of oxytocin (drug of choice), plus timing within 3 minutes of delivery of fetus • “AMTSL” includes uterotonic, controlled cord traction and uterine massage
Quality of Care: Percent distribution of the timing of the administration of uterotonic drugs, Tanzania
Percent of providers with knowledge on various components of AMTSL: Tanzania
Percent of providers making correct statements on components of AMTSL, Ethiopia
Factors identified as barriers to AMTSL use • Knowledge gap • Providers’ poor understanding of steps/components of AMTSL. • Limited opportunity for in-service training • Lack of literature • Poor reading culture • lack of knowledge sharing • Staffing levels are low compared to clients load. • Difficult to provide massage every 15 mins for 2 hrs. • Inadequate supplies • Fear of retained placenta and snapping of cord
TBAs and Mx of the 3rd Stage of Labor TBAs physiologically manage the third stage of labor with: • variations in the type of “uterotonic” drugs (cold drink, herbs) • method of Mx 3rd stage (fundal pressure to deliver placenta)
PPH according to TBAs (Uganda) • Definition of PPH: more than one tumpeco (mug) or 500ml. • Causes: • full bladder • retained membranes • early or premature separation of the placenta • multi-parous women were more likely to bleed that prima gravida women
Constraints TBAs face in case of PPH • Lack of transport • Poor TBA relationships with health workers. • Lack of birth plan by the mothers • Pregnant women preference for TBA than a health unit • Lack of motivation: little pay for the service
Community involvement in PPH prevention/MX • In Uganda more women deliver at home than in the health facility (58% vs 42%). • Distance from the communities to the health units, • Inadequate facilities in the health units, • Health workers reception, • Presence of TBAs in the health facility etc • In case of obstetric emergency like PPH, the communities have to look for transport • Nakaseke - Motor Bike • Arua – Civil servant has personal car • Mbale and Kabale – Bicycle ambulance or taxi
Role of communities from H/W perspective Communities can play a leading role in: • encouraging mothers to deliver at the hospitals and health centres • transport a woman to hospital • Sensitize stakeholders about consequences of home birth
Conclusions • PPH is most common cause of maternal deaths • -Highly preventable • AMTSL is a proven intervention to reduce PPH, hence maternal mortality • -Seldom practiced, and when practiced, usually incorrectly • Since AMTSL is effective, it is imperative to promote it as a way to improve EmOC.
Recommendations • Revise the national STG & formularies • Include AMTSL in pre-service training curriculum/orientation • Low cost training approaches • Improve drug management • Monitoring & supervision • Prioritize interventions with AMTSL • High level advocacy on prevention of PPH • Develop standard in-service training material on RH/FP
Next steps • ECSA with TA from Africa 2010 will work with governments of Ethiopia, Tanzania and Uganda to update the STGs as necessary and train providers to systematically provide AMTSL • Results from all 10 countries will be presented at the FIGO conference in Kuala Lumpur in November 2008 (Benin, Ghana, Ethiopia, Tanzania, Uganda, Indonesia, El Salvador, Honduras, Guatemala and Nicaragua) • Survey tools are available for use by others on http://www.pphprevention.org/Surveytools.php