1 / 18

Public Health Prevails Over Preemption in South Carolina

Public Health Prevails Over Preemption in South Carolina. Sharon Biggers, MPH, CHES, Director Division of Tobacco Prevention and Control Bureau of Community Health and Chronic Disease Prevention S.C. Department of Health and Environmental Control. Tobacco Control Obstacles in South Carolina.

edana
Download Presentation

Public Health Prevails Over Preemption in South Carolina

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Public Health Prevails Over Preemption in South Carolina Sharon Biggers, MPH, CHES, Director Division of Tobacco Prevention and Control Bureau of Community Health and Chronic Disease Prevention S.C. Department of Health and Environmental Control

  2. Tobacco Control Obstacles in South Carolina • Heavy emphasis politically and financially on tobacco growing and production • History of tobacco farming • Loopholes in S.C. Clean Indoor Air Act • Lobbying influence • Significantly below CDC recommendations for prevention funding • Lowest cigarette tax in the United States until recently • Presumed Preemption on the books (SC Code of Laws16-17-504)

  3. A History… • Between 1977-1989, 20 ordinances with varying degrees of restrictions were passed • In 1990, a weak S.C. Clean Indoor Air Act was passed to halt the steady stream of local ordinances passing around the state • The Tobacco Industry focused efforts on passage of either explicit or implied preemption to block the authority of local governments from acting on their own

  4. Obstacles • In 1996, tobacco control advocates focused on strengthening the state’s Youth Access Law, seemingly to assure compliance with the federal Synar regulations • This opened up the state Clean Indoor Air law as well, and, through amendments, allowed the Youth Access bill to become a vehicle for preemption • The amendments passed with little opposition while tobacco control advocates were attending the ASSIST Annual Action Planning Conference

  5. Obstacles • As a result, tobacco control advocates did not pursue any action on smoke-free air laws between 1996 and 2003 • Question About Preemption Clean Indoor Air Act vs. Youth Access? • Ambiguity made advocates and municipalities uncomfortable with opening themselves up to potential lawsuits • Responsibility Issues

  6. The Tipping Point • Surgeon General’s Report, June 2006 • Sullivan’s Island, July 2006

  7. In July 2006:Sullivan’s Island led the way in South Carolina with the first smoke-free ordinance

  8. By July 1, 2007:10 ordinances had passed in SC

  9. Smoke-free Ordinances Taken To Court • Foothills Brewing Concern v. City of Greenville • Beachfront Entertainment, Inc. v. Town of Sullivan’s Island Did the trial court err in ruling that the ordinance is preempted by state law and violates the S.C. Constitution?

  10. S.C. Supreme Court Decisions • March 31, 2008—Foothills (Greenville case) “The City claims that the Ordinance is a proper exercise of municipal power because it seeks to protect citizens from second-hand smoke…(municipality may enact ordinance which promotes general welfare and preserves health). We agree.” • Sullivan’s Island decision (Sept. 2008) • Refined penalties

  11. By July 2008:15 ordinances had passed in SC

  12. Local, Local, Local • After Supreme Court decision, statewide partners decided to continue local strategy • Focus on worker health • Build more local ordinances before going for a statewide law • Any tobacco related bill is a vehicle for preemption • Cigarette tax campaign going on at same time

  13. Successful Strategies in South Carolina • Grassroots • Hospitals • School districts • Faith community • Recreational facilities • Large workplaces • Media advocacy • More earned media than paid

  14. By July 2009:27 ordinances had passed in SC

  15. By July 2010:33 ordinances had passed in SC: 28 city and five county covering more than 1.4 million people

  16. 2009 Smoke-free Air Challenge Award SC Results Speak for Themselves • SC has won the American’s for Nonsmokers Rights “Smoke-free Air Challenge Award” two consecutive years

  17. Lessons Learned • Local leaders more responsive to constituent concerns • Smoke-free opponent lobbying efforts have less sway locally than at the state level • Opportunities for explicit preemption abound on state-level bills • State level smoke-free champions don’t have political strength or understanding to defeat preemption • Local is working! • Economic and Health Impact data strengthen advocates • New challenges are being presented • Tea Party Movement/Less Government/Constitutional Rights

  18. What’s Next? • Continue to learn from each other • Each day vs. Each Occurrence Business licenses • Continue local strategy focus on large population centers • Fight off preemption • More local ordinances on horizon Second readings in three communities *Irmo, Chapin and Greer

More Related