1 / 20

Governors Forests and Climate Initiative 2011 Palangkaraya Central Kalimantan

Safeguards and REDD+: Lessons and Opportunities for Jurisdictional Programs Presentations + Open Discussion with Stakeholders. Governors Forests and Climate Initiative 2011 Palangkaraya Central Kalimantan Republic of Indonesia. Content for Safeguards Session.

edric
Download Presentation

Governors Forests and Climate Initiative 2011 Palangkaraya Central Kalimantan

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Safeguards and REDD+: Lessons and Opportunities for Jurisdictional Programs Presentations + Open Discussion with Stakeholders Governors Forests and Climate Initiative 2011 Palangkaraya Central Kalimantan Republic of Indonesia

  2. Content for Safeguards Session • PresentasidanDiskusi • Apasajamandat yang adauntukmenyusunrambu-rambupengaman (safeguards)? • Bagaimanamelibatkanmasyarakat, apa yang diharapkan? • Apasaja yang bisadijadikansumberataureferensidalammenyusunsafeguards? • Apaitu FPIC? • Presentations and Discussion • What is the mandate to develop safeguards? • Stakeholder engagement: What is expected? • What sources help guide rule-writing for safeguards? • What is FPIC?

  3. Agenda (1) • Introduction to Safeguards Peter Riggs, Ford Foundation • Developing Safeguards in Central Kalimantan Bisnart Ferry Ibie, Faculty of Agriculture, Dept of Forestry • Stakeholder Engagement • -- Indonesia Perspective – Bernadinus Steni, HuMa • -- REDD+ SES standards – Phil Franks, CARE International • --FPIC and local engagement -- Edi "Oeban" Subahani • -- Acre’s experience -- Monica Julissa, Govt of Acre (Brazil) • Discussion

  4. Agenda (2) – Following a break…. Sub-national Rule-writing for REDD+ -- Acre’s experience -- Monica Julissa, Govt of Acre (Brazil) -- KalTeng’s experience – Roundtable Discussion -- Free Discussion Final comments -- panelists On Thursday morning we will report recommendations from this session to the Plenary; looking forward to your contributions.

  5. What are Safeguards? – Origins • Started with World Bank • Created as a response to civil society concern about controversial projects • Adopted by other international institutions • Requires borrowers to mitigate risk. • Examples of risk mitigation: • Environmental and social impact assessment • Required consultations with affected communities • Restoring the livelihoods of displaced people.

  6. Evolution of Safeguards for REDD+ • From ‘Do No Harm’ to ‘Secure Benefits’ • From ‘infrastructure project’ focus to program focus • Adoption of SESA framework Social and Environmental Strategic Assessment • Safeguards as ‘proxy’ for investor risk. • Strong private-sector interest in safeguards. • Will jurisdictions ‘compete’ on safeguards for REDD+?

  7. Role of Safeguards

  8. Overview of REDD+ Safeguard Sources UNFCCC Cancun Agreement + Annex I Safeguards in FCPF + FIP: World Bank Operational Policies and Procedures REDD+ SES Standards (www.redd-standards.org) Brazil and Indonesia CSO Initiatives

  9. Cancun Agreement – REDD and Safeguards “safeguards…should be promoted and supported.” Developing countries are requested to develop: “…a system for providing information on how the safeguards referred to in Annex I…are being addressed and respected throughout [REDD implementation activities], while respecting sovereignty.”

  10. Perjanjian Cancun mengenai REDD “pengaman... harus dipromosikan dan didukung” Negara-negara berkembang diminta untuk mengembangkan: “sebuah sistem untuk memberikaninformasi mengenai bagaimana perlindungan dalam Lampiran I ... sedang ditangani dan dihormati di seluruh [pelaksanaan kegiatan REDD], sambilmenghormati kedaulatan."

  11. Overview of Safeguards – Cancun Agreement Annex 1 Safeguards: Social Environmental Sustainable forest management Biodiversity considerations Indigenous rights from UNDRIP

  12. Perjanjian Cancun Lampiran 1 Rambu-rambu pengamanan berikutharus dipromosikan dan didukung: (a) Tindakan yang melengkapiataukonsisten dengan tujuan program hutan nasional dan konvensi danperjanjianinternasional yang relevan; (b) pengelolaanhutan yang transparan dan efektif, dengan memperhatikan undang-undang nasional…;

  13. Perjanjian Cancun Lampiran 1 Rambu-rambu pengamanan berikutharus dipromosikan dan didukung: (c) Menghormati pengetahuan dan hak-hak masyarakat adat dan anggota masyarakat setempat, dengan memperhatikan kewajiban internasional terkait…..dan mencatat bahwa Majelis Umum PBB telah mengadopsi Deklarasi PBB tentang Hak-hak Masyarakat Adat Masyarakat;

  14. Perjanjian Cancun Lampiran 1 Rambu-rambu pengamanan berikutharus dipromosikan dan didukung: (d) partisipasi penuh dan efektif stakeholder yang relevan, khususnya, masyarakat adat dan komunitas lokal,…;

  15. Perjanjian Cancun Lampiran 1 Rambu-rambu pengamanan berikutharus dipromosikan dan didukung: (e) Tindakan tersebutkonsisten dengan konservasi hutan alam dan keanekaragaman hayati… mendorong perlindungan dan konservasi hutan alam dan layanan ekosistem mereka, untuk meningkatkan manfaat sosial dan lingkungan lainnya; ....

  16. Cancun Agreement– Safeguards and Indigenous Rights UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) – …is included in the Cancun Agreement section on REDD …UNDRIP enshrines ‘Free, Prior, and Informed Consent’ (FPIC)

  17. Safeguards in World Bank FCPF + FIP World Bank Operational Policies and Procedures • Environmental Assessment • Natural Habitats • Forests • Physical and Cultural Resources • Indigenous Peoples • Involuntary Resettlement

  18. Other REDD+ safeguard sources…. REDD+ SES Standards (www.redd-standards.org) Brazil CSO Initiatives Indonesia CSO Initiatives (is this Tony Brunello?)

  19. Design considerations for jurisdictions • Takes into account Cancun Agreement Annex I? • Good stakeholder process in place? • Easy to implement? Easy to monitor? Enforce? • Conforms to current state legal framework? • Quality of indicators? Guidance for investors? • Concern/provision for indigenous rights?

  20. More design questions Voluntary guidance….. or mandatory requirements? Minimal standards…….or global best practice? Self-reporting on compliance with safeguards….. or require external (third-party) verification? Project level safeguards…..and/or jurisdictional-level? Design your own system.....or use existing standards?

More Related