1 / 17

Realism

International Cooperation and the Study of International Institutions IIR – Graduate Institute 2 March 2010. Realism. Use international law for the promotion of national interests (Morgenthau 1948); “arenas for acting our power relations” (Evans and Wilson 1992)

edric
Download Presentation

Realism

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. International Cooperation and the Study of International InstitutionsIIR – Graduate Institute2 March 2010

  2. Realism • Use international law for the promotion of national interests (Morgenthau 1948); “arenas for acting our power relations” (Evans and Wilson 1992) • International institutions are epiphenomenal to state power and interest (Carr 1964) • Downs, Rocke and Barsoom (1996): Deep cooperation requires enforcement • International Institutions leading to pareto-inefficient outcomes (Gruber 2000) / “go-it-alone” power

  3. Liberalism Rational Functionalism (Neo-Liberal Institutionalism) Early Work Puzzle: Cooperation is possible in an anarchic system Question: What is the role of IOs? Answer: Institutions help overcome collective action problems, high transaction costs, tackle information asymmetries and help enforce contracts (Keohane 1984)

  4. The analogy: used car market • Inspiration: Georg Akerlof • The market for lemons (1970) • Market of used cars without car-dealer • Asymmetric information • Deals possible, but do not materialize • Consumers’ mistrust, “good cars” don’t enter the market… • Institution (car-dealer) is beneficial for seller and buyer…

  5. Discussion questions 3 and 4 Is the market analogy of supply and demand a good entry point into the discussion on the emergence of institutions? How has the liberal approach to international institutions changed over time?

  6. From the British School to Social Constructivism • International society: a group of states that have established by dialog and consent common rules and institutions for the conduct of their relations, and recognize their common interest in maintaining these arrangements (Bull and Watson 1984). • Shared goals (Bull) vs cultural unity (Wight) • International institutions define who the players are in a particular situation and how they define their roles (Onuf 1989) • Analysis of international institutions that takes nothing for granted

  7. Discussion question 1 • Are there situations in which international institutions could “spontaneously” emerge?

  8. Discussion question 2 • How can game theory help understand or predict policy outcomes in international politics?

  9. Free riding temptation: the PD

  10. Inhibiting fear: assurance games

  11. Where to meet: co-ordination games

  12. Mixed situations: e.g. chicken, called bluff

  13. A realist using game theory (Drezner)

  14. Great powers and the rest of the world

  15. Do we need institutions? • Axelrod • Cooperation strategies (Tit-for-Tat) • PD with indefinite rounds • Cooperation opportunities increase with the shadow of the future

  16. The role of institutions?

  17. Discussion question 5 What are the difficulties in thinking about institutional effects?

More Related