410 likes | 709 Views
Lee County EMS Customer Satisfaction Survey Design for Six Sigma (DFSS). February 23, 2007. Team Members Lt. Chris Sutton Lt. Tom Pillsy FTO Jim McFee EMT Steve Lupe Admin. Asst. Ruth Boonstra. Team Facilitators Capt. Art Garcia Lt. Todd Bardell Sponsor Chief Kim Dickerson
E N D
Lee County EMSCustomer Satisfaction SurveyDesign for Six Sigma (DFSS) February 23, 2007
Team Members Lt. Chris Sutton Lt. Tom Pillsy FTO Jim McFee EMT Steve Lupe Admin. Asst. Ruth Boonstra Team Facilitators Capt. Art Garcia Lt. Todd Bardell Sponsor Chief Kim Dickerson Capt. Art Garcia Project Team
Lee County EMSMission & Vision Mission Statement To provide the highest quality out-of-hospital emergency medical care and transportation for the residents and visitors of Lee county, Florida. Our highly trained professionals use the best technology to meet the needs of those who require assistance. Vision Statement To be a leader in our profession and serve as a role model for other emergency medical services agencies and is an organization that people are proud to be associated with.
Define Phase • How do we know how we are doing? • Does our service meet the publics expectation’s? • How do we go about measuring this? • Does our current Customer Satisfaction Survey (CSS) collect what we need? • Are we delivering it to the customer in a way to get a response?
Define Phase Problem Statement • CSS shows voice of the Organization • CSS has a low response rate • CSS uses a single methodology • CSS does not appear to meet the QI needs of the organization • CSS content and design not representative of DPS/LCEMS intent to exceed customer expectations • Completed CSS forms are not being processed consistently or in a timely fashion • CSS results/responses do not receive consistent follow-up
Project Impact Goal: • To define the DPS/LCEMS mission and commitment to exceed customer expectations • To design and implement a CSS process that allows LCEMS to identify exemplary customer service and detect and eliminate detrimental performance and practices
Project Scope • In Scope • Customers who were transported to a Lee County hospital • Out of Scope • Refusals, minors, deceased
Analyze Phase • Poor return • Font? • Color? • Bill? • No other survey methods currently being used
Improve Phase • Voice of the agency • Director of Public Safety • Deputy Director of Public Safety • Deputy Director of Public Safety, EMS • Operations Chief EMS • Quality Improvement/Quality Assurance Manager
Improve Phase • Voice of the customer • Other validated, existing customer satisfaction surveys • Multnomah County, OR • Stanislaus County, CA • Further to be determined by focus groups
Improve Phase • HIPAA • County Attorney office contacted for review of project material for patient confidentiality issues
Improve Phase • Mail Surveys • Face to Face • Focus Groups • Telephone Surveys
Improve Phase • Questions rated on a 1-4 scale • 4 being the most desirable rating • 1 being the least desirable rating • Evaluated whether the public recognized who we are • Evaluated whether the hospital destination is customer choice or not; and whether it was explained to them • Determine potential focus group participation
Improve Phase • Mail Survey • Improve legibility of questions • Improve formatting of questions • Standardize the responses to facilitate evaluating responses • Added a cover letter (February only) • Additional cost for color • Additional cost for extra page • Should it go out with the BILL
Improve Phase Larger font Standard Responses
Improve Phase - Pilot • Mail Survey • On Going
Improve Phase - Pilot • Face to Face • Top 3 questions from mail survey • District Supervisor assistance • Minimum of 2 a day at area hospitals • 44 interviews done
Improve Phase - Pilot • Focus groups determined to be difficult to do in pilot (to be used at a later time) • Potential participation to be determined in phone interviews • Use in the control phase
Improve Phase - Pilot • Telephone Surveys • Same as mail survey • Contacted all transported patients who were in the project scope
Improve Phase - Pilot • Goal of 50 completed telephone surveys • 134 calls were made to get 35 responses • No family member were allowed to answer for the patient • No Minors were allowed to participate
Improve Phase Shows number of surveys returned Shows average of responses per question “The emergency service personnel were courteous and respectful throughout my experience”: 1 2 3 4 Strongly Disagree Disagree Agree Strongly disagree Average: 2.92 Show that the response to this question, overall, was between Disagree and Agree
Control Phase • To be turned over to Chief Dickerson and Capt. Garcia
What we found out 1 - Strongly disagree 2 - Disagree 3 - Agree 4 – Strongly Agree Average 3.5 • Face to Face
What we found out • Phone Survey
What we found out 1 2 3 4 Strongly Disagree Disagree Agree Strongly Agree
What we found out Very Quick Quick Slow Very Slow Strongly Agree Agree Disagree Strongly Disagree
What we found out Very Clean Clean Dirty Very Dirty Strongly Agree Agree Disagree Strongly Disagree
What we found out Strongly Agree Agree Disagree Strongly Disagree Strongly Agree Agree Disagree Strongly Disagree
What we found out Very Good Good Fair Poor
Recommendations • Organize focus groups quarterly • Evaluate mail survey • Continue face to face interviews when possible • Continue phone surveys monthly • Consider professional marketing agency • Share results with agency