270 likes | 291 Views
This outline discusses sustainable water supply choices for residential areas in Auckland, including mains supply vs. rain tanks, settlement patterns impact, life cycle analysis, energy consumption, and CO2 emissions.
E N D
Sustainable choices for residential water supply in Auckland Nalanie Mithraratne & Robert Vale Centre for Urban Ecosystem Sustainability Landcare Research
Outline • Mains supply vs. rain tanks • Impact of settlement patterns • Water system in average house • Conclusions
LCA of mains supply • System boundary • Initial construction • Maintenance/ replacements - 1% of the total length of pipes/year replaced • Operational requirements • Analysis period – 100 years
Bulk supply system LCE LCCO2
Local supply network - 2005 • CLS - cement lined steel • CI - cast iron • PE - polyethylene • AC - asbestos cement
Mains supply performance • Energy intensity = 2.11MJ/m3(Range 2.08 - 2.27MJ/m3) • CO2 emissions factor = 0.128kgCO2/m3(Range 0.126 – 0.146kgCO2/m3) Mains water supply contribution, • Life cycle energy = 86GJ/house • CO2 emissions = 4.9 tonnes CO2/house
Impact of Settlement Pattern Roberton site • Residential density 14units/ha • Parallelogram bounded by roads
Impact of Settlement Pattern Sandringham site • Residential density 17units/ha • Road across the site
Impact of Settlement Pattern Freeman’s Bay site • Residential density 23units/ha • Trapezoid, open spaces within
Impact of Settlement Pattern Ponsonby site • Residential density 24units/ha • Rectangle bounded by roads
Mains supply vs. Rain tanks • Wastewater and stormwater • Mains - more, rain tanks - reduced • Water quality • Mains - Grade A, rain tanks – untreated • Water supply volume • Mains - 370m3, rain tanks - varies
Rain harvesting system [Source: Marley 2005]
Building Industry Advisory Council House (BIAC) Plan [Source: Baird and Chan (1983)]
Building Industry Advisory Council House (BIAC) Section & Front Elevation [Source: Baird and Chan (1983)]
ASSUMPTIONS • Useful life of NZ houses is 100 years. • Living room faces north. • Space heating: Whole house, temp 18oC, 2 schedules • Water heating: varies with water volume.
Conclusions • Consumption significantly impacts the system choice. • Use of mains supply in smaller houses (>150m2) and rain harvesting in larger houses is better for the environment. • Mains supply is cheaper initially but costly in life cycle terms. • Water supply is negligible in terms of total environmental performance of house.