180 likes | 406 Views
GCAA Tier 4 Specifications. BP Lubricants USA Inc Geno Capitoni National Accounts Manger. History – Emissions Reductions. Tier 1 phased in from 1996 Tier 2 phased in from 2001 Tier 3 phased in from 2006 Meeting the limits included; Engine design Piston ring position EGR Turbo design
E N D
GCAATier 4 Specifications BP Lubricants USA Inc Geno Capitoni National Accounts Manger
History – Emissions Reductions • Tier 1 phased in from 1996 • Tier 2 phased in from 2001 • Tier 3 phased in from 2006 • Meeting the limits included; • Engine design • Piston ring position • EGR • Turbo design • Fuel injection timing • Electronics • Fuel quality
Tier 4 Standards • Introduced in May 2004 • Phased in from 2008 – 2013 for categories <11hp thru 74 hp • Phased in from 2012 – 2013 for categories 75 hp thru 175 hp • Phased in from 2011 – 2014 for categories 176 hp thru 750 hp • 50% compliance by 2013 • 100% compliance by December 30, 2014 • Emissions reductions of NOx and PM reduction by 90% + • Closed crankcase ventilation allowable, emissions measured and added to exhaust emissions for total engine emissions • Emissions must be met over the entire “useful life of the engine”
Emissions Time Period – Engine Useful Life • EPA requires the application of deterioration factors (DFs) to all engines covered by the rule. • The DF is a factor applied to the certification emission test data to represent emissions at the end of the useful life of the engine.
EOM Answers to Tier 4 Lower Emissions • Diesel Oxidation Catalyst • Particulate Filter • Increase % Cooled EGR • ACERT technology • Particulate Filter w/ advanced regeneration • Electronics • Turbo Charger Configurations • No announcement of SCR • Fuel Quality
Retrofitting Existing Equipment • No requirements for retrofitting existing engines or equipment • No restrictions on the sale of used equipment • The estimated costs for added emission controls for the vast majority of equipment was estimated at 1-3% as a fraction of total equipment price • 175 hp dozer that costs approximately $230,000 would cost up to $6,900 to add the advanced emission controls and to design the dozer to accommodate the modified engine (source EPA)
Fuel Quality • June 2007 - 500 PPM max fuel sulfur • June 2010 – 15 PPM max fuel sulfur (ULSD) for off road • June 2012 – 15 PPM max fuel sulfur (ULSD) for locomotive and marine use
Biodiesel Fuel Benefits • Check with OEM for approved “B” blend, most at B5 (some at B20) • PM and HC emissions are toxic / carcinogenic • B100 reduces 90% of these air toxins • B20 reduces air toxins by 20-40% • Depends on fuel quality • Depends on biodiesel quality • Improved cetane value • Improved lubricity for pumps • Lower soot levels (more complete burn)
Biodiesel Fuel • Higher boiling points causes fuel dilution in the engine oil • High biodiesel gelation point causes thicker oil at start up • Can cause faster degradation of non-premium engine oils • Higher cost per gallon • ~15% lower BTU value • 8% less energy per gallon • 1% - 2% less fuel economy • Cold weather performance • Premium winter blend -36F cloud point • B20 to the winter mix resulted in a -4F cloud point for the blend • High in solvency • Fuel filters may be affected pending fuel system / storage tank cleanliness (varnish) • Blends higher than B20 should use new equipment (tanks, plumbing, pumps) • Increase of NOx by ~2% • Oxidation stability less than #2 diesel fuel
Recent Test Runs with B20 • National BioDiesel Board / Engine Manufacturers Association • API CJ-4 oils used • CAT C-13 test • 500 hr test • Piston deposits • Oil consumption • Cummins ISB test • 350 hr test • Cam lobe • Cam follower wear • Mack T12 test • 300 hr test • Liner / Bearing / Ring wear
Recent Test Runs with B20 • National BioDiesel Board / Engine Manufacturers Association • CAT C-13 test • Top groove and top land deposits within pass/fail vs 100% diesel • Second ring land deposits reached top end of pass/fail limits • Oil consumption elevated, but within pass/fail limits • Two cold stuck rings reported, but not in the area of increased deposits • Cummins ISB test • Acceptable results within pass/fail limits vs 100% diesel • Mack T12 test • Lead wear limits were exceeded • TAN and Oxidation was significantly higher
B20 Biodiesel Bend Contains biomass-based diesel or biodiesel in quantities between 5 percent and 20 percent B20 Biodiesel Bend B100 Biodiesel Contains biomass-based diesel or biodiesel contains 100 percent biodiesel Federal Labeling Requirements • December 16, 2008 the Federal Trade Commission required the use of retail labels to inform consumers of the percent of biodiesel in the fuel • Labeling requirements are based on the concentration levels of biodiesel in the “finished” fuel • Less than B5 blends - No label is required • B5 < BXX B20 - Label are required but are NOTrequired to provide the exact percentage ofbiodiesel in this range • B20 < BXX < B100 - A specific blend designationis required (e.g. B25, B50, B99, etc.) • B100 - The heading must display “B100”
State Labeling Requirements • State requirements will vary from state to state • For Example: Washington state requires: • Less than B2: No label is required • B2-B5 blended fuel must be labeled as: “Contains up to 5% biodiesel” • Greater than B5 must be labeled with the volume percentage of biodiesel
Financial Incentives to Use Biodiesel • Federal mandates • 500 million gal B100 used per year in 2009 • 1 billion gal by 2012 • Federal tax incentives • Biodiesel excise tax credit: $1.00 or $0.50 per gal, depending feedstock source, for B100 (ends 2010) • 30% credit for cost to install B20 (or E85) refueling stations (ends 2009) • State mandates • Minnesota: B5 in every gallon of fuel sold by mid 2009 • B2: Washington (2008), Massachusetts (2010) • State tax incentives - About 25 provide some incentives • IL: B1 – B10 partial state sales tax exemption; > B10, 100% exemption (6.25%)
Emissions Reductions Results • Emissions reductions estimated at 738,000 tons of NOx • Emissions reductions estimated at 129,000 tons of PM after full compliance • Estimated equivalent of parking 35,000,000 annually • Estimated 12,000 premature deaths will be prevented annually by 2030
Sources • http://www.dieselnet.com/ • Cational Biodiesel Board http://www.biodiesel.org/ • EPA http://www.epa.gov/cleandiesel • EPA http://www.epa.gov/nonroad-diesel/2004fr/420r04008.pdf • Technology & Maintenance Council presentation