160 likes | 402 Views
Insolvency Regime in India. Concept of
E N D
1. Bankruptcy Restructuring in India
29 November 1999
KISHORE SONI
Chief Executive
SONI INDUSTRIAL RESTRUCTURING CONSULTANTS NEW DELHI
2. Insolvency Regime in India Concept of industrial sickness
Sickness worse than Bankruptcy- defined based on net worth and not by debt default
Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 - SICA
Board for Industrial & Financial Reconstruction (BIFR)
4. SICA definition -- its problems Either SICA catches it too late
5. SICA definition -- its problems BIFR either identifies extremely sick firms or mistakenly declares non-sick companies as sick
Asymmetry between lender and borrower -- at the expense of lender
Lender: NPA after 180-days default
Borrower: NPA after net worth ? 0
6. BIFR delays: Jan 97 to Mar 98
7. Pending cases at BIFR
8. Where does BIFR stand? Objective: bad managers, like bad currency to be kept out of circulation
Facts speak otherwise
Total cases disposed 1229
Mergers 94 (8%)
Change in management 39 (3%)
9. Where does BIFR stand? Automatic suspension of all legal proceedings
Average delay: > 3 years
More than 18% got illegitimate stay till the case got rejected
Debtor in possession
10. APR violations
then and now
11. Agenda for Reforms Early detection
Speed
Voluntary references
Facilitation and quick arbitration
12. Towards a new SICA Definition to be altered to debt default
Onus on company
Time bound negotiations
If negotiation fails, referred to BIFR
Appointment of administrator by BIFR
Invitation for a two-part bid
Creditors vote on the bids
13. An alternative
14. A Caveat Indian law requires liquidation by courts which confirm the Hindu belief that there is life after death
15. Reform or Perish... No. of references to BIFR shooting up since 1996
16. Reform or Perish... Bank credit in sick industries increased by 14% to Rs157 billion as on March 1998
NPAs at Rs586 billion as on March 1999
This massive gap demonstrates urgency for quick reforms of bankruptcy laws