190 likes | 589 Views
Fuel Management. Simon Stuart. Squadron 80. San Jose, CA. Video. Would you fly this airline?. Courtesy AOPA. 2. Fuel Starvation & Exhaustion. “ Engine Failure: A condition which occurs when all fuel tanks mysteriously become filled with air.“. Fuel Starvation
E N D
Fuel Management Simon Stuart Squadron 80 San Jose, CA
Video Would you fly this airline? Courtesy AOPA 2
Fuel Starvation & Exhaustion “Engine Failure: A condition which occurs when all fuel tanks mysteriously become filled with air.“ • Fuel Starvation • Engine cannot get available fuel • Selected tank runs dry • Contaminant blockage • Pump failure (Esp. low wing aircraft) • Forced landing inevitable unless prompt action taken. • Usually pilot error • Fuel Exhaustion • All tanks “dry” • Forced landing inevitable • Almost always pilot error 3
Do pilots just “Forget”? • Sometimes, but frequently the cause is: • An error in preflight planning • Lack of enroute monitoring • Too hurried to divert and refuel • No pilot departs anticipating an accident. 4
Invulnerable Attitudes “Range: Usually about 10 miles beyond the point where all fuel tanks fill with air.” “It won’t happen to me.” “That gauge can’t be right.” “This isn’t happening!” 5
Three Accidents per Week… • Most do not show up as NTSB reports • Databases: • NTSB: http://www.ntsb.gov/ntsb/query.asp • FAA Accident / Incident Data System (AIDS): http://www.asias.faa.gov/ • AOPA Fuel management Mishap Map: http://www.aopa.org/asf/ntsb/fuelmap.cfm • NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (ASRS): http://asrs.arc.nasa.gov/ 6
NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System “If the pilot survives the accident, you'll never find out what really happened.” — Doug Jeanes • The ASRS: First hand pilot accounts • Different from NTSB reports • Learn from the mistakes of others • http://asrs.arc.nasa.gov/ • Report Sets: http://asrs.arc.nasa.gov/search/reportsets.html • Fuel Reports: http://asrs.arc.nasa.gov/docs/rpsts/fuel.pdf • Example: ACN: 849661. “A CL65 Captain laments the low fuel loads that are routinely being used by dispatchers at his airline”. Assessment: Primary Problem: Company Policy 7
Determining Fuel Levels • Traditional dipstick method • Analog fuel gauges • Only required to be accurate when empty • Digital fuel gauges • Fuel totalizers • Accurate to 1/10th gallon • Depends upon pilot setting after adding fuel • Glass Cockpit (e.g. G1000) Features • Range rings • Annunciations 8
“Know Thy Airplane” • “Many pilots run afoul of fuel management when switching • between aircraft with different fuel systems.” • Citabria 7ECA. High wing. Gravity fed. Off/On selector. No fuel pump • Cessna 182T. 13 sumps. 3 ways of confirming fuel levels during preflight. Totalizer accuracy • Bonanza 35. Many variations and some complex fuel systems. Up to 5 tanks. Left tank venting on some models • CG moves rearward. Possible landing out of CG envelope • Low fuel takeoff limits, 6g unusable 9
How Much Fuel Do You Need? • FAA Regulations • General (Part 91). E.g. “Going up in Uncle Bob’s plane” • Commuter & On Demand (Part 135). E.g. “Aspen Air Charter” • Scheduled Air Carrier (Part 121). E.g. “United Airlines” • Non-FAA Overlays • Airline Policy • Civil Air Patrol Requirements. E.g. “1 hour left? Land and refuel.” • FAA Factors Influencing Reserves • Day, Night, VFR, IFR, Alternates • Other Factors To Consider • Mountains, Water, Icing, Altitude, Headwinds, Traffic • Personal Minimums • Arguably the most important • Developed from experience • Create a “Risk Profile” for the flight 10
Can You Carry Too Much Fuel? "The only time an aircraft has too much fuel on board is when it is on fire.” — Sir Charles Kingsford Smith • well, not always… • Additional fuel affects TAS only marginally. • Increasing weight 440lbs to MGTW in a Mooney 201 reduces cruise speed by around 5 knots (3%). • Additional fuel affects takeoff distances and rate of climb significantly. • A Cessna 182T departing Tahoe at 65F at MGTW vs. 400lbs lighter will require an additional 1500’ to get to 50’ AGL. • The ROC on a Mooney 201 would decrease by 50%. 11
AOPA Recommendations • Flight Planning • Know your airplane • Give yourself an hour's reserve • Be realistic with routing • Check fuel availability • Remember aircraft performance • Note color and smell • Let water settle • Sump early, sump often • Dispose of fuel properly • Check for leaks • Verify quantity • In Flight • Check groundspeed • Lean and mean • Switch tanks regularly • Be prepared to divert • Tell ATC http://www.aopa.org/asf/hotspot/fuel_check.html 12
Personal Experiences • Rapidly venting fuel. Palo Alto. Citabria. • Inaccurate gauge readings near the end of a 500nm cross country. San Jose. Cessna 182. • Broken gauge resulting in fuel starvation on final. Reid-Hillview. Cessna 172. • Over a quart of rainwater in a tank after a heavy overnight downpour. Oceanside. Bonanza P35. • High fuel burn due to low altitude plus headwinds resulting in diversion. Los Banos. Cessna 170. Fortunately, all these situations ended with uneventful non- emergency landings. But they can happen to anyone. 13
Notable Fuel Related Accidents • Airlines • United 173. DC-8. Portland • Tuninter 1153. ATR-72. Tunisia • Charter • Pel-Air. Westwind. Norfolk Island • Bay Area Aircraft • N1857H. PA-28. Firebaugh • N2805E. Aeronca 7BC. Half Moon Bay • N9547D. PA-22. San Jose RHV • N5479A. C210. San Jose RHV • Other • N7589S. Cessna 182. Texas • Amelia Earhart 14
Case Study: N16EJ • May 2000, Pennsylvania • Two Professional Pilots. Captain 8,500 hours TT • British Aerospace Jetstream 3101 • PIC fails to check fuel prior to departure • Fuel exhaustion after cleared for the approach in IMC • 19 Fatalities 15
Other Suggestions • Special diligence required for expected IMC at the destination airport, especially with alternates. • Resist passenger pressure – get-there-itis. • CAP Aircrew: Check the gauges yourself. Prior to departure, politely ask the Mission Pilot key questions. Expect concise answers. It keeps professionalism high. • Sump carefully. Wait for additional fuel to settle. Failure to do so could easily result in a fatal situation on takeoff. 16
Additional Insight • AOPA Fuel Safety Advisor • http://www.aopa.org/asf/publications/sa16.pdf • AOPA Fuel Safety Brief • http://www.aopa.org/asf/publications/SB04.pdf • Pelican’s Perch #7 • http://www.warmkessel.com/jr/flying/td/jd/7.jsp 17
Summary When it comes to fuel, “Getting it wrong” has consequences ranging from embarrassing to fatal. Be methodical. Remain aware. Land if uncertain. 18