1 / 30

The Challenge of Biometrics

The Challenge of Biometrics. Laurence Edge. Proposition. Agenda. Biometrics – some definitions Technical background What are the issues? Solutions?. Definition - 1.

elliot
Download Presentation

The Challenge of Biometrics

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The Challenge of Biometrics Laurence Edge

  2. Proposition

  3. Agenda • Biometrics – some definitions • Technical background • What are the issues? • Solutions?

  4. Definition - 1 • “a general term for technologies that permit matches between a ‘live’ digital image of a part of the body and a previously recorded image of the same part usually indexed to personal or financial information” (Alterman - 2003)

  5. Definition - 2 • “measuring relevant attributes of living individuals or populations to identify active properties or unique characteristics” (Mordini - 2004)

  6. Definition – 3 (mine!) • unique physical characteristic capable of being matched automatically • possible to match at acceptably low rates of error • possible to perform automatic one-to-many identification matching, with a high accuracy (near 100%) against a reference database consisting of tens or hundreds of millions of records; • accepted in a court of law as a legal proof of identity

  7. Authentication • Identification – selection of one from many e.g. fingerprints from a crime scene • Verification – “I am who I claim to be” e.g. passports or ID cards

  8. The Technologies - Types • Fingerprints • Hand/Finger geometry • Voice print • Signatures • Facial Recognition • Vein Patterns • Iris Recognition • Retina Scans • DNA • Others

  9. The Technologies - Concepts • Generic method • Accuracy • General concerns

  10. Generic Method - Enrolment • Measure • Generate template • Record

  11. Generic Method - Operation Biometrics at the Frontiers: Assessing the Impact on Society (2005)

  12. Accuracy? Biometric Product Testing: Final report, Issue 1.0 (2001): CESG/BWG

  13. Performance Improvements- Facial Recognition Phillips et al. “FRVT 2006 and ICE 2006 Large-Scale Results”. (2007)

  14. 7 Pillars of (biometric) Wisdom • Universality • Uniqueness • Permanence • Collectability • Performance • Acceptability • Circumvention EC report: Biometrics at the Frontiers: Assessing the Impact on Society (2005)

  15. 7 Pillars of (biometric) Wisdom

  16. The Technologies - Challenges • Spoofing / Mimicry / Residual Images • Usability • Accessibility • Hygiene • Safety • Secondary use • Public Perception

  17. DNA • Physical sample required • Slow to process • Lowest FAR & FRR • FTE & FTA of 0%

  18. DNA – Uniqueness?

  19. DNA – Acceptability? • 97% were happy to include a photograph • 79% fingerprints • 62% eye recognition (no distinction was made between iris and retina scans) • 41% approved of the inclusion of DNA details Hiltz, Han, Briller. “Public Attitudes towards a National Identity "Smart Card:" Privacy and Security Concerns” (2003)

  20. DNA – Foolproof? • Scene of crime samples in particular may be contaminated, degraded, and misinterpreted (especially if mixed). Human errors (e.g. sample mix-ups) will occur. • Need for corroborating evidence. • Expanding databases could lead to an over-reliance on ‘cold hits’. • Increased potential for ‘framing’ of suspects? • “The forensic use of Bioinformation: ethical issues” Nuffield Council on Bioethics (2007)

  21. Privacy Assessment - 1

  22. Privacy Assessment - 2 International Biometric Group – www.bioprivacy.org

  23. Risk Assessment - DNA

  24. Legal Background • Enabling Legislation • Constraints • Uses and Abuses • Challenges

  25. Enabling Legislation • NDNAD's • UK – 3.8 million samples by Jan 2007 (6%) • Canada • Australia • NZ • USA • Prum: “Member States shall open and keep national DNA analysis files for the investigation of criminal offences”

  26. Constraints • Privacy • Human Rights • US Constitution • Common Law • Privacy Acts • Data Protection Law

  27. Challenges • UK – via HRA 1998 Articles 8 and/or 14 • R v Marper – now at ECHR (27 Feb 2008) • US – via 4th Amendment • US v Kincade • Johson v Quander • Canada – via s.8 of CCRF • R v Rodgers

  28. Uses and Abuses • Collection and Retention • Forensic DNAD's • Other DNAD's • Data Sharing • Privacy Challenges • Evidence • Scope Creep • Ethics - What is identity?

  29. Conclusion • ID fraud becomes worse if there is a single strong identifier • Biometrics do not offer non-repudiation • Biometrics should be confined to smart cards or encrypted if on databases • Biometrics are useless once compromised

  30. Questions laurence.edge@resultex.co.nz

More Related