300 likes | 520 Views
The primary prevention of hepatitis C among injectors: model projections of the impact of opiate substitution therapy, needle exchange and antiviral therapy. Matt Hickman Natasha Martin, Peter Vickerman, Daniela De Angelis. Primary Prevention of HCV. Epidemiology Intervention Effectiveness
E N D
The primary prevention of hepatitis C among injectors: model projections of the impact of opiate substitution therapy, needle exchange and antiviral therapy Matt Hickman Natasha Martin, Peter Vickerman, Daniela De Angelis
Primary Prevention of HCV • Epidemiology • Intervention Effectiveness • Modelling Impact of Prevention & HCV treatment • Case Finding - Implications
Public Health Importance • In UK liver disease is 5th commonest cause of death • In UK HCV/HBV 2nd most important cause • Worldwide HCV infection causes ~1/4 liver disease (over 350,000 deaths per year)
UK: Majority of chronic HBV infection results from the migration of HBV carriers 2007: Estimated annual new chronic HBV infections in England and Wales Estimates of chronic HBV infections Chronic HBV infection arising from acute HBV infection in resident population 269 per year Hepatitis B Foundation estimate 350000 UK HBV infections Department of Health estimate 300000 250000 200000 150000 Chronic HBV infection imported by people who acquired infection prior to migration 6,571 per year 100000 50000 0 Hahné Set al. J Clin Virol 2004;29:211–20. Hepatitis B Foundation UK. Rising Curve: Chronic Hepatitis B Infection in the UK (2007)
Estimated number of people infected with HCV: E&W ~15,000 White; 11,000 (IPB) Sweeting et al. Biostatistics 2008; De Angelis et al, Statistics in Med Research 2009; Ross et al EJPH 2011
Intervention effectiveness: Emerging evidence that ost and NSP reducing hcv incidence during exposure Turner Addiction 2011 doi: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2011.03515.x
Pooling UK evidence on intervention impact Turner Addiction 2011 doi: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2011.03515.x
Intervention Effect Turner Addiction 2011 doi: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2011.03515.x
But what about the effect on HCV prevalence? England and Wales data • 20 million syringes distributed annually • 5 fold increase in methadone prescription in last 10 years • BUT: little impact on HCV prevalence Sweeting, M., et al., AJE 2009. 170: 352-60
Can scaling up the coverage of existing interventions reduce HCV prevalence?
Modeling transitions between OST and NSP & transmission of HCV Vickerman et al under review
Impact of changing coverage of OST and NSP from 50%: 0%, 60%, 70%, 80%
Implications • NSP and OST can reduce HCV incidence • Introducing OST & NSP will avert infections • OST is critical • BUT unclear whether alone NSP and OST could be lead to substantial reductions HCV prevalence • In UK sites already have high coverage sustained interventions & 40% chronic HCV prevalence in IDU • Other prevention options needed • Could HCV treatment have an impact?
Could scaling up HCV treatment have an impact on HCV prevention?
HCV antiviral treatment: Barriers among active IDUs • Antiviral treatment effective (~60%) for curing HCV infection and approved for active injecting drug users (IDUs) • BUT few currently being treated (<1%) • Perceived reluctance/concern over: • Non-completion/compliance • Re-infection following treatment
DYNAMIC HCV TRANSMISSION MODEL Non-responder infected IDUs Allow for reinfection Antiviral treatment New Injectors Uninfected active IDUs HCV-infected active IDUs Cease/die Outcome: Impact on HCV prevalence Infection Martin et al. J Hepatology 2011; J Theoretical Biology 2011
PREVENTION IMPACT RESULTS: PREVALENCE REDUCTIONS AT 10 YEARS • Population of 3500 IDUs, 1400 chronic infections • 70 treated annually (20 per 1000 IDUs) • 30% reduction by 2022 (40% 28%) • 140 treated annually (40 per 1000 IDUs) • 58% reduction by 2022 (40% 17%) Martin et al. J Hepatology 2011
Model projections through time (5, 10, 20 years) annually treating 20 per 1000 IDUs • Swift and substantial reductions at low prevalence • Significant reductions even at high prevalence • 3500 IDUs, 1400 infected (40% prevalence), 70 treated/yr • 15% reduction in 5 years (4034%) • 30% reduction in 10 years (4028%) • Halved in 20 years (40 20%) Martin et al. J Hepatology 2011
MODEL FORMULATION • Extend ‘infected’ state to include HCV disease progression stages • Attach health care costs and quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) to each state
COST-EFFECTIVENESS RESULTS Martin et al Hepatology 2012
INCREMENTAL COST PER QALY GAINED:REDUCED TREATMENT SUCCESS RATES FOR IDU UK cost-effectiveness threshold Martin et al Hepatology 2012
NICE ECONOMIC ANALYSIS: WAYS TO PROMOTE/OFFER TESTING OF HBV/HCV IN AT RISK POPULATIONS
INTERVENTIONS TO PROMOTE HCV TESTING AMONG IDU • Introducing HCV dried blood spot testing in prisons and specialist addiction services • Pilot 1 UK cluster randomized controlled trial • Increased testing rate by 2.63 and 3.61-fold in addiction services and prisons, respectively. • General practitioner (GP) education and remuneration for targeted testing of former-IDU aged 30-54 years old • Cullen et al. 20112 non-randomized controlled trial in Scotland • Increased testing rate by 3.40-fold, also increased proportion positive HCV tests (yield) 1Hickman et al. 2008 J Viral Hep 15(4):250-254 2 Cullen et al. 2011 J Pub Health (Ox) Epub
INTERVENTIONS TO PROMOTE HCV/HBV TESTING AMONG UK MIGRANTS • Less evidence for effective interventions in this group. • Modelled hypothetical GP intervention • Based on Lewis et al 20111: Pakistani/British Pakistani people registered at GPs written and invited for an HCV/HBV test 1Lewis H, et al. Gut, 2011. 60 (Suppl 2) a26.
NICE PDG • Consultation on recommendations – June • IF more people diagnosed AND undergo treatment then case finding likely to be cost-effective...
Scale-up – from modelling to reality – empirical data needed • Trouble with models • Theoretical: projections not observations • Incorporate/test heterogeneity/ combine interventions… but empirical evidence required • NIHR PDG Grant • “Can HCV treatment be delivered to injecting drug users in order to reduce HCV transmission and prevalence in the population: an empirical demonstration and evaluation”
Scaling up HCV treatment and prevention • Audit current HCV treatment caseload • how far away from number required to observe impact in population • Pilot/develop HCV treatment in community • NIHR RfPB “Script in a day for injecting drug users: feasibility trial” • RCT to evaluate accelerated access to opiate substitution therapy from BDP to establish whether increases uptake and retains patients in treatment