1 / 13

The Altruism Paradox

The Altruism Paradox. Vinayak Ranade 9.20: Animal Behavior Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Darwinian Puzzles and Altruism. What is construed as altruism and what is an “Altruism Problem”? “self-sacrifice for the benefit of other individuals” Contradictory to natural selection.

emily
Download Presentation

The Altruism Paradox

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The Altruism Paradox Vinayak Ranade 9.20: Animal Behavior Massachusetts Institute of Technology

  2. Darwinian Puzzles and Altruism • What is construed as altruism and what is an “Altruism Problem”? • “self-sacrifice for the benefit of other individuals” • Contradictory to natural selection

  3. Reciprocal Altruism • Definition • I scratch your back, you scratch mine • Risk • Reciprocal scratching not guaranteed! • Good Samaritan Behavior • Examples • Meerkats, other cooperative societies • Counterexamples • Eusocial organisms

  4. Eusocial Organisms • Bees, ants, termites, naked-mole-rats • Classic Altruism Problem

  5. Kin Selection and Group Selection • Hamilton’s Rule • rB > C • E. O. Wilson • Kin Selection is flawed! • Species > Individual • Examples • Bees, Ants

  6. Genetic Fitness • Inclusive Fitness • George C Williams • The Selfish Gene • Examples • European wood ants • Naked mole rats • Wasps

  7. Accidental Altruism • Intentional and Unintentional Altruism • Law of unintended consequences • How can we tell the difference? • Examples • Yellow-billed cuckoo

  8. Zahavi’s Theory • Ability to incur cost  fitness  mating! • Different approach • Donating alms to a beggar => lots of resources => better mate • Examples • Arabian Babbler • Humans (?)

  9. Comparing the Models • Some species fit only one model • Some species fit multiple models • Most species fit William-Hamilton model • Is there one unified model which can explain all altruism problems? • WAM! (Weighted Altruism Model)

  10. Conclusion • Is there a best model? • Hamilton-Williams • Unified Altruism Theory? • Could it work? • Special cases • Only one theory applies • All theories apply • Ultimate Goals • Understanding human behavior • Implications of destroying altruism

  11. Study Questions • What is the altruism paradox? • What are some of the explanations for altruism problems? • Why is the genetic fitness theory favored over others? • How can we unify all the ideas for solving altruism problems? • And last but not least…

  12. Comparative Sociobiology(ists?)

More Related