1 / 28

HADES versus DLS:  no puzzle anymore !

HADES versus DLS:  no puzzle anymore !. E lena Bratkovskaya 22.10.2007 , Workshop ‚Bremsstrahlung in dilepton production‘ GSI, Darmstadt. 10 years of DLS puzzle. DLS-puzzle (since 1997):

errol
Download Presentation

HADES versus DLS:  no puzzle anymore !

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. HADES versus DLS:  no puzzle anymore ! Elena Bratkovskaya 22.10.2007 , Workshop ‚Bremsstrahlung in dilepton production‘ GSI, Darmstadt

  2. 10 years of DLS puzzle • DLS-puzzle (since 1997): • new (1997) DLS data for C+C and Ca+Ca at 1.04 A GeV are higher than the old (1995) DLS data by ~ a factor of 5-7 at 0.15<M<0.5 GeV • Transport models: • good description of p+p and p+d data from 1 to 5 GeV • missing yield at 0.15 < M < 0.5 GeV for C+C and Ca+Ca at 1.04 A GeV • (similar results obtained by HSD ‘97 , • UrQMD’98 and Tübingen QMD‘03) 10 years of waiting for HADES …

  3. Constraints on p, h by TAPS data: • HSD: good description of TAPS data • on p, h multiplicities and mT-spectra • => p (D), h dynamics under control ! Other channels: r, w: • accounting for in-medium effects (collisional broadening of vector meson spectral functions, dropping vector meson masses) does not provide enough enhancement at intermediate M • contribution from N(1520) (E.B.&C.M. Ko, PLB 445 (1999) 265) and higher baryonic resonances are small (cf. Gy. Wolf et al., PRC67 (2003) 044002) Also: • accounting for anisotropies in e+e- emission gives only a small effect A decade of search for the solution of the DLS puzzle HSD‘98

  4. DLS versus HADES Experiment: No contradictionbetween DLS and HADES ! What about theory ?

  5. Dileptons from transport models • HSD • UrQMD 1.3 (1998) • UrQMD 2.2 (2007) (Frankfurt) • RQMD (Tübingen) • IQMD (Nantes) • BRoBUU (Rossendorf)

  6. Basic concept of HSD • HSD – Hadron-String-Dynamics transport approach • for each particle species i (i = N, R, Y, p, r, K, …) the phase-space density fi followsthe transport equations • with collision termsIcoll describing: • elastic and inelastic hadronic reactions: baryon-baryon, meson-baryon, meson-meson • formation and decay of baryonic and mesonicresonances • string formation and decay (for inclusive particle production: BB -> X , mB ->X, X =many particles) • implementation of detailed balance on the level of 1<->2 • and 2<->2 reactions (+ 2<->n multi-particle reactions in HSD) • off-shell dynamics for short-lived states BB <-> B´B´, BB <-> B´B´m mB <-> m´B´, mB <-> B´ Baryons: B=(p, n, D(1232), N(1440), N(1535), ...) Mesons: m=(p, h, r, w, f, ...)

  7. e+ e+ g* N N R g* R N R N N N N e- N e- = Dilepton channels in HSD • All particles decaying to dileptons are first produced in BB, mB or mm collisions • ‚Factorization‘ of diagram in the transport approach: • The dilepton spectra are calculated perturbatively with the time integration method.

  8. Time integration method for dileptons ‚Reality‘: e+ only ONE e+e- pair with probability ~ Br(r->e+e-)=4.5 .10-5 r r w e- ‚Virtual‘ – time integ. method: t0 tabs e+ r time e- tF Calculate probability P(t) to emitan e+e- pair at each time t and integrate P(t) over time! r: t0 < t < tabs w: t0 <t < infinity tF – final time of computation in the code t0 – production time tabs – absorption (or hadronic decay) time

  9. The time integration method for dileptons in HSD Dilepton emission rate: e+ r e- t0=0 time tF Dilepton invariant mass spectra: tF < t < infinity 0 < t < tF

  10. g*->e+e- Phase-space corrected soft-photon cross section: Soft-Photon-Approximation (SPA): NN bremsstrahlung - SPA N N -> N N e+e- ‚quasi- elastic‘ N N -> N N elastic NN ‚off-shell‘ correction factor SPA implementation in HSD: e+e- production in elastic NN collision with probability:

  11. Kaptari&Kämpfer, NPA 764 (2006) 338 OBE-model: N N -> N N e+e- NN bremsstrahlung: OBE-model ‚pre‘ ‚post‘ ‚pre‘ ‚post‘ + gauge terms The strategy to restore gauge invariance is model dependent! charged meson exchange contact terms (from formfactors)

  12. Bremsstrahlung – a new view on an ‚old‘ story • New OBE-model (Kaptari&Kämpfer, NPA 764 (2006) 338): • pn bremstrahlung is larger by a factor of 4 than it has been • calculated before (and used in transport calculations)! • pp bremstrahlung is smaller than pn, however, not zero; consistent with the 1996 calculations from de Jong in a T-matrix approach 2007 (era of HADES): The DLS puzzle is solved by accounting for a larger pn bremsstrahlung !!!

  13. HSD: Dileptons from p+p and p+d - DLS • bremsstrahlung is the dominant contribution in p+d for 0.15 < M < 0.55 GeV at ~1-1.5 A GeV

  14. HSD: Dileptons from A+A at 1 A GeV - DLS • bremsstrahlung and D-Dalitz are the dominant contributions in A+A for 0.15 < M < 0.55 GeV at 1 A GeV !

  15. HSD: Dileptons from C+C at 1 and 2 A GeV - HADES Preliminary HADES data • HADES data show exponentially decreasing mass spectra • Data are better described by in-medium scenarios with collisional broadening • In-medium effects are more pronounced for heavy systems such as Au+Au

  16. HSD: Dilepton pT and y spectra from C+C at 1 A GeV - HADES Preliminary HADES data • HSD predictions for pT and y spectraare in good agreement • with the HADES data for all M-bins!

  17. M<0.15 GeV/c2 0.15<M<0.55 GeV/c2 M>0.55 GeV/c2 HSD: Dilepton pT and y spectra from C+C at 2 A GeV - HADES Preliminary HADES data • HSD predictions for pT and y spectraare in good agreement • with the HADES data for all M-bins!

  18. Ernst et al, PRC58 (1998) 447 Bremsstrahlung in UrQMD 1.3 (1998) SPA: Bremsstrahlung-UrQMD’98 smaller than bremsstrahlung-Kaptari’06 by a factor of 3-6 SPA implementation in UrQMD (1998): e+e- production in elastic NN collisions (similar to HSD)

  19. Ernst et al, PRC58 (1998) 447 Dileptons from pp and pd - UrQMD 1.3 • „old“bremsstrahlung: missing yield for p+d at 0.15 < M < 0.55 GeV at ~1-1.5 A GeV

  20. Ernst et al, PRC58 (1998) 447 Dileptons from A+A - UrQMD 1.3 • „old“bremsstrahlung: missing yield for A+A at 0.15 < M < 0.55 GeV at 1 A GeV • (consistent with HSD with „old SPA“)

  21. D. Schumacher, S. Vogel, M. Bleicher, Acta Phys.Hung.A27 (2006) 451 Dileptons from A+A - UrQMD 2.2 (2007) NO bremsstrahlung in UrQMD 2.2

  22. C. Fuchs et al., Phys. Rev. C67 025202(2003) Dileptons from pp and pd - RQMD (Tübingen) • NObremsstrahlung: missing yield for p+d at 0.15 < M < 0.55 GeV at ~1-1.5 A GeV

  23. C. Fuchs et al., Phys. Rev. C67 025202(2003) HADES - RQMD‘07 Dileptons from A+A - RQMD (Tübingen) DLS - RQMD‘03 1 A GeV • NO bremsstrahlung in RQMD • too strong D-Dalitz contribution (since no time integration?)

  24. M. Thomere, C. Hartnack, G. Wolf, J. Aichelin, PRC75 (2007) 064902 Bremsstrahlung in IQMD (Nantes) HADES: C+C, 2 A GeV SPA implementation in IQMD (?): e+e- production in each NN collision(i.e. elastic and inelastic) !? - differs from HSD and UrQMD’98 (only elastic NN collisions are counted!)

  25. H.W. Barz, B. Kämpfer, Gy. Wolf, M. Zetenyi, nucl-th/0605036 Bremsstrahlung in BRoBUU (Rossendorf) SPA implementation in BRoBUU (?): e+e- production in each NN collision(i.e. elastic and inelastic) ! - similar to IQMD (Nantes)

  26. Test in HSD:bremsstrahlung production in NN collisions (only elastic vs. all) In HSD assume: e+e- productionfrom „old“ SPA bremsstrahlung in each NN collision (i.e. elastic and inelastic reactions) => can reproduce the results by Gy. Wolf et al., i.e. IQMD (Nantes) and BRoBUU (Rossendorf) !

  27. Summary: Bremsstrahlung in transport models • Transport models give similar resultsONLY with the same • initial input ! • => REQUESTS: • „unification“ of the treatment of dilepton production in transport models: • Similar cross sections for elementary channels • Time-integration method for dilepton production • Off-shell treatment of broad resonances • + • Consistent microscopic calculations for e+e- • bremsstrahlung from NN and mN collisions! We need: clear separation of the individual contributions in a form applicable in transport codes, e.g. many-dimensional matrix (or parametrization) for ds/dMdydpT (s,M,y,pT )

  28. Summary HADES succeeded: the DLS puzzle is solved ! Outlook: need new pp and pd data from HADES for a final check!

More Related