120 likes | 266 Views
Innovative features of the Design Project at Sheffield Deciding what to make and where to make it. Steve Wilkinson Dept. of Chemical & Process Engineering, University of Sheffield. Overview. Sheffield BEng and MEng design projects Plant location Product Development Supervisors view
E N D
Innovative features of the Design Project at SheffieldDeciding what to make and where to make it Steve Wilkinson Dept. of Chemical & Process Engineering, University of Sheffield
Overview • Sheffield BEng and MEng design projects • Plant location • Product Development • Supervisors view • Students view
Sheffield BEng and MEng design projects • 40 credits • Group presentation (early Nov, 10%) • Group report (7 Nov, 20%) • Individual report (6 Feb 70%)
BEng Design Project • Hydrogen manufacturing unit • Steam hydrocarbon reforming process • 31 students • Use of industrial consultants • Site visit
MEng Design Project • Fischer-Tropsch biodiesel • Lignocellulosic bioethanol • Hybrid sulphur cycle • Rotating spiral contactor • Wood biomass gasification • Plug flow reactor • Caprolactam production • CO2 capture and utilisation • Chocolate production
Plant location • Assigned location for BEng - helps differentiate: • Seasonal temperatures • Feedstock composition • Labour costs • Safety legislation • Chosen location for MEng • Political stability • Costs • Market demand • Access to utilities, transportation • Adds realism and interest • Ok for less technical group members
Product design: Chocolate confectionary in China Factory Location: Hefei, China Why China? • Highest population • High marketing potential Why Hefei? • Fast developing city • Strategic position • Good transportation • Industrial area • Suitable climate • average temperature: 15.7°C
Liked Disliked
The final product- Fruitilicious Fruit filling Jam-based Cherry Kiwi Banana Milk chocolate • 10% Cocoa liquor • 20.5% Cocoa Butter • 20% Whole milk powder • 49% Sugar • 0.5% Lecithin 1.6 cm 2 cm
Supervisors views • Get them moving early in first 2 weeks • Massive culture shock for many students • First time to read scientific papers • Making assumptions, estimates, approximations • Realise there is no right answer! • Light teaching commitment – one hour meeting each week • Challenging student attributes • Unable or unwilling to search for information (Google) • Incapable of making assumptions • Send in draft reports for checking • Thinking the supervisor is an expert in the process • Inability to formulate questions by email
Students views: Questionnaire 2012 (43 returns) • What did you enjoy most? • Working in a group and flexible working • Reading journals, learning how to research with Google scholar • Applying knowledge creatively to design something from scratch • What did you find most challenging (in a good way)? • First time reading scientific papers • Making assumptions, estimates, approximations • Realising there is no right answer! • How much did you use what you had learnt in lectures? • A lot = 42%, some = 49%, very little = 5% • Do you think the plant location part makes it more realistic? • Yes = 74% • What could be changed to make it better? • More guidance on where to find the info required • More realism and site visits • More books in library, more contact/feedback with supervisors