400 likes | 536 Views
AUTHORITATIVE SOURCES IN HYPERLINKED ENVIRONMENT. By Jon M. Kleinberg Presented by Moonyoung Kang. Warnings. S tatements might be strong. Argue me back. Correct me if wrong. Slides are razzle -dazzling. Keep your attention. Old tech (1998). We know the result
E N D
AUTHORITATIVE SOURCES IN HYPERLINKED ENVIRONMENT By Jon M. Kleinberg Presented by Moonyoung Kang
Warnings • Statements might be strong. • Argue me back. • Correct me if wrong. • Slides are razzle-dazzling. • Keep your attention.
Old tech (1998) • We know the result • Presentation focus: Who won? Why?
Paper talks about… Hubs & Authorities Clustering Page Similarity
I will focus on… Hubs & Authorities
What Instructors Want Don’t forget Ranking Nodes
Hubs & Authorities In 5 slides
What is “Hubs & Authorities” • Finding important & relevant nodes • Hubs (outlinks) • Authorities (inlinks)
Relevance Query Seed Matching terms
Outlink 1 1 1 1 Hub scores authority
Inlink 1 1 1 1 Authority scores hub
Stationary state Hubs & Authorities In 5 slides Converge
It is a period of node-ranking war. • PAGERANK and HITS knew each other
What Google Scholar says… 7751 6380
Why? Similar? Different? Hubs & Authorities
Similarities… Iterative Adj. Matrix Eigenvector Link to Scores
Easy differences… Adj.Matrix Two scores Single score Voting
What Jon says… Query dep. Two-degree model Local Query indep. One-degree model Global
#1 Query dependent search = = + Is this good or bad?
Variance = = High = = Low + + = = High 24
#2 Local computation Fast Do you buy this? Google’s solution?
Visit all nodes, eventually. In & Out links Web is connected
Multi-users? … …
#3 Two-degree model Do you buy this? WWW divisible into Hubs & Authorities
Bipartite How Jon thinksweb looks like How web reallylooks like
Conclusion • PageRank beats HITS in many ways… • REAL WORLD ≠ PAPER • Arguments may be misleading • Don’t share this presentation publicly • Jon hates this