210 likes | 376 Views
Competitor analysis. Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG Sirius. 3RT contactors 75HP. 45. 85. Contactors 75HP (1/5). Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG. 45. 45. 75. LC1-K06/K09/K12/K16 2.2 / 4 / 5.5 / 7.5kW. LC1-D09/D12/D18
E N D
Competitor analysis Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG Sirius 3RT contactors 75HP
45 85 Contactors 75HP (1/5) Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG 45 45 75 LC1-K06/K09/K12/K16 2.2 / 4 / 5.5 / 7.5kW LC1-D09/D12/D18 5 / 7.5 / 10HP LC1-D25/D32/D38 15 / 20 / 25HP LC1-D40/D50/D65 30 / 40 / 50HP LC1-D80/D95 60/60HP S00 S0 S2 S3 3RT101 3RT102 3RT103 3RT104 3/5/7.5HP 5/7.5/10/15HP 20/25/30/40HP 50/60/75HP 45mm 45mm 55mm 70mm
Contactors 75HP (2/5) - Dimensions: From LC1-D40 - D65 (30-50HP) - wider than SIRIUS Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG - Connection system: Contacts can only be changed from 75HP and upwards SIRIUS:Possible from Size S2/ 25HP & up Up to 60HP, terminal box cannot be removed Busbar/cable lug connection not possible SIRIUS: Possible from Size S3/ 50HP & up Different insertion-depth for the main conductors for LC1-D09- D16 It is possible to accidentally clamp on the insulation The maximum cable cross-sections for the appropriate rated currents cannot be connected
Contactors 75HP (3/5) Auxiliary and control conductor connections: Up to 30HP, the auxiliary and coil conductors are always wired-up through the contactor SIRIUS: Four-terminal coil S0 - S3 A1 - Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG A2 - Label: The coil label cannot be read when the contactor is mounted SIRIUS: The complete catalog number can be read from the front - Materials/environmental compatibility: Contains some halogens + Dimensions/series: Small and compact series K contactors from 3 HP upwards in comparison to S00 Depth up to LC1-D95/ 75HP is generally lower (even with the integrated auxiliary contact) Auxiliary contacts: 1NC+1NO integrated up to LC1-D38/ 25HP ; access from the front (refer above)
Contactors 75HP(4/5) + Connection system: Ring cable lugs can be used to connect main conductors ofLC1-D09/ 5HP to LC1-D38/ 25HP Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG - Restriction: Ring cable lugs cannot be used for auxiliary and control cables + Coil energization: Generally a wider operating range for DC coils: 0.7 - 1.25 Vs + Safety cover: The front cover to prevent accidental actuation is provided as standard (cover for the auxiliary contact coupling;the cover is thrown away for Hischa mounting) SIRIUS: The main contact coupling is recessed in the outer contour to protect it against accidental actuation. A sealed safety cover is available as an accessory.
Circuit - Breakers Soft Starters Contactors - Air Break - Vacuum Contactors 75kW(5/5) Size S00 S0 S2 S3 S6 S10 S12 TeSys scope Combined with 3 VL circuit-breakers Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG Overload Relays - Thermal Overload Relays - Electronic TeSys only covers part of the modular SIRIUS system - only contactors 3 to 30 HP have been re-developed with the Quickfit technology, otherwise just a face-lift
45 45 45 Contactors 75HP (1/3) Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG 60 70 100 DILEEM / EM 3 / 5HP DIL00M/AM 5 / 7.5HP DIL0M/AM 10 / 15HP DIL1M/AM 25 / 30 HP DIL2M/AM 40 / 50HP DIL3M/AM 60 / 75HP S00 S0 S2 S3 3RT101 3RT102 3RT103 3RT104 3/5/7.5HP 5/7.5/10/15HP 20/25/30/40HP 50/60/75HP 45mm 45mm 55mm 70mm
Contactors 75HP (2/3) - Series: Width: 25/ 30HP: 60mm / SIRIUS: 55mm 40HP: 70mm / SIRIUS: 55mm 60/75HP: 100mm / SIRIUS: 70mm 4 widths up to 75HP / SIRIUS: 3 widths No standard, unified design Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG - Endurance: DILEEM/ EM small contactor: Electrical and mechanical endurance is significantly lower than our S00: Mechanical: 10 million operating cycles / SIRIUS: 30 million oper. cycles Electrical: 1.2/0.75 million op. cycles / SIRIUS: 2/ 1.5 million op. cycles DC operating system: For 60/75HP, mechanical endurance: LD: 3 million operating cycles. SIRIUS: 10 million operating cycles - Permissible ambient temperatures: Up to 30kW max. 50°C / SIRIUS: 60°C
Contactors 75HP (3/3) - Accessories: Wiring connectors for reversing combinations - only up to 30HP SIRIUS: 400HP Wiring connectors for star/delta combinations - only up to 50HP SIRIUS: 400HP Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG - Wide operating range: There are no contactors available with a wide operating range (e.g. coupling relays) - Coil terminals: Three terminal coil: This causes restrictions when directly mounting protective devices / SIRIUS: 4-terminal coil + Dimensions: Standard low depth - less than SIRIUS + Small contactor: Compact DILEM/ DILEEM small contactor (low depth)
47,5 44 Contactors 100HP (1/3) Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG 54 70 90 B6-30/B7 5 / 7.5HP A9-30/A12 /A16 5 / 7.5 / 10HP A26-30/A30/A40 15/ 25/ 30HP A50-30/A63/A75 40 / 50 / 60HP A95-30/A110 745/ 100HP S00 S0 S2 S3 3RT101 3RT102 3RT103 3RT104 3/5/7.5HP 5/7.5/10/15HP 20/25/30/40HP 50/60/75HP 45mm 45mm 55mm 70mm
Contactors 100HP (2/3) - Coil terminals: Three-terminal coil: Restrictions when directly mounting protective devices/ SIRIUS: 4-terminal coil Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG - Connection system: Single box terminal (only 1 conductor) from 40HP/ A50 up to 100HP/ A110 - Changing contacts: Contacts can only be changed from 40HP SIRIUS: Contactors can be changed from Size S2/ 20HP - Auxiliary contacts:Ie/ AC-15 (auxiliary contacts): 4A/ 230V SIRIUS: 6A/ 230V - Ambient temperature/operating range: Max. ambient temperature, +55°C / SIRIUS: +60°C Operating range: 0.85 - 1.1xUs; at >55°C, restricted operating range up to 1xUs
Contactors 100HP (3/3) + Dimensions: Compact small contactor B6/B7 (low depth) Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG + Auxiliary contacts: 1 integrated auxiliary contact as standard all the way up through to 30HP From 40 to 60 HP, 6 front-mounted auxiliary contactors are possible
47,5 44 Contactors 75HP (1/3) Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG 54 54 72 100-M05/M09/M12 3 / 5 / 7.5HP 100-C09/C12/C16/C23 5 / 7.5 / 10 / 15HP 100-C30/C37 25 / 30HP 100-C43 40HP 100-C60/C72/C85 50 / 60 / 75HP S00 S0 S2 S3 3RT101 3RT102 3RT103 3RT104 3/5/7.5HP 5/7.5/10/15HP 20/25/30/40HP 50/60/75HP 45mm 45mm 55mm 70mm
Contactors 45kW (2/3) - Coil terminals: Two-terminal coil: Connections top or bottom (separate Order Nos.) SIRIUS: 4-terminal coil Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG - Changing contacts:Contacts can only be changed from 75HP/ CAB6-85 onwards SIRIUS:Possible from Size S2/ 20HP - Dimensions:DC contactors: Very deep - Labeling:Rating plate data inadequate: - no connection cross-sections - no insulation stripping lengths - no tightening torques The coil label cannot be read when the contactor is mounted SIRIUS: complete catalog number can be read from the font
Contactors 75HP (3/3) - Screw mounting: The screws which are used to mount the contactor to the front panel are not captive screws Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG + Wye-delta starter: Space-saving design: Square footprint Safety contactors: Separate series of safety contactors 5 – 75HP (100S-C) - Positively-driven contacts SIRIUS: General - The contactor and auxiliary contact block are permanently coupled with one another SIRIUS: Special version with a Hischa block which cannot be removed - Protection against accidental/undesirable actuation SIRIUS: Accessory - Auxiliary contact, electronics/compatible in compliance with DIN 19240 SIRIUS: General
45 45 Contactors 100HP (1/3) Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG 55 66 75 LS02K/ 05 3 / 5HP LS4K/5K/7K/11K 5 / 7.5 / 10 / 15HP LS12K/15K/18K 20 / 25 / 30HP LS22K/30K/37K 40 / 50 / 60 HP LS45K/55K 75 / 100HP S00 S0 S2 S3 3RT101 3RT102 3RT103 3RT104 3/5/7.5HP 5/7.5/10/15HP 20/25/30/40HP 50/60/75HP 45mm 45mm 55mm 70mm
Contactors 100HP (2/3) - Labeling: No order designation [catalog number] on the front plate Coil voltage cannot be read from the front Rating plate: No data on the connection cross sections Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG - Coil terminals: Three terminal coil: Restrictions when directly mounting protective devices/ SIRIUS: 4-terminal coil
Contactors 100HP (3/3) + Series: Auxiliary contacts: 1NO/1NC integrated up to LS11K/ 15HP for 45mm wide (as version) 1NO+1NC can be snapped onto the front (2 individual blocks) as MRPD version from 30 to 100HP Complete series of 4-pole contactors: Up to 10HP: 45mm side Schneider Electric Moeller ABB Allen Bradley GE / AEG + Connection system: Main and control circuits up to 100 HP are connected using ring cable lugs (this was presented at the Hanover Fair 2002) + Changing contacts: Contacts can be changed from 5HP / LS4K SIRIUS: this is possible from S2/ 25HP + Changing coils:Coils can be changed from LS02K (3HP) / LS05K (5HP)