320 likes | 432 Views
Education and Service, Supervision and Protection: Four-in-One to Vigorously Develop the Team of Qualified Investors. President of Shanghai Stock Exchange Zhang Yujun July, 28th, 2008. Contents. Introduction: Brief Analysis of the Characteristics of Investors Conclusion.
E N D
Education and Service, Supervision and Protection: Four-in-One to Vigorously Develop the Team of Qualified Investors President of Shanghai Stock Exchange Zhang Yujun July, 28th, 2008
Contents Introduction: Brief Analysis of the Characteristics of Investors Conclusion First, to enhance the investor education by innovating the approaches Second, to develop the investor service based on the analysis of their demands Third, to conduct the supervision over investors with fresh ideas Fourth, to improve the investor protection by putting the system first
Introduction: Brief Analysis of the Characteristics of Investors
Characteristics of the structure and conducts of investors(1) • The number of individual investors’ accounts has increased, while their proportion in total cap has declined every year; The proportion of institutional investors’ accounts in total market cap has steadily increased year by year. • Individual investors especially small-sized ones prefer small cap stocks and ST stocks; Institutional investors prefer larger cap stocks. • Although equipped with less investment experience, individual investors prefer high-risk securities that may bring huge profits. • Individual investors prefer stocks with high P/E, neglecting the intrinsic value of stocks.
Characteristics of the structure and conducts of investors(2) • Overall profitability of individual investors has increased with the enlargement of the investment scale, but is still lower than that of institutional investors at the same period. • The corresponding proportions of stocks with different up/down ratio in the portfolios of individual investors remain constant; For the institution investors, just the opposite. The institutional investors are capable of picking the right stocks in a bull market. • Individual investors trade actively with a turnover rate about 2-4 times that of institutional investors. • Individual investors and institutional investors trade adversely.
Figure 1: Change of market cap held up by individual and institutional investors Individual investors prefer stocks with high P/E, neglecting the intrinsic value of stocks.
Figure 2: Percentage change of various periods of investment for the investment scale of less than 100,000 RMB
Figure 3: Cash amount for net purchase of individual investors with an investment of less than 100,000 RMB or between 100,000 to 1 million RMB
Figure 4: Cash amount for net purchase of investment funds or QFII members Finding based on the comparison between Figure 3 and Figure 4: Individual investors and institutional investors trade adversely. In the year of 2007 and 2008, individual investors were the net seller, while institutional investors were the net buyer in the market.
Figure 5: Individual vs. Institutional: Change of proportions of stocks with different up/down ratio in the portfolio(2005-2008) Individual investors and institutional investors prefer stocks with different up/down ratio
Figure 6:Percentage change of stocks with low up/down ratio in the portfolios of individual investors
Figure 7:Percentage change of stocks with high up/down ratio in the portfolios of individual investors The corresponding proportions of stocks with different up/down ratio in the portfolios of individual investors remain constant; For the institution investors, just the opposite. The institutional investors are capable of picking the right stocks in a bull market.
Four-in-One to Vigorously Develop the Team of Qualified Investors Education Investors Supervision Service Protection
First, to enhance the investor educationby innovating the approaches • What’s the signification of investor education? • How to conduct investor education? • What are the role and focus of SSE in investor education?
Significance • Investors are the foundation of the market • The maturing of investors is a driving force for the maturing of the market • Investors’ maturity is an important indicator of the maturity of the market • The cultivation of rational and mature investors relies on the relentless efforts of various market participants to effectively conduct investor education • This work is long-term, basic and routine.
How to do? To understand the educational needs of investors and conduct investor education based on the classification of investors To popularize investor education To include investor education into the national education system To strengthen the assessment of the education results
The Investor Education of SSE (1) Role The Four Combinations To sort out external relations, To understand market conditions, To perfect operational system, To integrate market resources, To make full use of our own advantages, to encourage members to conduct investor education, and start face-to-face education, in order to establish an information sharing mechanism to enhance cooperation with other market participants as well as leading media. Combine Investor Education with • Institution building • Frontline regulation • Market innovation • Handling of investors’ complaints
The Investor Education of SSE (2) The newly established Investor Education Department has launched investor education featuring qualified investors regime recently. • Integrating the current dispersed resources, establishing and perfecting the investor education platform, making full use of our own advantages. • With the launch of new products, conducting the investor education among ordinary investors, fully revealing the investment risks, making them fully aware of the principle of ‘Buyers Take the Risks’ . • Strengthening the institution building: Appointing the contact points of members for investor education. • Establishing the investor education messaging platform and urging members to remind the investors of the risks in a timely fashion. • Developing relevant guidelines to discipline individual investors. • Developing and launching mock trading for ETFs, Warrants etc. Developing and promoting the mock testing and qualification assurance.
Second, to develop the investor service based on the analysis of their demands • Why to promote investor service? • How does SSE provide investor service?
The service philosophy of SSE Service creates the core value of SSE Service Objects: • Members and intermediaries • Listed and pre-listed companies • Investors (Creating values for them and protecting their interests) Regulation? Service?
The Investor Service of SSE (1) Making transparent and dynamic service: publicizing the information and update it timely. Standardizing the service: Optimizing the service procedures and providing timely feedback for investors. Providing service with passion and sincerity. Defining the service contents: Setting out the procedures, contents, FAQs, and exemption clauses. Diversifying the service: Using both the electronic and non-electronic means to provide routine or targeted services.
Third, to conduct the supervision over investors with fresh ideas • Why to supervise investors? • How to supervise investors? • How does SSE supervise the investors?
Thinking The logical support for investor supervision Market failure? Government failure? Discrepancies among investors in funds, risk identification and investment decision-making. Even an open market may fail to provide fairness and equitability when the investors are irrational. To exercise supervision based on the classification of investors. Pursuit of value:order, efficiency and true fairness Classification criteria: net asset, knowledge, experience, etc. Dynamic Classification: Making adjustment according to specific circumstances and allowing certain exemptions from regulation in strict conditions. Pay attention to the protection of investors’ property right, privacy, the right of equality, liberty and so on.
Supervision methods According to different risks associated with products, setting up the specific entry requirements for investors as well as risk disclosure criteria accordingly. Special rules for products To establish core teams of investors for related products Product entry Market entry Individual investor vs. institutional investors Domestic investors vs. foreign investors Market participants: Senior, intermediate, ordinary Investor entry Account monitoring Monitoring the accounts with unusual trading. Including the accounts with unusual trading into the ‘black list’, freezing their accounts and restricting their transactions. The record can be a reference for qualification assurance. ‘Black list’ Banishment from the market The accounts with serious violations are banished from the market.
How does SSE supervise the investors? • Lawfully conducting the front-line regulation over investors • Introducing the entry system for investors based on accurate analysis of the characteristics of investors and the national conditions. • Carrying out classified investor management based on keen observation of investors’ risk managements abilities. • Strengthening the supervision over trading activities and the punishment mechanism. Adopting such measures as ‘Black List’ and ‘Banishment from market’.
Fourth, to improve the investor protection by putting the system first • What are the investor’s rights and interests? • How to build the institutions related to investor protection? • How to protect the investor’s rights and interests? • How does SSE protect its investors?
Institutional guarantee • Market entry mechanism for securities offering • Fixed-price offering mechanism • Risk insulation mechanism of securities companies • Third-party depository mechanism • Information disclose system • Corporate Governance of listed companies • Credit rating of listed companies and intermediaries • Securities Investor Compensation Fund System • Shareholder derivative litigation, securities class action • Bankruptcy reconciliation, re-organization system • Social supervision
Protection of rights ‘Rule of Law’—To improve the relevant legal system to protect the rights and interests of investors and to highlight INTEGRITY. Methods Public protection Administrative decisions, litigation Increase the costs for violations of the law Negotiation, mediation, appeals, arbitration, etc. Adopt legal means Self-protection Effect The investor’s interests can be safeguarded when violations are punished. The execution of civil judgment of compensation helps to ensure justness in the market thus maintaining social order.
How does SSE protect its investors? • Establishing SSE as the market organizer and front-line regulator. Effectively combining the education, service, supervision and protection of investors. • Further strengthening the information disclosure of listed companies. • Intensifying the management of members. • Establishing the system of prudent qualified investors. • Promoting the mechanism of investors’ self-protection. Providing related rules for products and transaction data, etc to help defend their rights.
Conclusion:Education and Service, Supervision and Protection: Four-in-one, to vigorously Develop the Team of Qualified Investors Thank you!