1 / 15

BS2912 Public Administration in Britain

BS2912 Public Administration in Britain. 5: Agencies; Best Value. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value. Next Steps Report (1988) proposes:

flower
Download Presentation

BS2912 Public Administration in Britain

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value

  2. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Next Steps Report (1988) proposes: • All the executive functions of government (paying benefits, issuing licences, collecting taxes) should be responsibility of agencies • Agency managers should have considerable freedom to manage their agency, leading to managerial efficiency • By 1998 there were 138 agencies operating

  3. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Next Steps Report (1988) proposes: • Own Chief Executives (not Ministers) • Own internal accounting procedures • Own responsibility for ‘pay and rations’ within a fixed budget • A framework document to define responsibilities • Series of performance indicators to judge effectiveness

  4. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Examples: • Employment Service  Meteorological Office • Prison Service  UK Passport Agency • Benefits Agency  Ordnance Survey • DVLA  Office of National • Highways Agency Statistics

  5. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Has it worked ? [1] Survey by Karbhari & Pendlebury concludes: • Agency managers perceive they have more freedom • Argue for increased effectiveness, value-for-money • But accounting systems (annuality, virement) do not fit easily with agencification • Budgetary controls were restrictive

  6. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Has it worked ? [2] • As the civil servants were previously unenthusiastic, this might be considered a good test • Respondents from trading fund agencies much more enthusiastic than others • Views of users has not yet been sought!

  7. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Pessimistic view of Next Steps • Private sector working practices needed to pervade Whitehall • ‘Public service ethos’ does not exist • Not ‘what can we sell’ but ‘what must we keep’ • Accountability is fudged • All agencies should be considered for privatisation at least once every five years

  8. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Optimistic view of Next Steps • Logical development from Raynor efficiency scrutinies • Move from a monolithic to a more federal structure • Benefits perceived for both Ministers and Chief Executives as well as the customer, the taxpayer, and agency staff

  9. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Accountability [1] • Constitutional theory is that policy is decided by the Minister who is answerable to Parliament • Day-to-day operations are handled by the agency • A ‘framework’ document defines the responsibility of each to the other • Neither should ‘dabble’ in the affairs of the other

  10. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Accountability [2] • But in the case of a large agency (e.g. Prisons) it is hard to divorce ‘policy’ from ‘operations’ e.g. is ‘locking up prisoners up all day’ a policy descision or an operational decision ? • In practice, accountability is weakened if chief executives cannot be questioned by Parliament • Small agencies now have no political control (because they are under control of civil servants)

  11. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Recent Developments • Accent not on creating new agencies but developing performance initiatives within them • Two thirds of agencies are now engaged in benchmarking against the Business Excellence Model • Agency Performance and Efficiency

  12. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Best Value • Has replaced CCT (Compulsory Competitive Tendering) • Is now regarded as a key point in modernising local government • Requires local authorities to review functions, publish annual plans showing past and projected performance and introduce a rigorous programme of audit and inspection

  13. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Modernising Government - Summary • Make public services available 24 hours a day • Joined up government • Remove unnecessary regulation • Deliver all dealings with government electronically by 2008 • New ‘Learning Labs’ • Incentivise public service staff • New focus on delivery

  14. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Modernising Government - 3 aims • Joined up government • Public service users, not providers are the focus • Delivery of high quality and efficient public services

  15. BS2912 Public Administration in Britain 5: Agencies; Best Value Modernising Government - 5 commitments • Better long-term policy making (not just reacting to events) • Responsive public services • Quality public services • Information age government • Value and modernise public service, not denigrate it

More Related