1 / 11

WHAT IS A NON-STATE ACTOR?

WHAT IS A NON-STATE ACTOR?. 22 January 2010. ARE WE SURE WHAT A STATE ACTOR IS?. Modern conception: A Government (An inter-governmental institution, esp. if it has its own legal base)

francis-conley
Download Presentation

WHAT IS A NON-STATE ACTOR?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. WHAT IS A NON-STATE ACTOR? 22 January 2010

  2. ARE WE SURE WHAT A STATE ACTOR IS? • Modern conception: • A Government • (An inter-governmental institution, esp. if it has its own legal base) • Military forces maintained by a government, police, civilian officials etc • (Local government authorities)

  3. BUT..... • Historical complications: partial/unclear statehood, armies used to be commercially recruited, some officials worked as ‘farmers’ • Ethical complications: state authorities not necessarily ‘recognized’, legitimate, or generally ‘good’ • Practical complications: what is called a ‘government’ may not act like one or be the real one in a ‘weak’ state

  4. PRIVATIZATION ETC • A state authority may ‘sell’ a function that it formerly controlled - privatization • It may share the costs with private funders but keep a share in control – Public-Private Partnership • It may purchase a service from a non-state supplier rather than doing it itself – outsourcing • It may delegate tasks ad hoc

  5. TYPES OF NON-STATE ACTORS • [Supranational organizations] • (Multinational) business corporations • Terrorist and criminal networks • Factions in an internal conflict • (Multinational) NGOs • (Multinational) civil society networks • Ordinary people – you and me

  6. TYPICAL NON-STATE FEATURES • Self-motivating and self-resourcing • Free choice of structure or no structure • (often) ‘transnational’ operation/impact: -information access -information flows -equipment+technology access -cross-border movement -network building and ‘franchising’

  7. TYPICAL PROBLEMS OF CONTROL • National and international laws do not ‘bite’ unless drafted to apply to such actors (and to take account of their characteristics) • Problems in applying direct coercion, deterrence or ‘defeat’ • Problems of direct negotiation+agreement • Problems of tracking and controlling resource flows (multinationals, money laundering, terrorist finance, gun running etc)

  8. ON THE OTHER HAND.... • Non-state security activity can: - Make up for weaknesses of non- functioning state, empower individuals - Defend against a dysfunctional state - Support and supplement the state esp in newer security dimensions (+ subsidiarity) - Find transnational solutions for transnational/global processes (modernity, flexibility) - Share and ease resource burdens

  9. ‘GOOD’ OR ‘BAD’? • What is our instinctive classification of - Multinationals? - Business in general? - Terrorist groups and networks? - Criminals and their networks? - National and international NGOS? - National and international civil society networks: a) religious, b) other? - Individuals playing a security role?

  10. TESTCASE A: A CIVIL WAR • Possibleroles of multinationalbusiness • Possibleroles of localbusiness • Possibleroles for terrorists • Possibleroles for variouskinds of criminals • Possibleroles for non-statearmedgroups • Possibleroles for NGOs, external+national • Possibleroles for civilsocietygroups • Possibleroles for families+individuals

  11. TESTCASE B: A BIG NATURAL DISASTER • Roles for multinationals? • Roles for other business? • Roles for terrorists? • Roles for criminals? • Roles for NGOs? • Roles for civil society groups? • Roles for individuals?’

More Related