1 / 20

Computer Systems and The Design of Organizational Interaction

Computer Systems and The Design of Organizational Interaction. Fernando Flores, Michael Graves,Brad Hartfield,Terry Winograd ACM Transactions on Office Information Systems 1988 Swapnil Sinvhal and Eunyee Koh CPSC 671 Spring 2004. Introduction. Theory and practice :

fredericka-kelley
Download Presentation

Computer Systems and The Design of Organizational Interaction

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Computer Systems and The Design of Organizational Interaction Fernando Flores, Michael Graves,Brad Hartfield,Terry Winograd ACM Transactions on Office Information Systems1988 Swapnil Sinvhal and Eunyee Koh CPSC 671 Spring 2004

  2. Introduction • Theory and practice : Organizational communication and management Technology = Design of practices and possibilities (opens up possibilities of new realms of practice) != Design of physical things • Theory of language as social action • Design of the Coordinator

  3. Theory And Design (1 of 2) • Design of new technology  intervention into ongoing activity  resettling into new practices • “A theory, as an ontology, is a set of key distinctions for observing, participating, and designing.” • Effectiveness of design , theory must be assessed in terms the context of the consequences difficult to predict acceptability of new technology

  4. Theory And Design (2 of 2) Two prominent orientations of existing computer systems • Rationalistic • Believes more electronically connected  more information  more effective organizations  better management • BUT Productivity != quantity of information (Overload) it concerns effectiveness of people getting things done ... scope for research !!

  5. Language / Action Perspective(1 of 3) • Human beings are fundamentally linguistic being • Verbal / non-verbal, formal / informal • Details of the situation: • - Context of phrases (request/invite) • - Some cultures "never decline a request" • Theory: Teach ontology of linguistic action for better management • Reduce time and effort spent in “unproductive” conversation • People become more aware of distinctions • Lead to a less panicked, confused atmosphere • Computer Tools for Acting in Language • Domain = Networks of people engaged in conversation Networks of action that connect them

  6. Language / Action Perspective(2 of 3) • Older media • Specialized roles, institutions to handle breakdown (Libraries, Universities, publishers, editors, ...) • Assistance in managing information (Secretaries, Receptionists, Assistants) • Email • Pro: New possibilities for communication, Cut across organizational hierarchies • Con: New source for breakdown Is that really a “pro” ?!

  7. Language / Action Perspective(3 of 3) • The problem: • Accessibility of information outpaced growth of new roles/institutions to handle it • Management of information becomes a burden - not a support • The Solution ??? The Coordinator

  8. The Coordinator (1 of 3) • Metaphor: Dance • Social Action happens through language Request Action Request Action Decline (someone does it) Promise Revoke promise Ask for progress report Cancel Declare complete Report completion >1 variations of workflow?

  9. The Coordinator (2 of 3) • Program: Explicit declarations of structure • Natural Language Processing by users • Email Integration Mainly written language

  10. The Coordinator (3 of 3) • Renaming? • Sub-conversations? • >1 topic ? • Undo? • Basic unit of work = conversation • Retrieval based on status • “Complete” vs “Open” • Time – oriented retrieval • Calendar subsystem integrated • Identify potential breakdowns • Theories of language (replace typing) • Generic tool

  11. May be good for multi-location teams New overhead? – strictly define work May even lead to new management strategies The Coordinator … for Management • Managers have to manage : • Very complex projects, actions • Recurrent mis-coordination of actions • Information overload • “The activity of management is the creation and • development of conversations for completing action.” • “Coach” the user • People begin to acquire a “new common sense”

  12. Social Environment • By making the network of requests and promises explicit in its structure, the Coordinator can provide a means of improving the degrees to which people have adequately shared interpretations of their commitments and actions. • Each message of the Coordinator carries a label that distinguishes it as a request or as not-a request (e.g., a conversation for possibilities). This changes the space of possibilities for communication – the form of the dance. • The Coordinator offers more structure than conventional mail systems and is less confining than the customer-order system.

  13. The underlying Claim • Conversation Types – only dealing with some of the conversations in an office setting. As office communication systems evolve, there will be a mix in which computer-based text is used for the more explicit forms, while recorded and transmitted voice and video images become the preferred mode for the casual conversation. • Stability of Role Structure – the basic parameters of authority, obligation, and cooperation are stable. • Cooperation and Competition – the cooperative aspects of achieving mutually declared results dominate over the competitive aspects of interpersonal or intergroup conflict.

  14. Technology, Change and Learning • “missionary software” – organizational or social change is being imposed on an unwilling populace by outsiders with a dogmatic theory. • “educational software” – the everyday use of the Coordinator serves to educate users in the principles of conversation and action.

  15. Discussion • The Coordinator depends on the setting of stable roles within organization. What if roles are unstable, or in the case of large organization? • The Coordinator supports the “dance” of request and commitment. What if the pattern is maintained but the actual content is confused? • The actual working environment is not coordinative but competitive. Will the Coordinator succeed in such a competitive environment? • What if we do an iterative work like the design, prototype, evaluation cycles with the Coordinator?

  16. Fernando Flores • 1979. Management and Communication in the Office of the Future. PhD Thesis, Department of Philosophy, University of California at Berkerly. • Principal author of this paper, at the time of writing(1988) was associated with Action Technologies in Emeryville. • Dr. Fernando Flores is founder and former CEO of Business Design Associates which he recently sold.   In addition, Dr. Flores founded Action Technologies, Inc and introduced new distinctions in Workflow Analysis, GroupWare software design and business process analysis. • In the late 1980's and early 90's, Dr. Flores designed and presented numerous educational programs through Logonet, Inc.  He is now living in Chile and has been recently elected to the senate there.

  17. Terry Winograd • Professor Winograd's focus is on human-computer interaction design, with a focus on the theoretical background and conceptual models. He directs the teaching programs in Human-Computer Interaction and HCI research in the Stanford Interactivity Lab. He is also a principal investigator in the Stanford Digital Libraries Project and the Interactive Workspaces Project. • 1970 M.I.T -- Ph.D. (Applied Mathematics), 1967 University College, London – (Linguistics), 1966 The Colorado College – B.A. (Mathematics) • http://www-pcd.stanford.edu/winograd/

  18. Books • Bringing Design to Software, Addison-Wesley, 1996.  • with Paul Adler (eds.), Usability: Turning Technologies Into Tools, New York: Oxford University Press, 1992.  • with Fernando Flores, Understanding Computers and Cognition: A New Foundation for Design, (220 pp.) Norwood, NJ: Ablex, 1986. Paperback issued by Addison-Wesley, 1987, translations published in Italian, Spanish, German, French and Japanese.  • Language as a Cognitive Process: Volume I: Syntax , (650 pp.) Reading MA: Addison-Wesley, 1983.  • Articles • Brad Johanson, Terry Winograd, and Armando Fox, Interactive Workspaces, IEEE Computer 36:4 (April 2003), 99-103. • Winograd, Terry (2001), Interaction Spaces for 21st Century Computing, in John Carroll (ed.), Human-Computer Interaction in the New Millennium, Addison-Wesley, 2001. • "Thinking machines: Can there be? Are We?," in James Sheehan and Morton Sosna, eds., The Boundaries of Humanity: Humans, Animals, Machines, Berkeley: University of California Press, 1990. Reprinted in D. Partridge and Y. Wilks, The Foundations of Artificial Intelligence, Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1990.  • "Strategic computing research and the universities," in D. Schuler and J. Jacky, eds., Directions and Implications of Advanced Computing, Norwood NJ: Ablex, 1989, pp. 18-32. 

  19. Michael Graves • Flores, Fernando and Michael Graves, Reading a Text, 1-11. Berkeley, California: Logonet, Inc., 1985 • Flores, C. F. & Graves, M. (1986a). Domains of permanent human concerns. Unpublished report, Logonet Inc., Berkeley. • Flores, C. F. & Graves, M. (1986b). Designing education. Unpublished report, Logonet Inc., Berkeley.

  20. Brad Hartfield • Learning HCI design: mentoring project groups in a course on human-computer interaction B. Hartfield, Terry Winograd, John Bennett Proceedings of the SIGCSE ‘92 Technical Symposium of the ACM, March, 1992 • Winograd, Terry, with John Bennett, Laura De Young, and Bradley Hartfield (eds.), Bringing Design to Software , Reading, MA: Addison Wesley, 1996. • Teaching at Stanford 1996

More Related