Water What can the irrigation industry learn from Australia?

1. Water What can the irrigation industry learn from Australia? Prof Mike Young Director, The Environment Institute Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide 31 July 2009

2. Water • The irrigation industry depends on access to water • Adapting to change • Urban and industrial demand is drawing water away from agriculture;and • Supply may be decreasing • Industry prosperity will depend on its capacity to rapidly access water in an rapidly changing world.

3. Some Australian mistakes • Climate shifts • We forgot to plan for shifts to a dryer regimes • We still call what’s happening “a drought” • Rights, policy and governance • We embraced water reform without establishing a property right system that was designed for trading

4. River Murray Inflows (GL) In 2006/07, we broke the month by month minimum inflow record for 11 months Inflows have been well below evaporative losses Managed by running down stocks and reducing evaporation by closing off wetlands and not replenishing lakes This last year has been the third driest ever!

5. Robust planning and water entitlement regimes are essential. Communities rarely plan for severe adversity! • When dramatically adverse climate change occurred, many management plans has to be suspended! • Last year, high security licences in SA on 18%. This year they start with 2%!

6. Symptoms - The River Murray • Over-allocation • Dredges in its mouth since Oct 2002 • Level below the sea • Rising salinity • Serious acid-sulphate soil problems

7. - 1% - 3% Insufficient planning for step changes

8. With half as much water Users Users Environment Environment River Flow River Flow

9. A robust sharing system Flood water Entitlements Entitlements Environment Environment with a fully-specified share Volume of water available Shared Water Now buying back water for the MDB environment $3.1 billion Water needed to ensure conveyance

10. Users Environment River Flow With half as much water Users Users Environment Environment River Flow River Flow

11. Which future is best? • One that gets water fundamentals right, now? • A system that can be confidently explained as one that will enable the irrigation industry to cope -- whatever future arrives • One that facilitates autonomous adjustment and change • One that creates opportunity • One that is always behind, always playing catch up? • No guarantee of resolution of current problems • Lots of impediments to change • Beyond Triple Bottom Line to system design for autonomous adaptation

12. Australian water rights & policy • Share rather than seniority system • In rivers, usually two surface water pools • High security pool • Low or general security pool • Formal volumetric allocation systems • All use is metered and use limited to allocation • Minimal role for courts and lawyers • Allocations and rules decided by government of the day • Legislative plans that fully specify the rules of the game • Right to trade held by individual water users not districts

13. Single Title to Land with a Water Licence National CompetitionPolicy 1993/94Plus Cap Water Land Tradable Right Price Entitlement Sharesin Perpetuity Use licences with limits & obligations Bank-like Allocations Delivery Capacity Allocations SalinityShares SalinityAllocations Delivery Capacity Shares Water Rights Reform & unbundling National Water Initiative2004 Now trying to fix the problems created by the naive introduction of markets bolted onto an entitlement regimes that lacked hydrological, environmental & economic integrity

14. Water Reform Trading opened up Scarcity and Trading • Source: Murray Darling Basin Commission, 2007. Trading has been good for the Australia’s irrigation industry

15. Reform Outcomes • Positive • Facilitated considerable greenfield development • Grapes • Almonds • Massive innovation • Massive wealth creation • Many more irrigators survived the current long dry • Movement of water out of areas with salinity environmental problems • Negative • Over-allocation still not solved

16. Psi-Delta 2007 Bjornlund and Rossini 2007 Water reform created Wealth

17. Water reform • Driven by political realization about the importance of getting water right • States have referred MDB planning powers to Federal Government • New independent Authority of 6 people to produce a new Basin Plan • Buying water entitlements for the Environment • Investing in water efficiency • Trying to remove remaining barriers to trade • Taking climate change risk seriously

18. CSIRO Sustainable Yield Project, 2008

19. Advice from the lessons Aust has learned Regime arrangements • System connectivity – manage GW and SW as one • Capping use – cap entitlement potential not use • Return flows – account for them • Unmetered uses – include them in the entitlement system • Climate change – plan for an adverse shift • The environment’s share – define it and allocate to it Individual license arrangements • Registers – validate them early • Entitlements - define entitlements as shares of defined pools • Trading – Get costs and settlement time down & keep lawyers out • Control – Unbundle so you can manage at correct scales • Inter-seasonal risk management – allow markets to optimize carry forward (don’t worry about beneficial use) • Exit fees – Allocate water to individuals or them to trade out of districts – communities will be OK • Trading risk – develop tagged trading

20. Water reform and your industry • Encourage discussion of and planning for very long drys – build system to manage with very little water before the big dry comes • Encourage transfer of ownership to individuals • Encourage replacement of seniority system with a share system designed for adverse climate change • Encourage connected management of ground and surface water as a single system • Encourage preparedness for a different water future and need to trade water on a daily basis Embrace water reform – trial itWithout reform you do not have a secure future!

21. South Australia’s new water security plan

22. South Australia’s new water security plan

23. Download our reports and subscribe to Jim McColl and my droplets at www.myoung.net.au Contact: Prof Mike Young Water Economics and Management Email: Mike.Young@adelaide.edu.au Phone: +61-8-8303.5279Mobile: +61-408-488.538 www.myoung.net.au

24. Water Use-Efficiency in Australia • Australian irrigators have increased water use efficiency significantly • 1991 -2001 water use per hectare down by 50% • Area under irrigation only reduced by 6% • This has been driven by • Low rates of agricultural protection • Water reform - since 1994 • Improved entitlement and risk specification • Water trading • Separation of policy from delivery • Impact of prolonged drought since 2001

25. Trends in Rice productivity, MIA Over last 25 years rice yields have risen from 5 to 10 tonnes per hectare Source: Modified from Humphreys and Robinson (2003).

26. National Water Reform • Competition policy followed by a National Water Initiative • Recognition of Scarcity – freeze on new licences • Separation of water title from land and trading • Administrative separation • Full cost pricing (Lower Bound) • Formal Planning • Reduced allocations per entitlement

27. Competition payments to MDB states (A$millions) NSW fined A$26 million for non-delivery of water reform milestones Source: NCC. 13th January 2008.

28. Administrative separation - Murrumbidgee • Source: After Young et al. 2006. Separation of policy from water supply has lowed costs. Allow irrigators to own and run their supply systems