1 / 10

Same selves?

Same selves?. Identification of identity: a social perspective from a legal-philosophical point of view. identification in terms of correlations presumes comparability. identification as ipse uniqueness in sense of incomparability. What is identity? What is identification?. sameness.

gaetan
Download Presentation

Same selves?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Same selves? Identification of identity: a social perspective from a legal-philosophical point of view WP2 kick-off meeting

  2. identification in terms of correlations presumes comparability identification as ipse uniqueness in sense of incomparability What is identity?What is identification? sameness selfhood WP2 kick-off meeting

  3. sameness verification authentification comparison with template/profile in central database on chip chains of id’s 3rd person perspective selfhood embodied situated relational fuzzy underdetermined performative 1st person perspective WP2 kick-off meeting

  4. Technology is neither good nor bad, nor is it neutral Kevin Kranzberg WP2 kick-off meeting

  5. If self-identity is: • interactional; • under permanent (re)construction; • shifting in time and between different (role-)sets; • embodied; • experiencing the world through artefacts (technologies like eyeglasses or cars) • than identification based on sameness (instrumented by id-technologies) co-produces identity in the sense of selfhood, while at the same time selfhood co-produces sameness-id. WP2 kick-off meeting

  6. Latour’s production of hybrids: • co-production of humans and non-humans • Roger Clarke’s digital persona • (digital biography via continuous data-traces and data-tracing • (profiles: correlated humans • relation to the concept of legal persona WP2 kick-off meeting

  7. The legal and political concept of subject (persona) is constitutive for democracy and rule of law. • If rule of law safeguards the constitution of a system that allows a minority to become majority, while the majority rules, • than this implies facilitating and protecting the underdeterminacy of the identity of subjects. • Need to rethink identity in information society especially the distinction and the relation between sameness-id and selfhood-id WP2 kick-off meeting

  8. As to the definition of identity and identification, a suggestion to create room for: • the distinction between selfhood-id and sameness-id • acknowledgement of co-production, hybrids, profiles • the underdeterminate character of selfhood-id (freedom) in combination with the need for determination of the sameness-id (certainty, security) WP2 kick-off meeting

  9. selfhood/sameness legal tools of opacity limits to power shields protection of autonomy prohibitions example: privacy protection facilitation & protection of selfhood, by means of sameness (legal and technological) sameness/selfhood legal tools of transparency channeling of power accountability and controlability of power example: data protection facilitation & protection of selfhood, by means of sameness (legal and technological) de Hert/Gutwirth WP2 kick-off meeting

  10. definition identifiabilityinspired by the work done by Marit Hansen and her group and comments of D-O Jaquet Chiffelle • Identifiability (in sense of sameness/correlations) is the possibility of being individualized (detected) within a set of subjects, the identifiability-set. • An identity (in sense of sameness/correlations) is any subset of correlations that render an individual detectable within a set of individuals, the identifiability-set • Now take fuzzy-set logic into account and you come very close to identifiability in the sense of selfhood. • Identifiability (in sense selfhood) is interactional, performative and underdetermined WP2 kick-off meeting

More Related