280 likes | 366 Views
FUNDACION CASTILLA DEL PINO ABORDAJES PSICOTERAPEUTICO DE LOS TRASTORNOS PSIQUIATRICOS Cordoba, Marzo 2009. INVESTIGACION EN PSICOTERAPIA DINAMICA BREVE Manuel Trujillo, M.D. Professor of Psychiatry New York University.
E N D
FUNDACION CASTILLA DEL PINO ABORDAJES PSICOTERAPEUTICO DE LOS TRASTORNOS PSIQUIATRICOS Cordoba, Marzo 2009
INVESTIGACION EN PSICOTERAPIADINAMICA BREVE Manuel Trujillo, M.D. Professor of Psychiatry New York University
BIOLOGICAL CORRELATES OF PSYCHOTHERAPYFIGURE I -3 -2 -1 0 2 3 1 Average (no treatment) control effect size Average psychotherapy effect size (.82) Average Minimal Treatment (placebo) effect size (.42) Adapted from Lambert, et al. 1993
TABLE IMETA-ANALYTIC REVIEWS OF OUTCOME WITH DEPRESSION * Adapted from Lambert, et al. (1994)
TABLE IIMETA-ANALYTIC REVIEWS OF OUTCOME WITH ANXIETY DISORDERS * Percent improved , ** Pretest/Posttest measure Modified from Lambert (1994)
TABLE IIIMETA-ANALYTIC REVIEWS OF OUTCOME WITH ANXIETY DISORDERS * Percent improved , ** Pretest/Posttest measure Modified from Lambert (1994)
Criteria for Admission to the StudyInclusion Criteria • Age between 18 and 60 • Evidence of at least one close personal relationship • No evidence of psychosis, organic brain syndrome or mental retardation • Absence of active Axis III medical diagnosis • No evidence of substance abuse • Not actively suicidal • No history of violence or destructive impulse control problem • No recent psychotropic medication such as neuroleptics, antidepressants, Lithium, etc.
Assessment Instruments • Social History • Target Complaints • Symptom Checklist (SCL-90) • Social Adjustment Scale - SR • Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire (PDQ)
Reliability of Six Combination VariablesProcess Coding of Videotaped Psychotherapy Sessions VariableThree Judges Pooled Transference Interpretation .93 followed by affect Transference Interpretation .75 followed by defense Non-transference Interpretation .84 followed by affect Non-transference Interpretation .67 followed by defense Clarification Interpretation .62 followed by affect Clarification Interpretation .63 followed by defense
Admission & Termination Means and Effect Sizes* for Significant Findings on the SCL-90 and SAS Subscales Across Groups
Admission & Termination Means and Effect Sizes for Global Outcomes Across Groups
Subscales with STDP showing significant differences over BAP and controls
Average Frequencies of Occurrence and Comparative Percentages Per Session of Therapist Behaviors in the Two Treatment Groups
Stepwise Regression For Affect and Defense Variables On Composite Outcome Score Multiple R Squared = .66 (F Value=7.71; df=3 and 12)
Partial Correlations of Affect Variables & Outcome(with Defensive Responding Partialed Out Composite Outcome Clarification followed by Affect .09 Nontransference Interpretation followed by Affect .44 Transference Interpretation followed by Affect .73 All Interventions followed by Affect .58
BEST/WORST OUTCOMES BEST OUTCOME WORST OUTCOME STDP 2-Obsessional 1- Histrionic 1 - Mixed BAP 1- Histrionic 2- Obsessional 1- Mixed
BIOLOGICAL CORRELATES OF PSYCHOTERAPY PSYCHOTHERAPY CHANGE AGENTS • Affective experiencing • Cognitive mastery • Behavioral regulation
BIOLOGICAL CORRELATES OF PSYCHOTHERAPY AFFECTIVE EXPERIENCE • Implosion therapy Flooding • Gestalt therapy Emotional Experience • Psychodrama Role playing • STDP Impulse/Feelings Experiencing
BIOLOGICAL CORRELATES OF PSYCHOTHERAPY COGNITIVE MASTERY • Psychoan. therapy Interpretation • Supportive Clarification, support • Cognitive Modification of beliefs
BIOLOGICAL CORRELATES OF PSYCHOTHERAPY BEHAVIORAL REGULATION • Behavior therapy Conditioning • Assertiveness Skills develop. therapy • Token economy Modification of rewards system
PSYCHOTHERAPY AND NEUROBIOLOGY Cortex Pre Frontal Cortex - + Stimulus Amygdala Hippocampus Thalamus
PSYCHOTHERAPY AND NEUROBIOLOGY Stress Glucocorticoids Glutamate Moderate duration stress Severe and prolonged stress CA3 Reversible atrophy and loss of dendritic spines Neuronal death * Adapted from Kandel, 1999
THE MIRROR NEURON SYSTEMRizzollati 1995 • Subset of multimodal neurons (Simultaneous activation by different sensory modalities) • F5 in monkeys • Broca 44, 45 in humans (Prefrontal Cortex)
THE MIRROR NEURON SYSTEM Activated by: • Observing a meaningful action • Performing the same action • Basis for primitive learning/communicating with others
THE MIRROR NEURON SYSTEM Plays a role in: • Affect resonance • Empathy • Group behaviors: hunting, dancing • Language development