600 likes | 606 Views
Dr. Glenn Mueller, a renowned Real Estate Investment Strategist, offers insights on maximizing portfolio growth potential through smart real estate investments. Learn about market cycles and property types to make informed investment decisions.
E N D
Glenn R. Mueller, Ph.D. Professor University of Denver Franklin L. Burns School of Real Estate & Construction Management & Real Estate Investment Strategist Dividend Capital Research glenn.mueller@du.edu
Dr. Glenn Mueller • Real Estate Investment Strategist – Dividend Capital Group • Professor – University of Denver – Franklin L. Burns School of Real Estate & Construction Management • Visiting Professor – Harvard University, 2002-2008 & summer executive education semesters • Guest Lecturer – Wharton School, Yale, Berkeley, Ohio State, UNC, USC, European Business School, University of Regensburg Previous Experience • Legg Mason – Real Estate Investment Strategist • PriceWaterhouseCoopers – National Director of Real Estate Research • Alex. Brown Kleinwort Benson – Head of Real Estate Research • Prudential Real Estate Investors – Vice President of Real Estate Research • B.S.B.A. in finance from the University of Denver • MBA from Babson College • Ph.D. in Real Estate from Georgia State University
DU Founded 1864 Daniels COB ranked top 50 - WSJ • 550 Students Earning Degrees • Undergraduate - BSBA • Graduate – MBA & MS • Executive – MS Real Estate, Construction Management, RECM, RE & Accounting, Finance, Marketing, Management, International Business, Law
Why Real Estate Fits A Portfolio = Size U.S. Real Estate vs. Other Asset Classes - 12/06 Source: Pension & Investments, October 30, 2006 and Prudential Real Estate Investors, December 2006.
All Real Estate = Half - 12/06 U.S. Real Estate Values = $33.3 Trillion Source: Prudential Real Estate Investors, December 2006.
Market Cycle Analysis Physical Cycle Demand & Supply drive Occupancy Occupancy drives Rental Growth
Market Cycle Quadrants Phase 3 - Hypersupply Phase 2 - Expansion Demand/Supply Equilibrium Point Increasing Vacancy Declining Vacancy New Construction Occupancy New Construction Long Term Vacancy Average Increasing Vacancy Declining Vacancy More Completions No New Construction Phase 1 - Recovery Phase 4 - Recession Legg Mason Real Estate Research Time
Demand/Supply Equilibrium High Rent Growth in Rent Growth Rents Rise Tight Market Positive But Rapidly Declining Toward New Construction Occupancy Levels Cost Feasible New Construction Rents Long Term Average Occupancy Below - Inflation & Negative Below Rent Physical Inflation Growth Rental Market Cycle Negative Growth Rental Characteristics Growth Time
Historic National Office Rental Growth 11.0% 10.5% 11 6.1% 10 12 6.4% 9 12.5% 3.3% 13 10.0% 8 Long Term Average Occupancy 7 Occupancy 6 14 1.7% 6.7% 5 0.3% 15 4.0% 4 -1.0% -3.0% 1.6% 3 2.7% 16 2 1 1 30 Year Cycle - Periods 1968-1997 -1.5% Time
Historic National Industrial Rental Growth % 8.3% 6.8% 11 4.6% 10 12 5.1% 9 5.9% 4.8% 8.5% 13 8 Long Term Avg Occupancy 7 Occupancy 3.8% 3.0% 6 14 5 -2.1% 15 4.6% 4 -0.4% 0.8% 3 0.7% 0.4% 16 2 1 1 30 Year Cycle - Periods 1968-1997 2.8% Time
National Property Type Cycle Locations Phase II - Expansion Phase III-Hypersupply Retail - 1st-Tier Regional Malls Retail - NH & Com Power Center Retail Health Facility 11 Hotel - Full-Service 10 12 9 Retail - Factory Outlet Industrial - Warehouse 8 13 LT Average Occupancy 7 6 14 Industrial - R&D Flex 15 Apartment Senior Housing Hotel - Ltd. Service 5 16 1 4 1 3 2 Office - Downtown Retail - 2nd Tier Regional Malls Office - Suburban 1st Qtr 2008 Phase I - Recovery Phase IV - Recession Source: Mueller, 2008
Office Market Cycle Analysis 1st Quarter, 2008 • Dallas FW • Ft. Lauderdale-1 • Hartford • Indianapolis • Kansas City • Long Island • Las Vegas-1 • Memphis • Minneapolis • St. Louis • Stamford • W. Palm Beach-1 Honolulu Miami Wash DC Austin Charlotte+1 Denver Houston New York Los Angeles New Orleans-1 Oklahoma City Orange County Phoenix-1 Raleigh-Durham Salt Lake San Jose Tampa 11 Albuquerque Baltimore Cincinnati Cleveland Columbus Detroit Milwaukee Norfolk Pittsburgh 10 12 9 8 13 7 San Antonio+1 6 14 LT Average Occupancy 15 5 16 1 4 1 3 Boston East Bay Orlando Portland Sacramento San Diego San Francisco Seattle NATION 2 Atlanta Chicago Jacksonville Nashville Philadelphia Riverside-1 N. New Jersey Richmond Wilmington Source: Mueller, 2008
Industrial Market Cycle Analysis 1st Quarter, 2008 Los Angeles Orange County Riverside-1 Chicago Cincinnati Dallas FW-1 Indianapolis Milwaukee Minneapolis New York Orlando-1 Philadelphia St. Louis+1 Stamford Ft. Lauderdale Houston Kansas City+1 Norfolk+1 Richmond Salt Lake Seattle 11 Las Vegas Portland San Francisco San Jose 10 12 Atlanta Baltimore Boston Columbus Hartford Tampa 9 8 13 7 East Bay New Orleans+1 W. Palm Beach 6 14 15 LT Average Occupancy Jacksonville Phoenix Sacramento San Antonio San Diego 5 16 1 4 1 3 2 Austin-1 Charlotte Denver Honolulu Long Island Memphis Miami Nashville N. New Jersey Oklahoma City Raleigh-Durham Wash DC NATION Cleveland Detroit Pittsburgh Source: Mueller, 2008
Apartment Market Cycle Analysis Austin+2 Jacksonville Las Vegas Ft. Lauderdale Miami Norfolk Sacramento Wash DC 1st Quarter, 2008 East Bay N. New Jersey Portland San Jose NATION New Orleans+2 Salt Lake Orange County+1 Phoenix+1 Riverside+1 San Diego+1 11 Baltimore Denver Philadelphia Seattle 10 12 Orlando+1 Tampa+1 W Palm Beach+1 9 Cincinnati+1 Houston Long Island Nashville Richmond-1 St. Louis 8 Chicago Los Angeles 13 7 New York San Francisco 6 14 Indianapolis Raleigh-Durham LT Average Occupancy Atlanta Boston Columbus Dallas FW Honolulu Kansas City Minneapolis Oklahoma City 15 5 16 1 4 1 3 2 Charlotte-1 Cleveland Detroit Memphis Pittsburgh San Antonio Stamford Hartford Milwaukee Source: Mueller, 2008
Retail Market Cycle Analysis 1st Quarter, 2008 East Bay Long Island New York Orange County San Diego San Francisco Wash DC Baltimore Ft. Lauderdale Honolulu+1 Portland Richmond+1 Seattle St. Louis NATION Cincinnati-1 Cleveland Columbus Hartford-1 Milwaukee-1 Nashville W. Palm Beach-1 Oklahoma City 11 Boston Los Angeles San Jose 10 12 Kansas City Pittsburgh Raleigh-Durham 9 Chicago+1 Orlando+1 Phoenix+1 8 13 LT Average Occupancy 7 Memphis-1 New Orleans Riverside-1 San Antonio 6 14 N. New Jersey Philadelphia Miami+1 Norfolk+1 Sacramento Salt Lake Tampa+1 15 5 1 4 16 1 3 2 Dallas FW Denver Houston-1 Minneapolis Stamford Atlanta Austin Jacksonville-3 Las Vegas Charlotte-1 Detroit-1 Indianapolis Source: Mueller, 2008
Hotel Market Cycle Analysis Atlanta Chicago Denver Ft. Lauderdale+1 Norfolk Philadelphia-1 Phoenix-1 Portland Raleigh-Durham Richmond Riverside-1 San Antonio Stamford Seattle W. Palm Beach NATION 1st Quarter, 2008 Austin East Bay Honolulu+1 Long Island Los Angeles 11 10 12 9 Cincinnati Hartford+1 Indianapolis Pittsburgh Tampa-1 Houston New York San Diego San Francisco+1 8 13 7 Charlotte Jacksonville Miami Nashville Oklahoma City Orange County Orlando San Jose Wash DC 14 6 Columbus St. Louis LT Average Occupancy 5 15 Boston+1 Dallas Las Vegas Memphis Milwaukee Minneapolis Sacramento Salt Lake-1 16 1 4 1 3 2 Baltimore-1 Detroit Kansas City New Orleans N. New Jersey Cleveland Source: Mueller, 2008
1970s Cycle • Factors Driving The First Half Cycle (5 Year) • Strong Demand from the 1960s that stopped • Recession 1974 • Capital Flow - Mortgage REITs produced oversupply • Factors Driving The Second Half Cycle (5 Year) • Baby Boom Generation Goes to Work = Demand • Capital Flow Shut Down = no supply = Lenders Recover • Markets tighten and reach peak occupancy 1979 (5% vacancy)
Oversupply Years Baby Boomers Go To Work Source: FW Dodge, CB Commercial, BLS, Mueller
1980s Cycle • Factors Driving The First Half Cycle (5 Year) • Tight market in 1979 pushes rents and prices up • Tax Act of 1981 attracts taxable investors supply up • Inflation pushes real estate prices higher • Thrift Deregulation allows capital to flow • Factors Driving The Second Half Cycle (5 Year) • Tax Act of 1986 slows taxable investors, but not tax free • Poor stock market attracts Pension & Foreign capital • Rising R.E. prices masks poor income returns
Oversupply Years Source: FW Dodge, CB Commercial, BLS, Mueller
1990s Cycle • Factors Driving The First Half Cycle (5 Year) • Moderate but stable demand growth (1991 recession minor) • Oversupply and Foreclosures shut down construction • Excess space absorbed - bringing markets back • Factors Driving The Second Half Cycle (5 Year) • Moderate Demand growth Continues • Oversupply absorbed and return performance improves • Construction “constrained” causing rents & prices to rise • More efficient markets match supply to demand
Demand Supply Matched Oversupply Absorbed Source: FW Dodge, CB Commercial, BLS, Mueller
2000s Cycle • Demand • Globalization - creates stable U.S. economy • Job Growth out of Technology Change • 2.7 million population growth per year for 10 years • Baby boomers at “highest income earning” years • second home market wave • Echo boom children – college, first job, & renting • Aging population not a major factor till 2014 • Employment growth drives commercial demand
2000s Cycle Demand Age 0-60: Percent of Total Population Source: U.S. Census Bureau, November 2006.
2000s Cycle Change in 20-29 Year Old Age Cohort 1,500,000 Baby Boom 1,000,000 Echo Boom 500,000 - (500,000) Gen X (1,000,000) 1962 1964 1966 1968 1970 1972 1974 1976 1978 1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2008E 2010E 2012E 2014E 2004 2006 Source: National Center for Health Statistics and Mueller estimates
Government Stimulus Working? % of GDP Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Office of Management & Budget
Any U.S. Recession Should be MILD The Rest of the World is Growing Well Export growth supports demand for industrial space. 2008 GDP % Growth Source: World Bank estimates Source: World Bank estimates
2000s Cycle • Supply Constraint • Public Markets make R.E. Capital markets efficient • Economically driven capital - low spec construction • 500 + Research watchdogs – Data Available • Constrained Supply (economically driven capital) • construction labor harder to find • materials costs increasing • infrastructure problems constrain growth • Feedback loop keeps demand and supply in better balance • greater transparency • Faster reaction to demand slowdown
2000s US Office Demand & Supply FORECAST Demand 1.41% Supply 1.44% Supply Reacted to Demand Slow Down Source: Property & Portfolio Research, Grubb & Ellis, Mueller 2007.
National Property Type Cycle Forecast Phase II - Expansion Phase III-Hypersupply Health Facility Hotel - Full-Service Retail - 1st Tier Regional Malls Neighborhood/Community Retail+1 Power Center Retail 11 10 12 Apartment 9 8 Office - Suburban Senior Housing 13 7 6 14 LT Average Occupancy Hotel - Ltd. Service 15 5 16 1 4 1 3 Office – Downtown Retail - Factory Outlet 2 Retail 2nd -Tier Regional Malls Industrial –Warehouse 1st Qtr 2009 ESTIMATE Industrial - R&D Flex Phase I - Recovery Phase IV - Recession Source: Mueller, 2008
Office Occupancy & Rent Cycle Forecast 1.7% Source: Property & Portfolio Research, Grubb & Ellis, Mueller 2008.
Office Market Cycle FORECAST 1st Quarter, 2009 Estimate Chicago Jacksonville Kansas City Las Vegas-1 Memphis Minneapolis Norfolk N. New Jersey Richmond Riverside Stamford St. Louis 11 Dallas FW New Orleans Miami-1 Oklahoma City Orange County Orlando-1 Sacramento Salt Lake Denver New York 10 12 9 8 13 LT Average Occupancy 7 6 14 Austin-1 Honolulu Houston-1 San Antonio San Francisco 15 5 16 1 4 1 3 2 Boston Charlotte East Bay Portland San Diego San Jose Seattle Wash DC NATION Atlanta Ft. Lauderdale-1 Hartford Indianapolis Long Island Los Angeles Nashville Phoenix-1 Raleigh-Durham Tampa W. Palm Beach-1 Baltimore Cincinnati Cleveland Columbus Detroit Milwaukee Philadelphia Pittsburgh Baltimore Cincinnati Cleveland Columbus Detroit Milwaukee Philadelphia Pittsburgh Source: Mueller, 2008
Industrial Occ. Cycle & Rent Growth 1.2% Source: Property & Portfolio Research, Grubb & Ellis, Mueller 2007.
Industrial Market Cycle FORECAST 1st Quarter, 2009 Estimate Denver Houston Jacksonville Long Island Memphis Milwaukee Norfolk Phoenix Raleigh-Durham+1 Richmond Sacramento Salt Lake Wash DC Los Angeles New Orleans 11 Las Vegas Riverside San Jose San Francisco W. Palm Beach 10 12 9 Atlanta Baltimore Cleveland Columbus Hartford Pittsburgh St. Louis 8 Orange County 13 7 6 14 LT Average Occupancy East Bay 15 5 Portland San Diego 16 1 4 1 3 2 Austin Charlotte Ft. Lauderdale Honolulu Kansas City Minneapolis New York Orlando Philadelphia Seattle-1 NATION Detroit Boston Chicago Cincinnati Dallas FW Indianapolis Miami Nashville-1 N. New Jersey Oklahoma City San Antonio Stamford Tampa Source: Mueller, 2008
Apartment Occ. Cycle & Rent Growth 3.8% Source: Property & Portfolio Research, Grubb & Ellis, Mueller 2008.
Apartment Market Cycle FORECAST 1st Quarter, 2009 Estimates New Orleans+1 San Diego Wash DC Salt Lake Austin Ft. Lauderdale+1 Las Vegas+1 Miami+1 Norfolk+1 Orange County Riverside Chicago Baltimore Boston Kansas City Oklahoma City Richmond St. Louis East Bay N. New Jersey 11 10 12 9 San Jose+1 San Francisco Jacksonville+1 Phoenix+2 Sacramento+2 Charlotte Cleveland Detroit Indianapolis 8 13 Los Angeles New York Portland 7 6 14 Atlanta Columbus Denver Honolulu Nashville Minneapolis Philadelphia Seattle NATION LT Average Occupancy 15 5 16 1 4 Orlando+2 Tampa+2 W. Palm Beach+2 1 3 2 Cincinnati Dallas FW-1 Houston Long Island Pittsburgh Stamford Memphis San Antonio Hartford Milwaukee-1 RaleighDurham Source: Mueller, 2008
Retail Occ. Cycle & Rent Growth 1.4% Source: Property & Portfolio Research, Grubb & Ellis, Mueller 2007.
Retail Market Cycle FORECAST 1st Quarter, 2009 Estimates East Bay New York Oklahoma City Orange County San Francisco Wash DC 11 Los Angeles Dallas FW Denver Milwaukee Minneapolis W. Palm Beach 10 Chicago Miami Richmond Tampa 12 9 Pittsburgh Stamford Boston 8 Atlanta Austin Orlando+1 San Antonio Sacramento+1 13 Cleveland-1 Indianapolis Las Vegas Nashville Riverside LT Average Occupancy 7 6 14 Baltimore Ft. Lauderdale Honolulu+1 Long Island Norfolk Portland San Diego Seattle St. Louis NATION Philadelphia San Jose 15 5 16 1 4 1 3 Phoenix Salt Lake 2 Houston N. New Jersey Raleigh-Durham Charlotte Cincinnati Columbus Detroit Hartford-1 Kansas City Memphis Jacksonville New Orleans Source: Mueller, 2008
Hotel Occ. Cycle & Rent Growth 6.5% Source: Property & Portfolio Research, Grubb & Ellis, Mueller 2007.
Hotel Market Cycle FORECAST 1st Quarter, 2009 Estimates East Bay Houston Long Island San Jose San Francisco Charlotte Denver Jacksonville-1 Nashville Oklahoma City Orange County Portland Richmond Riverside Wash DC NATION Dallas FW Hartford Memphis Minneapolis Raleigh-Durham-2 Stamford Los Angeles New York 11 10 12 9 Baltimore-2 Detroit Kansas City St. Louis Tampa-1 8 13 Austin Chicago Honolulu Miami Orlando Philadelphia San Diego-1 LT Average Occupancy 7 6 14 Atlanta Boston Ft. Lauderdale-1 Las Vegas Milwaukee Norfolk Phoenix Sacramento Salt Lake Seattle New Orleans-1 15 5 16 1 4 1 3 2 Cincinnati Columbus Indianapolis N. New Jersey Pittsburgh San Antonio-1 W. Palm Beach-1 Cleveland Source: Mueller, 2008
Market Information used to: • determine competitive position • set lease strategy • determine improvements program
Real Estate Financial Cycles Capital Flows Affect Prices
Market Cycle Capital Flow Impact Hyper Supply Capital Flows to Existing Properties Cost Feasible Rents Reached LT Occupancy Avg. Property Market Cycle Total Capital Flow Cycle Capital Flows to New Construction
National Office Physical Market Cyclevs. Financial Cycle = New Permit Values 6 year lag Physical Financial No Lag Source: CB Commercial, Census Bureau Source: BEA, CB Commercial, Mueller
Flow of Funds Commercial MortgagesAll Sectors (1976 - 2001) False Price Appreciation Support ($ Mils) ? Public Market Volatility Source: Federal Reserve
Property Price Movement Source: Real Estate Research Corporation - Chicago
Property Prices Strong Source: Real Estate Research Corporation - Chicago
Transaction Pricing 36/1636 deals 25/1319 deals 33/1624 deals 37/1798 deals Source: Real Capital Analytics, New York www.rcanalytics.com
Transaction Pricing Q3 2006 Cap Rates 9.0 Denver 8.5 US 8.0 7.5 7.5 7.1 6.9 7.0 6.6 6.4 6.3 6.5 5.8 6.0 5.5 5.8 Office Industrial Retail Apartment 94/3512 deals 26/2871 deals 39/2703 deals 63/3922 deals Source: Real Capital Analytics, New York www.rcanalytics.com
Supply • The new supply of space was down in 2006 and 2007 and the forecast is for moderate supply growth – well below the long-term average Commercial Real Estate Supply Growth Source: Property & Portfolio Research & Dividend Capital Research.