1 / 22

Insights into Patrolling: Balancing Authority and Discretion

Delve into the world of police patrols, exploring their objectives, challenges, and evolution over the years. Understand the significance of beat culture, shift assignments, and the use of patrol vehicles in maintaining community safety. Explore past experiments and strategies in patrol deployment and learn about the complexities of discretionary police authority.

ggloria
Download Presentation

Insights into Patrolling: Balancing Authority and Discretion

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. CHAPTER 5 On Patrol

  2. On Patrol • Patrol as Work • Purposes and Nature of Patrol • Deployment should consider the where and when of crime • Many still deploy patrols based upon convenient beat dividers • Major purposes of patrol, according to ABA • To deter crime by maintaining a visible presence

  3. On Patrol • To maintain public order • To enable the police department to respond quickly to law violators or other emergencies • To identify and apprehend law violators • To aid individuals and care for those who cannot help themselves • To facilitate the movement of traffic and people • To create a sense of security in the community

  4. On Patrol • “JDLR” • “Just doesn’t look right” • Nonemergency calls to 911 • Detroit and Los Angeles staff over 60 percent of patrol units with two officers • Atlanta and Baltimore have no two-officer units • Most agencies assign 77 to 95 percent of their patrols resources to automobiles

  5. On Patrol • Patrol Work as a Function of Shift Assignment • Shift assignments • Day shift have the greatest contact with the citizens • Usually, officers with the most seniority work the day shift • Swing shift usually makes more arrests than day shift • Night shift is a different world • The shift is busy at the start and then the officer fights boredom at the end of the shift

  6. On Patrol • Influences of One’s Assigned Beat • Three “cops’ rules” are part of the beat culture • Don’t get involved in another officer’s sector • Don’t leave work for the next duty shift • Hold up your end of the work

  7. On Patrol • Where Danger Lurks • During 2000, 151 police officers were killed in the line of duty • The annual average in the 1990s was 153 • The annual average in the 1980s was 187 • The annual average in the 1970s was 222

  8. On Patrol • An Unappreciated American Icon: The Patrol Vehicle • A Sanctuary and a Place for Vital Gear • A mobile haven • An office • A rolling symbol of authority • Evolution of the Patrol Vehicle

  9. On Patrol • Studies of the Patrol Function • Kansas City Preventive Patrol Experiment (1973) • City divided into 15 beats • No preventive patrol • Police only responded to calls for service

  10. On Patrol • Increased patrol activity • Usual level of service • No increase in crime in any of the patrol zones • No change in citizens’ fear of crime or their attitudes toward the police • No change in the ability of the police to respond to calls • Patrol methods ere subject to question

  11. On Patrol • Team policing • Officers were divided into small teams • Assigned permanently to small geographic areas or neighborhoods • Officers were to be generalists • The concept was abandoned because of strain on resources • Was the beginning of the movement toward COP

  12. On Patrol • Directed patrol (1975) • Computer data of crime locations and times to set up deterrent runs • The program did not reduce crime, but rather displaced it • The program quietly died • Split-force program • 1/2 of patrol assigned to basic patrol units • 1/2 were assigned to a structured unit • Deployed in high-crime areas • Police productivity increased 20% • Crime decreased 18% in the first year

  13. On Patrol • Foot patrol • Renewed interest in late 1970s • Crime levels were not affected by foot patrol • Did have significant effect on the attitudes of the area residents • Residents felt safer • Officers had higher levels of job satisfaction • Officers felt safer on the job than motor officers

  14. On Patrol • Response times • Kansas City (1977) • Study found that response time was unrelated to the probability of making an arrest or locating witnesses • Dispatch nor travel time was strongly associated with citizen satisfaction • The time it takes to report a crime is the major factor determining whether an on-scene arrest takes place and whether witnesses are located • Two-person patrol cars are no more effective than one-person cars in reducing crime or catching criminals • Injuries to police officers are not more likely to occur in one-person cars • Most officers on patrol do not stumble across felony crimes in progress

  15. On Patrol • Discretionary Use of Police Authority • Attempts to Define Discretion • If the police see something that does not look right, they must decide whether to intervene in the situation and how to intervene • In a traffic stop, police have 770 different combinations of action that may be taken

  16. On Patrol • Criminal law has two sides • Formality • Found in the statutes and opinions of the court • Reality • Found in the practices of the enforcement officers • When formality and reality differ, reality prevails

  17. On Patrol • Determinants of Disciplinary Actions • Variables that enter into the officer’s decision • The officer’s attitude • The citizen’s attitude or demeanor • The citizen’s social class, sex, age, and race • Pros, Cons, and Politics of Discretionary Authority • The inverse relationship between the officer’s rank and the amount of discretion that is available • The exercise of discretion is an essential part of police work • There is a myth of full enforcement of the laws • The issue of police discretion is shrouded in controversy

  18. On Patrol • Advantages of the use of discretion • It allows the officer to treat different situations in accordance with humanitarian and practical goals • Justice tempered with mercy • Disadvantages of the use of discretion • Partiality • Breeding ground for corruption • Police do not know the consequences of their discretionary decisions

  19. On Patrol • Police discretion is part of the American political process • State legislative commands are ambiguous • Legislatures speak with three voices • They enact state statutes that seemingly require full enforcement of the laws • They provide only enough resources for limited enforcement of them • They consent to such limited enforcement

  20. On Patrol • A Related Function: Traffic • Policing Today’s Motorized Society • Traffic stops account for about half of the contact Americans have with the police • More than half of the nearly 20 million Americans stopped will be cited • Traffic stops are a major source of friction between the police and the citizens • Crackdowns on speeding have no impact on fatality rates and have little influence on traffic violations or accident rates

  21. On Patrol • Traffic Accident Investigation • Formal training in the area of accident investigation is essential • The era of accountability and litigation • The public demands skilled accident investigations

  22. On Patrol • In Pursuit of the “Phantom Driver” • Public support for the police in their efforts to apprehend the hit-and-run drivers • Physical evidence and witness statements must be collected • The police may have to use psychology to get a confession from the hit-and-run driver

More Related