240 likes | 257 Views
This informative piece delves into the complexities of implementing TMDLs for mercury and PCBs in the San Francisco Bay region. It discusses key challenges faced, such as uncertainties, and proposes adaptive implementation strategies to make progress in attaining water quality standards. The article covers various elements of the TMDL process, including numeric targets, impairment linkages, sources, allocations, and regulatory actions. It also highlights risk reduction efforts, watershed actions, and urban runoff control hypotheses. The importance of adaptive implementation studies and strategic management approaches for mercury and PCBs are emphasized.
E N D
Mercury and PCBs TMDL Implementation Tom Mumley San Francisco Bay Regional Water Quality Control Board
Clx Clx Status of TMDLs • Mercury • Regional Board adoption September 2004 • State Board action still pending • PCBs • Draft Basin Plan package Fall 2005 • Regional Board action Winter 2006
TMDL Process Elements Numeric Target Impairment Problem Linkage TMDL Sources Allocations Implementation Actions Regulatory Actions
Hmmm… Mercury… Key Challenge Make decision despite numerous uncertainties!
Adaptive Implementation • Early actions • Scope based on available information • Improve understanding of problem, sources, system, and solutions • Make progress towards attaining water quality standards • Take action prevent, manage, control observe system’s response
TMDL Process Elements Numeric Target Impairment Problem Linkage TMDL Sources Allocations Implementation Actions Regulatory Actions
TMDL Process Elements Numeric Target Impairment Problem Linkage TMDL Sources Allocations Implementation Actions Regulatory Actions
Risk Reduction • Pollutant related health risks to consumers of bay fish • Clean Estuary Partnership Work Team • Water Board, BACWA, BASMAA • Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment, Dept of Health Services • CEP Environmental Tech Rep
Central Valley Watershed Actions • Mercury • Cache Creek TMDL • Summer 2005 • Delta TMDL • Summer 2006
Guadalupe River Watershed Actions • Mercury • TMDL Winter 2006/07 • New Almaden Mine District • Reservoirs
Dredging and Disposal Actions • Implement LTMS • Long Term Management Strategy for the Placement of Dredged Material in the San Francisco Bay Region • In-bay disposal ambient
Wastewater Actions • Maintain performance • Pollution prevention • Treatment systems • Confirm no local effects • Assist with studies • Assist with control of other sources • Strategic treatment of runoff Watershed Permit
In-Bay Hot Spots Actions • Hunters Point • Seaplane Lagoon • (Alameda NAS) • Stege Marsh • (Richmond) • Others? • Relative significance • Opportunity
Mercury and/or PCBs - Urban Runoff Control Hypotheses • Hg and PCBs are distributed throughout urban watersheds • There are hot zones of Hg and/or PCBs (elevated levels) • Sediment bound Hg and PCBs accumulate in the transmission system • There is buildup of polluted sediment near some storm drain discharge points
Urban Runoff Action • Pollution prevention (light bulbs) • Clean-up on-land, storm drain, and discharge point “hot spots” • Strategic retrofit • Operation and maintenance
Urban Runoff Action • Pollution prevention (light bulbs) • Clean-up on-land, storm drain, and discharge point “hot spots” • Strategic retrofit • Site design • Intercept/treatment • Route to sanitary sewer system • Operation and maintenance • Street sweeping • Inlet and storm drain cleaning
Hmmm… Save Bay… Adaptive Implementation Studies • Sediment and sediment-bound pollutant fate and transport • Erosion of in-bay sediments • Recovery of the bay • Urban runoff loading and effectiveness of controls • Methylation • How, where, and when? • Can we manage it?
Mercury and PCBs TMDL Implementation • Multibox model • Manage methylation • if we can • Mine cleanup • Strategic hot spot cleanup - in bay, in storm drains, and on land • Strategic urban runoff management