1 / 28

Self Confidence and Diversity at MIT

Self Confidence and Diversity at MIT. Lizz Albany, Olivia Gierlich , Peter Lee, and Michael Plasmeier. How many of you think self-esteem is important? Do you think your academic self-esteem is directly affected by your gender or race?. Agenda.

grady-lopez
Download Presentation

Self Confidence and Diversity at MIT

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Self Confidence and Diversity at MIT Lizz Albany, Olivia Gierlich, Peter Lee, and Michael Plasmeier

  2. How many of you think self-esteem is important?Do you think your academic self-esteem is directly affected by your gender or race?

  3. Agenda • Introduction: Examining the self-esteem of MIT students • Literature Review: Current theories and what makes MIT different • Research Design: Distributing our Survey • Analysis: Examining the Data for Differences • Conclusion: Are MIT students really different?

  4. Importance of Examining Self-Esteem • For individuals • self-esteem affects performance in all aspects of life • At MIT • creating a sense of equality • In America • unemployment rates are higher for minorities • self confidence is an influential component of job interviews and other work-related interactions

  5. What Current Literature has Revealed • Two conflicting schools of thought: • Minorities have lower self-esteem • Stereotype Threat • Preferential Treatment • Minorities have equal or higher self-esteem • Academic Disidentification • Social Reference Theory • General literary conclusion: minorities will have the same or higher relative self-esteem, women will have lower self-esteem relative to their peers

  6. Hypothesis:Minorities and women at MIT have a lower relative self-esteem • Why is MIT different? • Prestigious Institution • Meritocracy Attitudes • Representative Demographics • Generous Financial Aid

  7. Methods

  8. Who is our target audience? • MIT Undergraduate population • Sent to: • Dorms • Sororities • Fraternities • Student Clubs • Goal: • Collect a varied sample from across campus

  9. What did we distribute? • Short electronic survey • Consent Form • Academic Self-Confidence • Demographics • Gender Stigma • Racial Stigma

  10. Academic Self Concept (ASC) • Examine effects on academic self-concept • Created by Liu and Wang of Nanyang University in Singapore • 7 Point scale • Sample: “I am usually interested in my schoolwork” or “I am always waiting for the lessons to end” • Positive and Negative questions

  11. Stigma Consciousness Questionnaires (SCQ) • Questions by Pinel from UT Austin • Asks about perceptions of discrimination • Sample: “Stereotypes about women have not affected me personally” or “Most men have a lot more sexist thoughts than they actually express”

  12. Results

  13. Hypotheses • H0 = ASCMale= ASCFemale • H1 = ASCMale≠ ASCFemale • H0 = ASCCaucasian= ASCAfrican American = ASCAsian=ASCHispanic=ASCOther • H1 = ASCCaucasian≠ ASCAfrican American ≠ ASCAsian≠ ASCHispanic≠ ASCOther

  14. Males have a higher academic self concept than females t: -4.59; p < .0001

  15. Males and females perceive similar amounts of stigma regarding their gender t = -1.35; p = .175

  16. Each race has a similar academic self concept… F = 1.03; p = .387

  17. …but African Americans, Asians, and Hispanics perceived a racial stigmavs Caucasian base line F=7.53; p < .0001

  18. Greek participation made no difference in academic self concept t = .1696, p = .86

  19. ASC Scale Regression

  20. SCQ Gender Regression African American

  21. SCQ Race Regression

  22. Summary of Results • Males have a higher academic self concept • Gender stigma consciousness is largely the same • Race stigma consciousness exists at MIT, but race does not have a statistically significant effect on academic self concept

  23. Discussion

  24. Outcome • There is no statistically significant difference to support our hypothesis • MIT is not unique in these parameters

  25. Implications • Academic environment may not impact a student’s academic self confidence as compared to their peers, particularly those of a different race or gender • Other factors, such as socioeconomic status, may override the impact of academic environment

  26. Limitations • Our survey was conducted on a small scale • Responses represented <10% of the student population • We did not ask for parameters like GPA • We did not know the source schools of the prior research, preventing direct comparisons with them

  27. Next Steps • MIT on a larger, more comprehensive scale • MIT vs. a less prestigious institution • MIT vs. another prestigious institution

  28. Questions?

More Related