70 likes | 77 Views
This analysis explores the establishment of government and leadership in the movie "Lord of the Flies." Discussing the ideas of John Locke and Thomas Hobbes, it examines the factors contributing to the failure of Ralph's government, the effectiveness of Jack as a leader, the influence of human nature, and the events that align with Hobbes and Locke's views. It also compares characters to Trump and Clinton.
E N D
Aim #4: Lord of the Flies Analysis • Does the government that Ralph establishes on the island rely more on the ideas of John Locke or Thomas Hobbes? In your response, discuss the ideas of both thinkers and use specific information and examples from the movie to support your response.
Lord of the Flies Analysis • Which factor do you think was MOST significant in bringing about the failure of Ralph’s government? Justify your answer with specific information and examples from the movie: • The poor leadership and decisions of Ralph and Piggy • The charisma and leadership ability of Jack • The evils of human nature (the “beast” within all of us)
Lord of the Flies Analysis • “There is no question that throughout the story Jack proved himself to be the more effective leader. Ralph’s goal of establishing a democracy was not realistic, and he was too concerned with being rescued, a goal that he himself had no control over reaching. Jack demonstrated strong leadership by providing for the immediate needs of the population: food, shelter and entertainment. The idea of the beast allowed the boys to fuel their energy into a silly but harmless cause.” Do you agree with this quote? Why or why not? Support your response with specific information and examples from the movie.
Lord of the Flies Analysis • Do the events in Lord of the Flies do more to support Thomas Hobbes view of human nature or John Locke’s view of human nature? In your response, discuss the ideas of both thinkers and use specific information and examples from the movie to support your response.
Lord of the Flies Analysis • Which character from Lord of the Flies do you think Trump most resembles? Which character do you think Clinton most resembles? Justify your response using both information from your internet research and the movie. If you don’t feel there is a character in Lord of the Flies to fit one or both of the candidates, explain why you feel this way.
Period 2 Teams • Lumin – Maggie • Bridget – Megan • Jamie – Yeana • Shemar – Alexis • Kayla – Manny – Regina • Najon – Eric • Justin – Jessica • Je Leah – Anthony • Michael – Antonella
Period 3 Teams • Courtney – David • Jack B – Samantha • Brittany – Rob • Pedro – Amanda • Alex – Anna • Spencer – Chloe • Jack K – Angelica • Chris – Jake • Saanchi – Jack S • Bailey – Kai • Buddy – Alexa • Daniel – Caitlin