320 likes | 435 Views
NEW CHARM RESULTS FROM FOCUS. Stefano Bianco Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati dell’INFN La Thuile - March 3 rd , 2004. OVERVIEW. Measurement of masses and widths of excited charm mesons, and evidence for broad states J.M.Link et al. (FOCUS Coll.) hep-ex/0312060 accepted by Phys.Lett.B
E N D
NEW CHARM RESULTS FROM FOCUS Stefano Bianco Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati dell’INFN La Thuile - March 3rd, 2004
OVERVIEW • Measurement of masses and widths of excited charm mesons, and evidence for broad states J.M.Link et al. (FOCUS Coll.) hep-ex/0312060 accepted by Phys.Lett.B • Measurement of Ds+fm+n formfactors J.M.Link et al. (FOCUS Coll.) hep-ex/0401001 accepted by Phys.Lett.B • K-matrix analysis of charm mesons Dalitz plots J.M.Link et al. (FOCUS Coll.) hep-ex/0312040 accepted by Phys.Lett.B Sorry, no time to report on these 2003-2004 results: • Measurements of six body hadronic decays of the D0 charmed meson. By FOCUS Collaboration [hep-ex/0401019] • Charm - anti-charm baryon production asymmetries in photon nucleon interactions. By FOCUS Collaboration Phys.Lett.B581:39-48,2004 • Study of hadronic five body decays of charmed mesons involving K0(S). By FOCUS Collaboration [hep-ex/0310051] • Study of the decay mode D0 ---> K- K- K+ pi+. By FOCUS Collaboration Phys.Lett.B575:190-197,2003. [hep-ex/0308054] • Search for rare and forbidden three body dimuon decays of the charmed mesons D+ and D(s)+. By FOCUS Collaboration Phys.Lett.B572:21-31,2003. [hep-ex/0306049] • Measurements of Xi(c)+ branching ratios. By FOCUS Collaboration Phys.Lett.B571:139-147,2003. [hep-ex/0305038] • Studies of correlations between D and anti-D mesons in high-energy photoproduction. By FOCUS Collaboration Phys.Lett.B566:51-60,2003. [hep-ex/0305018] • Measurement of the Omega0(c) lifetime. By FOCUS Collaboration Phys.Lett.B561:41-48,2003. [hep-ex/0302033] La Thuile 2004
Spectrometer at FERMILAB Wide Band Photon Beam Over 1 million reconstructed! Successor to E687. Designed to study charm particles produced by ~200 GeV photons using a fixed target spectrometer with updated Vertexing,Cerenkov,EM Calorimeters, and Muon id capabilities. Member groups from USA, Italy, Brazil, Mexico, Korea. DATA COLLECTED IN 1996-1997 La Thuile 2004
Charmed mesons spectroscopy chart (ante Spring 2003) SQ Sq L In the heavy-quark limit, the heavy-quark spin SQ and the total angular momentum of the light-quark jq=L+S are conserved Each level is composed of a degenerate doublet of states with the same jq and total angular momentum J=jq± ½. jq=½ states are predicted to be broad (100-200MeV width). THIS PICTURE QUESTIONED BY BABAR AND CLEO DISCOVER OF Dsj. For a recent review see SB Fabbri Benson Bigi Hep-ex/0309021 La Thuile 2004
Measurement of masses and widths of excitedcharm mesons, and evidence for broad statesJ.M.Link et al. (FOCUS Coll.) hep-ex/0312060 accepted by Phys.Lett.B • Processes studied: • gN D0p++ X, D0K-p+,K-p+p+p- • gN D+p-+ X, D+K-p+p+ • Feeddowns: • D1+(jq=3/2)D*0p+, D*0D0(p0,g) • D2*+D*0p+, D*0D0(p0,g) • D1+(jq=1/2)D*0p+, D*0D0(p0,g) La Thuile 2004
D and D* sample • Processes studied: • gN D0p++ X, • D0Kp • D0 Kppp • gN D+p-+ X, • D+Kpp • Remove Dp combinations from D* La Thuile 2004
D0p+and D+p- mass distributions Feed down from D2*, D1 partial reconstruction Feed down from D2*, D1 partial reconstruction Entries / 10 MeV/c2 Entries / 10 MeV/c2 Combinatoric background Wrong sign Wrong sign M(D+p--)-M(D+)+1.8693 (GeV/c2) M(D0p+)-M(D0)+1.8646 (GeV/c2) Shorthand:DM0 Shorthand: DM+ La Thuile 2004
Fitting D0p+and D+p- mass distributions • D-wave fixed • to PDG D2* mass and • width 2. D-wave free fit parameter Bad fits, excess of events between D2* and the feeddowns La Thuile 2004
Fitting D0p+and D+p- mass distributions • Add S-wave • Fit cl=22% now • Recompute the • feeddown lineshape • using the D2* parameters • measured in Step 3. • Fit cl=28% now La Thuile 2004
Significance of S-wave excess The broad excess observed could be the broad state D0*, or the feeddown from a broad D1 state goto feedown list . La Thuile 2004
RESULTS Errors on D2* masses and widths smaller than or equal to PDG03 Agreement with the recent BELLE result (hep-ex/0307021). La Thuile 2004
SYSTEMATICS STUDIES I La Thuile 2004
SYSTEMATICS STUDIES II • Background shapes: • (E687) • (L3) La Thuile 2004
THIS RESULT AND THEORY PREDICTIONSPredicted mass differences with respect to the D meson compared to this result La Thuile 2004
New measurements of the Ds+fm+nform factor ratios J.M.Link et al. (FOCUS Coll.) hep-ex/0401001 accepted by Phys.Lett.B • A long-standing problem: the form factor ratios rv and r2 describing D+K0*m+n should be close to Ds+fm+n since only difference is a spectator quark d replaced with a s • Lattice gauge calculations: max diff= 10% • Experiment: • rv OK • r2 inconsistent (3.3s). ??? La Thuile 2004
Form factor formalism for Ds+fm+n Ds+ s s La Thuile 2004
Searching for s-wave interference in fmn FOCUS published observation for a very strong s-wave interfering with p-wave in the Kpsystem forDK*mn NO evidence for s-wave interference in Dsfmn events cos qV dataccbar mc events cos qV events cos qV data K*mn K*mn fmn La Thuile 2004
The mKK distribution for Ds+K-K+m+n candidates Data (solid) and cc background MonteCarlo (dashed). Main background from D+K-K+p+ where a pion is misidentified as a muon La Thuile 2004
Comparing data and model Histogram:data- dots:model-dashed histogram: cc Montecarlo La Thuile 2004
RESULTS rv=1.549 ± 0.250 ± 0.145 r2=0.713 ± 0.202 ± 0.266 • Most precise measurement to date • very consistent with D+K0*m+n • very consistent with expectation that the form • factors for the two processes should be very similar Solid green: world av. Ds+fm+n Dashed blue: world av. D+K0*m+n La Thuile 2004
Form Factors D+K0*m+n and Ds+fm+n THIS RESULT La Thuile 2004
DP analysis of Ds+ and D+ decay to p+p-p+ using the K-matrix formalism J.M.Link et al. (FOCUS Coll.) hep-ex/0312040 accepted by Phys.Lett.Bsee also : S.Malvezzi Workshop on B physics, Rome Italy January 15, 2004. • Dalitz plots have been proved to be a powerful tool in three-body decays, investigating • Resonant substructure • Interference patterns • Final state interactions • Relationships to light-meson spectroscopy • Traditionally, isobar formalism used • Decay amplitude is a sum of Breit-Wigner propagators • Breit-Wigner amplitudes for a resonance which is broad and overlaps with other resonances can be connected to the pole positions only through models of analytic continuation La Thuile 2004
describes coupling of resonances to D known from scattering data K-matrix picture • The amplitude is written as a sum • The amplitude F takes care of S-wave component by integrating over the scattering amplitudes of the five virtual states pp, KK, hh, hh’, 4p La Thuile 2004
pp- KKn : * GAMS ppp0p0n,hhn, hh’n, |t|0.2 (GeV/c2) CERN-Munich * GAMS ppp0p0n, 0.30|t|1.0 (GeV/c2) * BNL pp p0p0p0, p0p0h , p0hh pp p0p0p0, p0p0h * p+p- p+p- At rest, from liquid * Crystal Barrel pp p+p-p0, K+K-p0, KsKsp0, K+Ksp- * Crystal Barrel At rest, from gaseous * Crystal Barrel At rest, from liquid np p0p0p-, p-p-p+, KsK-p0, KsKsp- * Crystal Barrel At rest, from liquid E852 * p-pp0p0n, 0|t|1.5 (GeV/c2) To describe the scattering a global fit to all available data was performed “K-matrix analysis of the 00++-wave in the mass region below 1900 MeV’’ V.V Anisovich and A.V.Sarantsev Eur.Phys.J.A16 (2003) 229 La Thuile 2004
FOCUS D s + p +p +p -analysis • Observe: • f0(980) • f2(1270) • f0(1500) Sideband Signal Yield Ds+ = 1475 50 S/N Ds+ = 3.41 La Thuile 2004
Low mass projection High mass projection decay channel phase (deg) fit fractions (%) First fits to charm Dalitz plots in the K-matrix approach C.L fit 3 % La Thuile 2004
p+ p- r p- p+ p+ p+ • No significant direct three-body-decay component • No significant r(770) p contribution Marginal role of annihilation in charm hadronic decays But need more data! La Thuile 2004
D+ p +p +p - analysis Yield D+ = 1527 51 S/N D+ = 3.64 Sideband Signal La Thuile 2004
K-matrix fit results C.L fit 7.7 % High mass projection Low mass projection decay channel phase (deg) fit fractions (%) No new resonance required not present in the scattering. La Thuile 2004
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS • New precise measurements of mass and widths of D2*+ and D2*0, with errors better than or equal to PDG03 • Evidence for broad states in D+p- and D0p+ final states • Puzzle of Ds+ fm+n form factors discrepancy solved with new precise measurement • First DP analysis of Ds+,D+ p +p +p -charm decays using K-matrix formalism • Use information from light-quark scattering experiments (five virtual channels considered pp, KK, hh, hh’, 4p). CONCLUSIONS: • Non-resonant components are described by known two-body S-wave dynamics • Negligible role of annihilation diagram in Ds p +p +p – • Possible applications in Brp (not discussed here) • DP analysis of Ds+,D+ p +p +p -charm decays using traditional isobar model is also in progress to compare to K-matrix model. La Thuile 2004
2 3 3 r r | 1 2 1 How can we formulate the problem? The problem is to write the propagator for theresonance r For a well-defined wave with specific isospin and spin (IJ) characterized by narrow and well-isolated resonances, we know how. La Thuile 2004