290 likes | 428 Views
Use of Scatterometer Winds in TC Forecasting Tropical Cyclone Warning Centre Perth. Andrew Burton Bureau of Meteorology , Perth, Australia. Application of Scatterometer to Tropical Cyclone Forecasting. Formation Size (radius of gales) Wind distribution Not for absolute intensity
E N D
Use of Scatterometer Winds in TC Forecasting Tropical Cyclone Warning Centre Perth Andrew Burton Bureau of Meteorology, Perth, Australia
Application of Scatterometer to Tropical Cyclone Forecasting • Formation • Size (radius of gales) • Wind distribution • Not for absolute intensity (winds saturate at >60 90? knots)
Where to Get Scatterometer Data • NRL Monterey http://www.nrlmry.navy.mil/tc_pages/tc_home.html • NOAA/NESDIS QuikSCAT http://manati.wwb.noaa.gov/quikscat Storms page – includes ambiguities: http://manati.wwb.noaa.gov/cgi-bin/qscat_storm.pl Alternative NOAA site, with SSMI wind speeds: http://polar.wwb.noaa.gov/winds/globdata.html • FNMOC http://152.80.49.210/PUBLIC/SCAT or http://www.fnmoc.navy.mil/PUBLIC/SCAT • Remote Sensing Systems http://www.ssmi.com
NRL Montereyhttp://www.nrlmry.navy.mil/tc_pages/tc_home.html
FNMOChttp://152.80.49.210/PUBLIC/SCAT/ FNMOC Ambiguity Removal over SSMI Near Real-Time Ambiguity Removal
QuikSCAT: SeaWinds Measurements V-pol H-pol From Dr. M. Freilich, Oregon State University
SeaWinds: Swath Geometry Subtrack View (4 solns,but small angle var) Forward Look Red = V-pol Blue = H-pol EdgeView (2 solns) V-pol only Ideal View (4 solns, 90 deg var) Backward Look From Dr. M. Freilich, Oregon State University
Scatterometry: 2-Look Solutions 1 2 3 4 Solution: wind ~10m/s at ?? deg From Dr. M. Freilich, Oregon State University From Dr. M. Freilich, Oregon State University
Scatterometry: 4-Look Solution(s) 1 2 3 4 Most-likely solution: 10m/s at 40deg From Dr. M. Freilich, Oregon State University From Dr. M. Freilich, Oregon State University
Location, Intensity, Wind Distribution Source: Tropical storms discussion group
Small system (X) analysed for 3 days --no help from NWP model 20S 170W 170W O O X X X O 25 Jan 1800Z 26 Jan 0517Z 26 Jan 1800Z 170W 160W 170W 160W O X O 27 Jan 1712Z 28 Jan 0427Z
Interpretation Challenges • Edge of swath (~ 7 wind vector cells) • Rain effects • Sensitivity to errors in NWP • Practical wind regime 3-45? m/s (problems with both very light and very strong winds) • Resolution (25km) – impact in tight gradients • Ambiguity Removal Process and rain flag process can affect final solution
Edge Problems Along the whole edge…or small portion… FNMOC DISPLAY
Rain Effects – “tear drop” • Position using the curvature outside ‘rain block’ region. • Look for good north-south winds.
Streamlines Beware of winds perpendicular to the swath, even when they are not flagged X Look for non-rain flagged winds TC Chris 03/02/02 0914Z
Isotachs X Look for min speed near centre TC Chris 04/02/02 1002Z
Errorsin NWP TC Guillaume 19/02/02 1341Z Wrong Model Position?
Where is TC HUDAH?No circulation! Try to fix in trough equator-ward of the strongest winds ? Max Winds 95knots
Model initialization errors In this case, poor model initialization combined with a lower skill nadir position, picks proper wind speed, but NO circulation center 20/2356Z AVN 19/12Z tau 24 (Light winds?) -----low skill c 10S c 10S ? MaxWind 55 KTS ? 20S TC Paul 20S
Comparing Different Solutions FNMOC-NRT FNMOC-NOGAPS
Microwave Imageryvs Quikscat Scatterometer winds give wrong estimate for centre 10 S 14 S 18 S 88 E 92 E 84 E 84 E 88 E 92 E Comparisonbetween Quikscat solution from NESDIS 30/11/2001 at 0023Z and fair LLCC seen in SSMI near 14.4S 89.1E 30/11/2001 at 0218Z
Analysis Methods - Summary • Ignore the bad - streamline the good • Tear-drop – curved end • TC’s – equatorward side of max wind • Compare different solutions • Isotach method – ignore direction
Conclusions • Provides coverage over data sparse areas • Wind speeds generally good – useful for areas of gales etc • Use the data if it makes sense • Be aware of low skill areas and different ambiguity removal processes (compare!) • Do not use in isolation