180 likes | 331 Views
“To confer, converse, and otherwise hobnob with my brother wizards”: SLIC, SLAINTE and Web 2.0. Celia Jenkins & Gillian Hanlon, SLIC. Why Web 2.0?. Improving SLAINTE. Focusing on needs of community. - Different ways of delivering content
E N D
“To confer, converse, and otherwise hobnob with my brother wizards”: SLIC, SLAINTE and Web 2.0 Celia Jenkins & Gillian Hanlon, SLIC
Why Web 2.0? • Improving SLAINTE. Focusing on needs of community. - Different ways of delivering content - Encourages communication, participation & collaboration - Enhances our resources
Tagging: Key features • User generated keywords • No controlled vocabulary • Non-hierarchical • Folksonomy • No limit to number of tags • Supporting fields
The great tagging debate: part I • Enables “pseudo-faceted classification”(Speller, 2007) • Creates a bottom-up consensus view(Shirky, 2005) • Adaptable to changing vocabularies (Mathes, 2004) • Facilitates serendipitous browsing (Mathes, 2004) • Combination approach(Pattern, 2007) • Evidence of tag consensus being reached (Golder & Huberman, 2005)
The great tagging debate: part II • Synonyms and homonyms(Mathes, 2004) • Ambiguity of uncontrolled vocabulary(Mathes, 2004) • Specificity and the level of expertise(Golder & Huberman, 2005) • Longevity of tags (Smith, 2005) • Spaces and multiple words(Mathes, 2004) • Personal versus social (Mathes, 2004)
Tagging: Library of Congress approach • Flickr pilot commenced Jun 2007 – live Jan 2008 • Two LoC photo collections added • Dublin Core records included • Tags applied by users – except “Library of Congress” tag • LoC flickr record
A delicate balance • Scalability - high cost of applying LoC approach • Cognitive issues - unlikely that users will tag to standards • Perception shift – not tagging versus cataloguing
Future developments • Continuous development of tagging guidelines • Building on existing content • Work in progress: pod/webcasting, Facebook, live chat and surveys • Overcoming legal barriers • Integration with SLAINTE
Contact details • References on del.icio.us • Presentation on slideshare • All available through pageflakes: http://www.pageflakes.com/scottishlibraries • email: Celia Jenkins slic4@slainte.org.uk Gillian Hanlon slic1@slainte.org.uk