50 likes | 226 Views
To reopen or not to reopen ( this is the question) Different approaches of re-opening nodes in heuristic search. Vitali Sepetnitsky Advisors: Prof. Ariel Felner Dr. Roni Stern Ben-Gurion University of The Negev Department of Information Systems Engineering. Experiment Setup.
E N D
To reopen or not toreopen(this is the question)Different approaches of re-opening nodes in heuristic search Vitali Sepetnitsky Advisors: Prof. Ariel Felner Dr. Roni Stern Ben-Gurion University of The Negev Department of Information Systems Engineering
Experiment Setup • First simple test • 4 maps from StarCraft: • BlackLotus • Hellfire • WinterConquest • Nightshade • 10 different instances for each map(different positioning of the start and goal states) • 42 different weights from Korf’s experiment setup
Results • Here you can see numbers of instances for each case(instance = map + positioning of start and goal states)
Conclusions • We have a very low number of instances in which NR outperforms AR by the solution cost (~1.13%) • For each map of the four, Case 1 is found in specific instances only (over the 10 available) with different weights:
Exploring Case 1 • Taking the “WinterConquest” map and 3 instances • Red circles = start and goal states • Case 1 can be found only in #2 • Can’t find any unique properties of #2 comparing to #0 and #1 instances # 2 # 0 # 1