1 / 10

How to box smart

How to box smart. TIPS Workshop, Pretoria 4-5 March Dr Mareike Meyn. The pros and cons. It is true… the negotiation power is highly asymmetric; EC has often delayed process and has not been responsive to ACP ideas;

harlan-williams
Download Presentation

How to box smart

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. How to box smart TIPS Workshop, Pretoria 4-5 March Dr Mareike Meyn

  2. The pros and cons • It is true… • the negotiation power is highly asymmetric; • EC has often delayed process and has not been responsive to ACP ideas; • having to give away market access in IEPA might have decreased ACP negotiation power • Interim EPAs are sufficient to guarantee WTO compatibility • but…. • taking EPAs out of the ‘headlight’ might help finding compromises; • African countries have supporting groups within the EU (NGOs, private sector, research institutes, Parliamentarian, single member states…) • IEPA countries have committed themselves to continue negotiations EPAs - How to box smart? TIPS workshop March 2008

  3. “There is no substitute during tough negotiations for a good argument and proper preparation.” Wilhelm Smalberger, member of the South African trade negotiation team when negotiating the EU-South Africa free trade agreement EPAs - How to box smart? TIPS workshop March 2008

  4. How to move things forward • Analyse the EPA • What provisions should be improved? • Are some of the provisions more onerous than those of other regions? • Improve the information exchange with other regions • What are their priorities and objectives? • What strategies did/do they apply? Are they suitable for your region? • Learn lessons • What went wrong when negotiating the interim EPAs? • How can former mistakes be avoided? EPAs - How to box smart? TIPS workshop March 2008

  5. How to move things forward • Identify your offensive interests • ACP prime focus in EPAs was defensive (maintaining market access; avoid market opening • Identify also your offensive interests with respect to services and trade related issues; and • With respect to A4T (identify gaps; propose allocation) • Formulate a coherent strategy for 2008 • Consult with national and regional stakeholders • Mainstreaming trade into your development strategy • Lobby for your interest by finding allies • Other ACP countries, development departments of EU member states, other WTO members… EPAs - How to box smart? TIPS workshop March 2008

  6. How to box smart • Important to remember that both parties need to present ‘successes’ • Some provisions might only be ‘make-up’ but allow the EC to sell the EPA as ‘comprehensive’ • Example of public procurement in the CARIFORUM EPA • CF submitted a positive list of public entities that shall treat “any eligible supplier of either … Party equally in accordance with the principle of open and effective competition.” • ?What is an ‘eligible supplier’? • Plus: • several areas are excluded from the provisions • Limited tendering allowed in cases such as ‘extreme urgency’ • Implementation of chapter is linked to technical assistance and subject to a 3 years transition period (5 years for LDCs) EPAs - How to box smart? TIPS workshop March 2008

  7. A regional negotiation machinery • Heads of States of the single African regions did not agree on a negotiation strategy and did not establish a joint negotiation machinery • To establish a regional negotiation machinery is hard work: • harmonisation of national positions • creation of a regional position; • continued information exchange, consultation and dialogue • according adaptation of the regional negotiation position; • However, there are significant advantages: • Best use of resources and sound advice to single countries; • A coordinated strategy is much more powerful • The risk that the region is split-up during negotiations is lower EPAs - How to box smart? TIPS workshop March 2008

  8. Basic rules how to box smart • Analyse the text and the obligations arising from it carefully. • Cooperate closely with countries that successfully negotiated with the EU (such as Mexico, Chile, CARIFORUM). • Develop a coherent national strategy and harmonise it on a regional level. • Consult with your regional partners how a non-acceptable provision could be rephrased to become acceptable. • Identify what you would like to get out of the EPA and link your obligations to • technical and financial assistance • transitional periods during which capacity is built. EPAs - How to box smart? TIPS workshop March 2008

  9. Basic rules how to box smart • Take advantage of the Special and Differential Treatment Provision when negotiating transitional periods • CF achieved longer transitional periods for its ‘lesser developed members’ in case or regional liberalisation; service liberalisation, public procurement, and IPR. • Bundling power when addressing the development component: • All ACP claim for binding commitments to tackle transitional costs (linked to single chapters!) • Finding supporters (EU states, European Parliament, lobby groups…) EPAs - How to box smart? TIPS workshop March 2008

  10. How to box smart TIPS Workshop 5-6 March 2008

More Related