1 / 9

Chuenchom & Chris Greacen Palang Thai: palangthai 3 December 2003

Governance issues in the Thai Electricity Sector WRI/TEI Workshop on Electricity Governance in Asia. Chuenchom & Chris Greacen Palang Thai: www.palangthai.org 3 December 2003. Outline. Brief history of Thai electricity sector

hateya
Download Presentation

Chuenchom & Chris Greacen Palang Thai: palangthai 3 December 2003

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Governance issues in the Thai Electricity SectorWRI/TEIWorkshop on Electricity Governance in Asia Chuenchom & Chris Greacen Palang Thai: www.palangthai.org 3 December 2003

  2. Outline • Brief history of Thai electricity sector • Story #1: Bo Nok & Hin Krud: NGOs, strategic alliances, and two coal fired power plants • Story #2: “National Champion” model • Structure • Governance issues • Story #3: Access to the grid for small renewable energy generators: law vs. practice

  3. Brief history of Thai electricity sector • 1950-1990: Centralized, state-owned utilities • Metropolitan Electricity Authority (MEA) • Provincial Electricity Authority (PEA) • Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT) • 1990-2000: Private capital and market based reform • Giving “concessions” to private power producers (IPPs, SPPs) to generate & sell power • Sale of EGAT’s assets: EGCO, Ratchaburi • Plan to create “Power Pool” • Break up / privatize the 3 utilities • Bidding & Market clearing price for electricity

  4.  Access to info  Participation Access to justice  Capacity building Story #1: Successful opposition toBo Nok & Hin Krud • Bo Nok, Hin Krud = planned large coal IPPs • First case NGO challenge government energy policy on technical basis: • reliability criteria • demand projection • investment planning • 3-hour televised debate NGO vs. Government • NGO: “Project not needed because of supply glut, canceling would be cheaper” • Ultimate success: Coal projects cancelled

  5.  Access to info  Participation Access to justice  Capacity building Bo Nok & Hin Krud Governance issues • Success due in part to uneasy strategic alliance with EGAT & PTT • NGO capacity building • Technical analytical capacity • However, access to information remains limited/unsustainable

  6. Access to info  Participation  Access to justice Capacity building Story #2: “National champion” • “National Champion” = large partially privatized, self-regulated Thai monopoly with capital to invest abroad in competition w/ other transnationals • EGAT to be the regional hub of ASEAN Grid • Privatization timeline kept – EGAT listed and partially (<30%) sold in Stock Exchange of Thailand by March 2004. MEA, PEA will follow • EGAT market capitalization: 500 billion baht (US$12.5 billion)

  7. Access to info  Participation  Access to justice Capacity building “National Champion”: governance issues • No independent regulatory body • Ability to assume both private & public identity as convenient • Ability to pass on cost & risk to captive consumers • If like PTT, then rapid sell-out of stock followed by commodity price rise. • PTT “public offering” = shares for 2000 people (0.003% of Thai population) • Limited public hearing process • Listing in stock market said to lead to “good governance” but applies only to narrow accounting criteria & financial management

  8. Access to info Participation  Access to justice Capacity building Story #3: Access to the grid for small renewable energy generators law vs. practice • 2002 Cabinet approved VSPP laws passed allowing grid interconnection of renewable energy <1 MW. • English & Thai regulationas available at: www.vspp.org • After they were approved… PEA removed one key page • Page specified that expensive “block reclose” device NOT necessary • No technical/engineering reason offered

  9. Key preliminary governance challenge Needed: Independent, empowered regulator  Access to info  Participation  Access to justice  Capacity building

More Related