190 likes | 333 Views
REALLY HIGH RATES OF EARLY ABSTINENCE AND TREATMENT RETENTION AFTER OPIATE DETOXIFICATION, USING ORAL NALTREXONE AND NETWORK-COMMUNITY REINFORCEMENT THERAPY IN GREECE. Colin Brewer, Research Director, The Stapleford Centre, London UK. Manos Koukides , Counsellor, Life Care NGO , Greece .
E N D
REALLY HIGH RATES OF EARLY ABSTINENCE AND TREATMENT RETENTION AFTER OPIATE DETOXIFICATION, USING ORAL NALTREXONE AND NETWORK-COMMUNITY REINFORCEMENT THERAPY IN GREECE Colin Brewer, Research Director, The Stapleford Centre, London UK. Manos Koukides, Counsellor, Life Care NGO, Greece. MatinaLagoudaki, Psychologist, Life Care NGO, Greece
PROBLEM 1 • On an ‘intention-to-treat’ (ITT) basis, drop-out and/or relapse during conventional opiate detoxification and in the first month following it are typically rather high and medium-to-longer-term success rates typically rather low, eg: • Strang et al 2003. only 27% of patients entering the ‘centre of excellence’ stayed the full 28 days and thus regained normal tolerance. • Keen et al Only 13% of patients from a reputable British residential unit were regarded as ‘successful’.
PROBLEM 2 • Definitions of ‘detox’ and ‘completion’ vary enormously, eg: • Completing a gradual taper of methadone (MET) or buprenorphine (BPN) plus two or three ‘drug-free’ days. • But ‘drug-free’ days just means that no opiates were prescribed on those days or that urines tested during this period were opiate-free. • It does not mean that withdrawal symptoms had stopped. • Indeed, in some studies, withdrawal peaked 1-2 days after the last MET dose.
A civilized detox certainly helps. • De Jong, Roozen et al 2007. Carefully selected, well-prepared, state-funded and intensively-supported patients benefited from the virtually 100% completion-rates typical of rapid detoxification under anaesthesia or sedation. • Followed by supervised NTX using Community-Reinforcement/Network Therapy. • However, only 32% (on an ITT basis) were opiate-free 16 months later. • Possibly because; about 60% of patients who had successfully detoxified and initiated supervised oral NTX had discontinued NTX within the first 4-6 weeks
THE FIRST MONTH IS CRITICAL • Persisting withdrawal discomfort – patients know it is instantly relieved by relapse. • Persisting addictive mindset and habits need much more than a month to change but if they don’t get through the first month, change is unlikely. • People doing the NTX supervising have to learn new habits too. If they don’t learn quickly (eg how to detect cheating) relapse is more likely. • Often not much change in levels of temptation from old user friends if patients return home. • Rule of thumb: 66% of relapses happen in the first 6 weeks. That’s why even short-acting implants are so helpful.
The Merimna Programme • Civilised in-patient detox with good symptom relief minimises fear of detox and makes abstinence more attractive (or less unattractive) • Implants not available in Greece, only tablets. • So, involvement and preparation including family members even before detox and specific instruction in NTX supervision. • At least weekly follow-up sessions for 1 year with counsellors familiar with NTX. Standard range of psychosocial approaches – and included in treatment price. • Urine testing – though not always possible or systematic.
RETROSPECTIVE CASENOTE STUDY • 229 fairly typical non-coerced patients. (m:208; f:21. age 20-24, 27%; 25-31, 50%: 52% employed full-time, 8.7% part-time or student: 48% education to 14 or less.) • Only 29 (12.6%) clearly relapsed or dropped out during the first month). • 134 patients (58.5%) attended most sessions and were opiate-negative throughout the planned period (usually 12 months) and continued to collect NTX prescriptions.
URINE TESTING • In 14%, no urine tests were done at any stage (usually for geographical reasons) but attendance was good - at least 75% of planned appointments during the first 3 months. • In 3.5%, urine not tested during first 3 months but attendance good during that period and later urine tests negative for opiates. • 3.5% had opiate-positive urines during the first 1-3 months but consistently negative ones later.
So that overall... • About 65% of patients seem to have been opiate free at around 12 months – which is not at all bad. • This rises to about 70% if we assume that a third of the 14% who weren’t tested but attended regularly for 3 months stayed clean for the rest of the year. • Very few patients dropped-out between detoxification being agreed and the planned admission for detoxification and NTX induction (usually not much more than a week) so that this is close to an ‘intention to treat’ study.
However.... • Patients come from all over Greece – and beyond. • So counselling happens at many different locations. • Counsellors are human – and thus variable. • Attitudes to urine testing vary. • Counsellor attitudes to NTX taking generally positive but also vary.
Some problems with counsellors.... • Ideally, NTX should be given in a foolproof way at some counselling sessions. Acceptance usually confirms abstinence from opiates. Refusal certainly raises suspicions. • Some counsellors are not keen on this because they see it as the family’s job (or a medical task). Giving it themselves might imply lack of trust in the family (or patient). • If parents were temporarily unable to supervise, many counsellors would not be happy to act as a substitute. • Implants would obviously solve these problems.
Urine testing is rarely done during counselling sessions but is usually ordered on a random basis. • Generally done at least monthly, more if necessary. (Op, BDZ, Can, Coc) • Counsellors in remote locations are encouraged to test samples on-site with test-sticks. • Cannabis use may be a factor in drop-out.
CONCLUSION • These apparently above-average outcomes probably reflect the good design of the programme, the competence and therapeutic ideology of those who administer it and the persistence of strong family structures in Greece.