650 likes | 936 Views
The Role of Point of Care Testing in Optimal Patient Blood Management. Paula J. Santrach MD Associate Professor of Laboratory Medicine & Pathology Mayo Clinic Rochester, MN SABM Annual Meeting September 21, 2012. Disclosures.
E N D
The Role of Point of Care Testing in Optimal Patient Blood Management Paula J. Santrach MD Associate Professor of Laboratory Medicine & Pathology Mayo Clinic Rochester, MN SABM Annual Meeting September 21, 2012
Disclosures • Employee of Mayo Clinic and member of the Department of Laboratory Medicine & Pathology • Mayo Medical Laboratories is a business of the Mayo Clinic • Off label uses: none
Point of Care Testing • The analysis of clinical specimens as close as possible to the patient (TheFreeDictionary) • Medical testing at or near the site of patient care (Wikipedia) • Testing performed outside of a traditional centralized laboratory (National Center for Competency Testing) • There is a wide spectrum of application in a variety of clinical settings
Point of Care Testing • The Good • Rapid turnaround time • Easy to use in general • Accessible • The Not So Good • Comparability to laboratory methods • Cost • Oversight issues • True clinical utility depends on • Facilitation of clinical workflow • Facilitation of clinical decision-making • Improved patient outcomes • It is not something you should do just because you can
Key Preoperative Questions That May Utilize Point of Care Laboratory Data • Is this patient at a higher risk of bleeding? • Patient history is the most important • History of bleeding: spontaneous, procedure-related, birth-related • Type, need for transfusion • Concomitant medical illnesses • Concomitant medications • Anticoagulation, anti-platelet therapy, others • Procedural issues • Extracorporeal circulation, reoperation, others • Evaluation of patients with a history suggestive of a bleeding disorder will need further laboratory workup
Key Preoperative Questions That May Utilize Point of Care Laboratory Data • What about the patient on anti-platelet therapy? • Balancing act • Need for surgery • 10-15% of patients presenting with acute coronary syndromes have to undergo CABG and 5-25% have to undergo non-cardiac surgery during the first five years after percutaneous coronary intervention • Risk of bleeding during surgery • Pretty clear for cardiac surgery • Literature more mixed for non-cardiac surgery Gruber et al. ThrombHaemost 106:248, 2011
Key Preoperative Questions That May Utilize Point of Care Laboratory Data • Balancing act (cont) • Risk of interruption of anti-platelet therapy • Very important issue for patients with stents • Preoperative discontinuation is associated with ~20% incidence of ischemic events • Preoperative continuation is associated with ~35% incidence of bleeding • Would preoperative platelet function testing be useful? • Anecdotal reports of using <50% platelet inhibition as decision point Gruber et al. ThrombHaemost 106:248, 2011
Comparison of 6 Platelet Function Tests to Determine Prevalence of Aspirin Resistance in Patients with Stable Coronary Artery Disease 201 patients on daily ASA European Heart J 28:1702, 2007
Comparison of 4 Tests to Assess Inhibition of Platelet Function by Clopidogrel in Stable Coronary Artery Disease Patients 116 patients in clopidogrel dosing trial > 50% resistance found by all assays except WBA (47%) poor correlation between tests European Heart J 29:2877, 2008
TARGET-CABG Study • Timing Based on Platelet Function Strategy to Reduce Clopidogrel-Associated Bleeding Related to CABG • Single center, nonrandomized, unblinded observational study • 180 patients, elective first-time isolated on-pump CABG, on aspirin with or without clopidogrel • Waiting time for surgery based on platelet function tests (MAADP from TEG Platelet Mapping System) • Primary endpoint: 24 hr chest tube drainage Mahla et al. CircCardiovascInterv 5:261, 2012
TARGET-CABG Study Mahla et al. CircCardiovascInterv 5:261, 2012
TARGET-CABG Study Mahla et al. CircCardiovascInterv 5:261, 2012
TARGET-CABG Study – Outcomes Mahla et al. CircCardiovascInterv 5:261, 2012
TARGET-CABG Study - Outcomes Mahla et al. CircCardiovascInterv 5:261, 2012
TARGET-CABG Study - Outcomes • Mean total amount of RBCs transfused: no difference • Median length of hospital stay: clopidogrel significantly longer, due to inpatient clopidogrel withdrawal • Duration of intubation: no difference • Length of ICU stay: no difference • Re-thoracotomy rates: no difference • 30 day mortality & 30 day readmissions: no difference • 46% reduction in waiting time to surgery without increasing bleeding Mahla et al. CircCardiovascInterv 5:261, 2012
Key Preoperative Questions That May Utilize Point of Care Laboratory Data • Is this patient anemic? • Point of care testing can have a role in screening • Testing method makes a difference • Electrical conductivity for hematocrit • Significant hemodilution leads to inaccurate results • Spectrophotometry for hemoglobin • Particle counting for hematocrit • Cell packing/centrifugation for hematocrit • Methods vary so be consistent • Diagnosis of the underlying problem requires more advanced data not available through POCT
Key Intraoperative Processes That May Utilize Point of Care Laboratory Data • Acute normovolemichemodilution • Hemoglobin or hematocrit testing can guide the collection of the appropriate number of whole blood units • Procedural anticoagulation with heparin • Activated clotting time or heparin concentration • Use of these approaches in various subpopulations may make a difference in the likelihood of bleeding and need for transfusion • Procedural anticoagulation with other agents • Monitoring strategy is unclear
Perioperative Transfusion DecisionsWhere the Money is (Literally & Figuratively) • Point of care or other rapid form of testing can significantly influence transfusion decisions • Liver transplantation • Cardiac surgery • Trauma • Building the transfusion algorithms • What abnormalities need to be detected? • What devices will be used for detection? • What are the decision points for transfusion? • What products should be transfused? How many?
Transfusion AlgorithmsCardiac Surgery as an Example • Microvascular bleeding after cardiopulmonary bypass • Coagulation factor deficiency • Hypofibrinogenemia among others • Thrombocytopenia • Platelet dysfunction • Fibrinolysis • Persistent heparinization
Transfusion Triggers for POCT • Options • Reference range • Multiples of the upper limit of the reference range • Decision points provided by device manufacturer • Decision points from published studies • Do your own study • Context: patient population of practice
Transfusion Triggers for POCT Nuttall, et al. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 9:355, 1995
Transfusion Triggers for POCT Nuttall, et al. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth 9:355, 1995
Operating Room Transfusion Algorithm Excessive microvascular bleeding in surgical field Order coagulationand platelet tests PT >16.6(1.6)sec aPPT >57 sec and/or and/or PLT <102K/mm3 TEG MA<48 mm Fibrinogen<140 mg/dL ACT >Baseline Allnormal Platelettransfusion Fresh frozen plasmatransfusion Cryoprecipitatetransfusion Protamine Surgicalre-explorationof chest Nuttall, Oliver & Ereth: Anesthesiology 94: 773, 2001
Clinical Use of Transfusion Algorithm Nuttall, et al. Anesthesiology 94:773, 2001
ICU Transfusion Algorithm Chest tube output <150cc/hr (<2cc/kg/hr) Excessive microvascular bleeding in surgical field AddPEEP OR Do nothing – observe Coagulation and platelet tests ordered PT >12.6(1.2)sec aPPT >45 sec and/or and/or PLT <140K/mm3 TEG MA<55 mm Fibrinogen<200 mg/dL ACT >Baseline Allnormal Platelettransfusion Fresh frozen plasmatransfusion Cryoprecipitatetransfusion Protamine Surgicalre-explorationof chest Nuttall, Ereth, & Oliver, Transfusion, Oct 2010
TEG-Based Transfusion Algorithm Royston et al: Br J Anaesth 86:575, 2001
TEG-Based Transfusion AlgorithmEffectiveness Royston et al: Br J Anaesth 86:575, 2001
Capraro Transfusion Algorithm Hemoglobin <9.0 g/dL 1 U RBC Platelets <100 x 109 1U platelets/10 kg – round up to nearest 4 U WB APTT or PT 1.5 x normal value 10 mL/kg FFP – in whole units ACT >10 sec longer than preop ACT Protamine 0.5 mg/kg Bleeding time >12 min DDAVP 0.3 ug/kg Normal values in all previous tests Tranexamic acid 10 mg/kg IV Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 45:200, 2001
Capraro Transfusion AlgorithmEffectiveness ActaAnaesthesiolScand 45:200, 2001
Capraro Transfusion AlgorithmEffectiveness • Caveats • Imbalance in groups • More combined operations in algorithm group • Already very conservative in transfusion decisions • Re-exploration rate >20% in both groups • Testing done in first hour postoperatively • What about immediate post-pump time frame? Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 45:200, 2001
Point of Care vs Conventional Lab Testing in Coagulopathic Cardiac Surgery Patients • Randomized controlled trial of 100 patients • Elective complex cardiothoracic surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass (high risk patients) • Enrolled after heparin reversal if at least one of these criteria met: • Diffuse bleeding from capillary beds at wound surfaces • Blood loss exceeding 250 mL/hr or 50 mL/10 min intraoperatively or in first 24 hours postoperatively • Conventional coagulation tests • Point of care tests • ROTEM (viscoelastography) • Multiplate (platelet aggregometry) Weber et al. Anesthesiology 117:531, 2012
Point of Care vs Conventional Lab Testing in Coagulopathic Cardiac Surgery Patients Weber et al. Anesthesiology 117:531, 2012
Postoperative algorithm nearly identical Excessive bleeding: >250 mL/hr or >50 mL/10 min Weber et al. Anesthesiology 117:531, 2012
Point of Care vs Conventional Lab Testing in Coagulopathic Cardiac Surgery Patients • Results • Trial stopped at interim analysis • Patient enrollment • Conventional: 45 in OR, 5 in ICU • Point of care: 43 in OR, 7 ICU • Conventional test results did not significantly differ between 2 groups at preop and at 24 hours after ICU admission • At ICU admission, POC group at significantly lower fibrinogen and lactate results Weber et al. Anesthesiology 117:531, 2012
Point of Care vs Conventional Lab Testing in Coagulopathic Cardiac Surgery Patients Median (25th : 75th percentile) Weber et al. Anesthesiology 117:531, 2012
Point of Care vs Conventional Lab Testing in Coagulopathic Cardiac Surgery Patients Median (25th : 75th percentile) Weber et al. Anesthesiology 117:531, 2012
POC vs Conventional Lab TestingOutcomes Weber et al. Anesthesiology 117:531, 2012
POC vs Conventional Lab TestingOutcomes Weber et al. Anesthesiology 117:531, 2012
Transfusion Algorithms in Other Clinical Situations • Liver transplantation • Trauma • Massive transfusion
Rapid Thromboelastography & Massive Transfusion in Post-Injury Coagulopathy • Retrospective study before and after rapid thromboelastography (rTEG) implementation • 68 consecutive trauma patients, 34 before & 34 after, who received 6 or more units of blood in the fist 6 hours • rTEG ordered by anesthesiologist or surgeon • Algorithm in place, but decisions based primarily on response to treatment rather than strict adherence to algorithm Kashuk et al. Transfusion 52:23, 2012