90 likes | 234 Views
Individual Restrictions, Quarantine, and Public Health Realities. Edward P. Richards, JD MPH Program in Law, Science and Public Health LSU School of Law http://biotech.law.lsu.edu. Definitions. Quarantine Isolation Personal Restrictions Pandemic. Example Diseases and Restrictions.
E N D
Individual Restrictions, Quarantine, and Public Health Realities Edward P. Richards, JD MPHProgram in Law, Science and Public HealthLSU School of Law http://biotech.law.lsu.edu
Definitions • Quarantine • Isolation • Personal Restrictions • Pandemic
Example Diseases and Restrictions • Tuberculosis • Smallpox • Yearly flu • Typhoid • Hanson's Disease (leprosy) • Ringworm • SARS • Theoretical pan flu
Resources • Where do you put them? • Why jail is always the wrong choice • Do you have appropriate facilities? • Should you move them to appropriate facilities?
Treatment and Testing • Can you treat them against their will? • What does this mean in practical terms? • Can you coerce them into treatment? • Treatment as a key to release? • What about DOT and enforcing it?
Dealing With the Civil Libertarians • Do not screw up the medical side and the place of confinement • This is the root of most problems, which then cost the state authority • Educate the public about the risk posed by disease carriers • Do not sugar coat it • Political correctness has hurt public health authority • Look at national security law
Stay at Home Orders • When would these be appropriate? • How do you provide medical care? • How do you provide food? • How do you support salary? • What about criminals, crazies, homeless, and illegals? • What is the role of a resilient communities approach?
How Far Do You Go to Enforce Orders? • What is the purpose of the restriction? • Does it have to be 100% • Is 100% even possible? • If 100% is not realistic, can you justify shooting someone? • Can you justify it a year later at your trial, when the public health department is seen as having failed in the epidemic?