110 likes | 262 Views
Seed Treatments on Corn Hybrids Tested in OVT’s. Fred Allen, Professor Department of Plant Sciences University of Tennessee. SCC-33 Meeting January 26-29, 2010 St. Pete Beach, FL. OUTLINE GENERAL INFO FUNGICIDE AND INSECTICIDE SEED TREATMENTS TN YIELD DATA ON CORN IST’s SUMMARY
E N D
Seed Treatments on Corn Hybrids Tested in OVT’s Fred Allen, Professor Department of Plant Sciences University of Tennessee SCC-33 Meeting January 26-29, 2010 St. Pete Beach, FL
OUTLINE GENERAL INFO FUNGICIDE AND INSECTICIDE SEED TREATMENTS TN YIELD DATA ON CORN IST’s SUMMARY TN’S CURRENT POLICY ON SEED TREATMENTS IN OVT
GOAL IN VARIETY TESTING: Historically -- Obtain UNBIASED data on genetic differences among varieties How?? Control extraneous variation in order to create a “level playing field” so that all varieties in the test have equal opportunity to express their full genetic yield potential. Via Randomization, replication, blocking on field variation, equal seeding rates, weed control, etc. Now & in the future, testing the package of: Genetics + biotech traits + seed treatments A potential bias may arise when seed of varieties are treated with different chemicals!
SEED TREATMENTS FOR CORN Corn Seed Trt. Fungicides: Allegiance (Metalaxyl) Apron XL (Mefenoxam) Maxim (Fludioxonil) Dynasty (Azoxystrobin) Trilex (Trifloxystrobin) Examples of Combinations: Dynasty CST = Apron XL + Dynasty + Maxim Trilex Advanced = Trilex + Baytan + Allegiance Corn Seed Trt. Insecticides: Poncho (Clothianidin) 250, 500, 1250 Gaucho, Axcess (Imidacloprid) 600 Cruiser (Thiamethoxam) 250, 500 Corn:fungicide(s)+ insecticide = standard Fungicides & Insecticides applied to seed last about 14-30 DAP. Examples of Combinations of Fungicides + Insecticides applied to corn seed: Acceleron = 3 fungicides + insecticide Avicta Complete (Cotton) = 3 fungicides + insecticide + nematicide $ per Acre (?): Fungicide ~ $2 – 4; Insecticide ~ $6 – 12 3 fungicides + insecticide seed trt. = $12 - 24
COMPANIES WANT TO PROTECT THEIR INVESTMENT IN BIOTECH TRAITS
CORN FUNGICIDE SEED TREATMENTS’ PRIMARY DISEASE TARGETS: seed rot and seedling diseases Pythium – Mefenoxam, Metalaxyl ( e.g.,Apron XL, Allegiance) Rhizoctonia, Fusarium, Penicillium, others – Fludioxanil, Azoxystrobin, Triadimenol (e.g., Maxim, Captan, Dynasty, Baytan, Protégé) Combinations of fungicides to get broader spectrum control Source: Iowa St. Univ.
CORN INSECTICIDE SEED TREATMENTS: Poncho, Cruiser, Gaucho EXAMPLES OF TARGET INSECTS: Root Worms Cutworms Seed Corn Maggots Wireworms Click beetle Photos: U. of Wis., IA St. & Univ. of Ark.
SUMMARY The response to INSECTICIDE SEED TREATMENT (IST) varied among hybrids, among locations, and among years. The highest responses to IST generally occurred in higher yield environments. In general the ISTs will provide a positive economic return in corn. CORN: fungicide + insecticide seed treatment is standard. It takes approx. 2-3 extra bu/a @ $3.50/bu to pay for the treatments. TN data indicates that IST added and average of about 6 bu/a; therefore there likely is a return on investment for producers.
Variety Testing Program Seed Treatment Requirements CORN: Must be treated with a fungicide and an insecticide (started in 2005). SOYBEAN: Must be treated with a fungicide and an insecticide (started in CST in 2009; start in REC’s in 2010). WHEAT & GRAIN SORGHUM:Must be treated with a fungicide but not with an insecticide. Allen’s (current) philosophy for future testing: Test varieties as they will be sold to the farmers.