190 likes | 305 Views
Applying DynusT to the I-10 Corridor Study, Tucson, AZ. ITE Western District Meeting Santa Barbara June 26th, 2012 Jim Schoen, PE, Kittelson & Assoc. Khang Nguyen, PE, Kittelson & Assoc. Project Scope. Develop Design Concept 7 miles 4 TI’s Frontage roads
E N D
Applying DynusTto the I-10 Corridor Study, Tucson, AZ ITE Western District Meeting Santa Barbara June 26th, 2012 Jim Schoen, PE, Kittelson & Assoc. Khang Nguyen, PE, Kittelson & Assoc
Project Scope Develop Design Concept • 7 miles • 4 TI’s • Frontage roads • Determine 2040 capacity requirements • 4 alternatives • Identify traffic control needs • Evaluate implementation phasing - 2015 Subarea
Analysis Approach • Traditional Approach - TDM • Develop design volumes from regional TDM • Develop peak hour turning volumes (K, D, turn proportions) • Apply HCM methodologies • Shortcomings • Estimating future turning volumes can be challenging • Repeat process for each alternative • Does not accurately reflect capacity constraint effects • Hard to predict traffic redistribution due to network changes
Analysis Approach • Microscopic Simulation • Too much detail at preliminary engineering level • Hard to predict traffic redistribution due to network changes • Too costly
New Approach – Dynamic Traffic Assignment Model • Meso-scopic traffic assignment • Based on TDM O-D tables • Model large area with greater detail than TDM • Turn lanes/movements • Traffic flow characteristics • Signal and stop control • Generate more accurate routing and demand estimates
Which DTA Model? • Dynasmart, DynusT, other proprietary models • Preliminary, uncalibrated regional DynusT model available from PAG
Modeling Process Synchro Existing Link Analysis Calibration TDM Model RDTA Model Modified Subarea Calibrated Subarea QC Modify DUE Subarea Model Refinement Validate Outputs Travel Time Runs Apply calibration results to the future model Future Future ODs Future DTA Model Link Analysis QC Modified Subarea Calibrated Subarea Calibration Modify DUE Subarea • Outputs • Vols • Delay • Travel Time • Queuing HCS Synchro Microsimulation
Model Calibration • Data collection • Link ADT’s • Saturation flow rates • Peak hour TMC’s • Freeway speed and density • Travel time
Model Calibration • Traffic model calibration • Saturation flow rates • Speed-density curves • OD table calibration • Peak period link volumes (DynusTutility) • Peak hour TMV’s (DynusT utilities, adjust centroid connectors, and manual O/D adjustments)
Future Models • 2040 am & pm • Determine freeway, frontage road, interchange, and cross road capacity and traffic control needs • 4 network alternatives • Synchro and HCM freeway methodologies • 2015 am & pm • Evaluate implementation phasing alternatives
Alternative Implementation Scenarios • Typical Construction Phasing • Work Zone • 3 mainline lanes each direction • Crossroad, frontage roads, ramps – fully closed • 55 mph approaching WZ, 45 mph through WZ
Implementation Phasing MOEs • MOEs: total network travel time, v/c ratios at signals, and mainline travel speed
Results • DTA modeling met the project’s objectives • Improved traffic projections • Quantifiable construction phasing strategies • Specific recommendations to minimize traffic impacts during construction • Cost effective and efficient modeling approach • Model is available for work zone evaluation during construction • Refinement of regional and subarea network is important • DTA output can potentially replace the need for HCM analysis step
Costs • I-10 Corridor Study - $150K • Extensive data collection (ADT, sat flows, travel times) • Existing, 2015, 2040 AM/PM subarea models • 4 network scenarios, 4 construction phasing options • I-96, Newburgh Rd to US-24, Michigan - $250K • Regional DTA model • Construction phasing options for I-96 corridor
The Future of DTA • DTA modeling supports: • Activity-based modeling • MOVES – advanced air quality modeling • More systematic prioritization of TIP projects • DTA can be integrated with microscopic simulation to better model complex scenarios Multi-resolution modeling) – on-going FHWA initiative • MPOs are building calibrated regional DTA models
Thank You! • Questions/Comments