1 / 10

By Tania Ajam: Knowledge Director Juan Bester: Programme Manager 5 August 2008

Public Hearings on the Draft Money Bills Amendment Procedure and Related Matters Bill, 2008 Submission to Portfolio Committee on Finance. By Tania Ajam: Knowledge Director Juan Bester: Programme Manager 5 August 2008. Background. AFReC’s 2000 recommendations:

izzy
Download Presentation

By Tania Ajam: Knowledge Director Juan Bester: Programme Manager 5 August 2008

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Public Hearings on the Draft Money Bills Amendment Procedure and Related Matters Bill, 2008Submission to Portfolio Committee on Finance By Tania Ajam: Knowledge Director Juan Bester: Programme Manager 5 August 2008

  2. Background • AFReC’s 2000 recommendations: • introduce a phased approach to budget process with parliamentary oversight at each stage • General and specific recommendations

  3. Recommendations (1) • General: • Bill needs distinction between macro-economic forecasts and fiscal policy targets. • Macroeconomic forecasts to be validated by independent agency. • Parliament to adopt fiscal rules framework for considering budgets: • consideration of criteria targeting, efficiency, effectiveness, economy, transparency, zero sum gains and losses, internal consistency, time consistency, and broad stakeholder consultation. • Stronger emphasis on stakeholder consultation. • Parliament to exhaust all reasonable avenues before amending budgets.

  4. Recommendations (2) • Specific: • Refine “fiscal framework” definition: rolling 3-year forecasts • Sections 5(1) and 5(2) of the Bill to be rewritten to read “medium term statements.” • Section 7(9) report to include medium term fiscal impact of proposed amendments + outline of reconciliation of proposed amendments relative to initial proposals from NT. • Section 7(9) report to note list of stakeholders to be consulted when considering amendments. • Budget Office adequately resourced + capacitated. • Budget Office’s mandate and performance criteria may need to include explicit focus non-partisanship + objectivity.

  5. Establishing fiscal rules (1) • Research shows that fiscal rules necessary to maintain fiscal discipline when economies are vulnerable, not prone to macroeconomic stabilisation. • Fiscal framework with methodologies • Examples: borrowing for capital assets but not for current consumption, referendums for drastic tax hikes, number + size of amendments, ratio of government expenditure to GDP, balanced budgets • International case studies

  6. Establishing fiscal rules (2) • Need for amendments to take into account budget trade-offs. • Allocative efficiency: maximise citizen welfare with current resources, not indebting future generations. • Operational efficiency: need for properly planned budgets, minimising cost of marginal output.

  7. Establishing fiscal rules (3) • Criteria for fiscal rules framework: • Effectiveness, economy, and transparency • Zero sum gains and losses • Internally consistency • Time consistency

  8. Circumspect use of amendments • Appropriation amendments should be seen as a last resort measure. • Rather then changes with current MTEF period. • Compelling rationale necessary, in terms of improved allocative + operational efficiency, fiscal discipline, or fiscal accountability • Risk considerations by Parliament, e.g. potential absorption capacity by organs of state, potential underspending and rollovers could be avoided. • Fiscal rigidities (e.g. personnel wage structures, social grants) leaves little fiscal discretion for changes in short term.

  9. Parliamentary Budget Office • Good idea, but imperative that it is: • Dedicated • Properly resourced + capacitated • Non-partisan + independent • Critical success factor: clarity in roles of Executive Authorities and Accounting Officers to relieve tension between the Parliament’s oversight function and its ability to amend budgets.

  10. ENDTHANK YOUWebsite: www.afrec.co.zaE-mail (1): tajam@afrec.co.za E-mail (2): jbester@afrec.co.zaTelephone: 021 659 9300/10/19

More Related