300 likes | 580 Views
Phytoremediation of Antibiotics. Ninad Gujarathi Department of Chemical Engineering Colorado State University PhD May 2005 Advisor: Professor James C. Linden. Means for Countering Antibiotic Pollution of Wastewaters.
E N D
Phytoremediation of Antibiotics Ninad Gujarathi Department of Chemical Engineering Colorado State University PhD May 2005 Advisor: Professor James C. Linden
Means for Countering Antibiotic Pollutionof Wastewaters • Convention methods: adsorption on hydrophobic beds, coagulation, and softening fail • Reverse osmosis: successful but impractical for wastewater treatment • Chemical and electrochemical oxidation: removes most antibiotics from wastewater • Phytoremediation: an alternative for advanced oxidation methods
Phytoremediation • Use of vegetation to contain, sequester, remove, modify or degrade pollutants from soil and water • Pollutants: metals or organic compounds • Metals either taken up or adsorbed on roots • Organic compounds degraded or detoxified • before uptake by the plants • by agents released to the rhizosphere
Plants Used in Phytoremediation Studies • Aquatic species - Pistia stratiotes (water lettuce) - Myriophyllum aquaticum (parrot feather) • Hairy root cultures - Helianthus annuus (sunflower)
Procedures for Obtaining Root Exudates • Grow aquatic plants or root cultures in growth medium for the required amount of time • Remove the plants/roots from the medium • Filter the medium through a 0.2-micron filter • Use immediately or refrigerate until convenient
Tetracycline and Oxytetracycline • Antibiotics studied in this project • Persistent in the environment • Difficult to remove in wastewater treatment plants • Can be oxidized by reactive oxygen species (ROS) • hydrogen peroxide • hydroxyl radical
General Structure of Tetracyclines Two UV absorbing chromophores*: • A- chromophore ~ 270 nm • BCD-chromophore ~ 360 nm
Evidence of OTC Modification by Root Exudates • A- OTC in water (0 day) • B- OTC in water (6 days) • C- OTC in sunflower root exudates (0 days) • D- OTC in sunflower root exudates (6 days) (UV abs.@355)/ (UV abs.@270) A: 0.75; B: 0.72 C: 0.64; D:0.22 The modification appears to be dominant at the BCD chromophore
Summary • All three plant systems gave significant antibiotic removal from water of both TC and OTC • Water lettuce greatest removal rates (biomass concentration ~ 250 g/L) • Parrot feather least removal rates, probably due to lower biomass concentrations (~20 g/L) • Sunflower hairy roots intermediate removal rates, depending on period of growth
A Conclusion Filtered, cell-free and microbe free, root exudates gave comparable antibiotic removal rates Therefore: - physical adsorption to biomass was ruled out - uptake by the roots was ruled out - microbial interaction was ruled out - antibiotic interactions are with root secreted exudates
Discussion • Aromatic compounds are known to be oxidized by plant root exudates • Three possible sites of oxidation on the OTC molecule: OH groups in the A, B and D rings • Quinone derivatives of OTC are the likely oxidation products
Oxidation of OTCPotential mechanismaccounts for - loss of electronic resonance in BCD rings- loss of UV at 360 nm - destruction of antibiotic activity
Effect of Ascorbic Acid on OTC Modification • Ascorbic acid (AA) is common antioxidant • Inhibition of OTC modification increases with increasing AA concentrations
Effect of ‘age’ of Root Exudates • Rates of modification increased with age of root exudates • ROS appear to be the limiting species in OTC interaction
Effect of Salicylic Acid Elicitation in Water Lettuce Microcosm on ROS Production Control Elicitation
Discussion • Plants respond to stress by producing ROS • Sunflower root cultures and water lettuce produce greater ROS concentrations with elicitation using salicylic acid and methyl jasmonate • Antimicrobial activity of the ‘modified antibiotics’ was determined to be destroyed
Design of Bioreactor System Water lettuce plants were employed in greenhouse microcosm Design constraints: • Biomass concentration - 250 g/L • Age of root exudates required - 7 days • Reaction follows first-order kinetics • OTC remediation in second stage bioreactor
Bioreactor System Layout Hoagland’s medium OTC at 5 mg/L Root exudates Mixer Pond microcosm Treated water Bioreactor
Continuous Stirred Tank Reactor (CSTR) • Shown as OTC remediation reactor • Temperature 30 C • Agitation 350 rpm • Residence time 7.5 h • Removal ~72% • Also proposed as hairy root propagation reactor
Conclusions • Antibiotics are oxidized by ROS produced by the plant roots • The CSTR, when coupled with the pond microcosm, gave good OTC removal rates • Phytoremediation of antibiotics is a possibility for treatment systems designed for field applications of the remediation system.
BOD Removal by Water Lettuce Root ExudatesL = waterLR = root exudates (RE)LRO = RE + OTCLROS = RE + 0.2 mM salicylateLROM = RE + 0.2mM methyl jasmonate
Acknowledgements • Colorado State University Agricultural Experiment Station (COL 00661) • National Science Foundation (EEC-0139478) Research Experience for Undergraduates • Byran J. Haney • Heidi J. Park