1 / 80

P14471 Vibration Testing Apparatus II Detailed Design Review 12/10/2013

P14471 Vibration Testing Apparatus II Detailed Design Review 12/10/2013. Brett Billings Jacob Gardner Nick Greco Ron Jimbo Claire Kobal Ryan Selig Ashley Waldron. Agenda. Project Summary Selected Design Preliminary Analysis Frame Motor Electrical / Control System Safety

jatin
Download Presentation

P14471 Vibration Testing Apparatus II Detailed Design Review 12/10/2013

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. P14471 Vibration Testing Apparatus IIDetailed Design Review12/10/2013 Brett Billings Jacob Gardner Nick Greco Ron Jimbo Claire Kobal Ryan Selig Ashley Waldron

  2. Agenda • Project Summary • Selected Design • Preliminary Analysis • Frame • Motor • Electrical / Control System • Safety • Improvements from P13471 • Test Plan • BOM • Project Plan • Concerns/Issues • Appendix

  3. Project Summary

  4. Problem Statement • Update company’s vibration test apparatus • Meet UL 844 Standard • Continue progress started by Team 13471 • Done: the eccentric drive mechanism • Still needs: • Frame • Motor • Control system

  5. House of Quality

  6. Engineering Requirements

  7. Selected Design

  8. Selected Design • Interchangeable Conduits • Motor with V-belt • VFD • Digital Dial Gauge • Encoder • LCD, Microcontroller • Polycarbonate Guards • E-stop • Paint for Rust Protection

  9. Preliminary Analysis

  10. Maintaining Displacement • ER #1: Displacement must be 1/32’’ • Clamping force: • Provided by 2 x A574 screws - 5/8’’-11 • M = torque on screws • = 168.9 M ft-1 • Frictional force: • 2 possible locations: • = 33.8 M ft-1 (worst case) • Maximum force applied: • 1.68 ft-lbs. (motor) at 1/32’’ • = 645 lbs. • Required screw torque: • = 38 ft-lbs. (Safety factor of 2) • Max recommended A574 torque = 220 ft-lbs *Detailed calculations in Appendix 1 2

  11. Engineering Analysis: Forces • ER # 12 – Maximum Luminaire Weight • Force on collar/conduit = 1641.3N (368.979lbf) • Force from connecting rod = 2822.68N (634.564lbf) • Calculated friction forces • Worst case = 297.68N (66.921 lbf) • Torque on connecting rod = 2.13667Nm (1.575 lbft) • Torque on block = 2.399Nm (1.769 lbft) • Torque on crankshaft = 2.399Nm(1.769 lbft) *Refer to Appendix

  12. Engineering Analysis: Fatigue • Conduit • σa=15456.9psi so σm=0psi • σa<0.5*σ0 • Therefore Infinite Life • Factor of Safety • σar=15,5229psi < 0.5*σ0 • Infinite life • C-Channel • Max stress = 7181.27psi = σa • σa<0.5*σ0 • Infinite Life • Refer to appendix σ0 =35,000psi; σu =58,000psi

  13. Engineering Analysis: Fatigue/Buckling σ0 =35,000psi; σu =58,000psi • Extension Rod: • Buckling: • Pcr = 4576.61lbf • 368.9 lbf < 4576.61lbf • No buckling • Fatigue: • σa=469.698psi • σa<0.5*σ0 • Infinite Life • Threaded Connector • Buckling: • Pcr = 13800.8lbf • 368.9 lbf < 13800.8lbf • No buckling • Fatigue: • σa=2855.26psi • σa<0.5*σ0 • Infinite Life • Refer to appendix

  14. Frame

  15. Final Frame Design

  16. Frame Halve Views Front and Back Views of Crankshaft Front and Back Views of Full Assembly

  17. Analysis Overview • ER # 2, 3 – Vibration of Luminaire, Test Duration • ER # 12 – Maximum Luminaire Weight • ER # 22 – Machine Footprint • ER # Tested both modal and harmonic response of frame using ANSYS Workbench • Simplified system to incorporate the respective weights of each system but not the complexity (bolt holes, threads, etc.) • Initially tested using a displacement of 0.015625” at the collar. This yielded: and • Tested using lower displacements and achieved a good result with a displacement of 0.0144” at the collar. This yielded: and

  18. Frame Analysis at 0.015625 in. Displacement

  19. Frame Analysis at 0.0144 in. Displacement

  20. Motor

  21. Motor Selection • ER #2 – Vibration of Luminaire • ER #10 – Max Motor Voltage • ER #12 – Maximum Luminaire Weight Maximum Load= 150 lbs Torque Necessary= 1.68 ft-lbs We will be running the motor at full load torque to allow for a longer life. With the v-drive offset, the motor can produce less torque than needed by the crankshaft system.

  22. Motor Performance Data:Baldor M3545 We chose a 1 HP motor with a full-load torque of 1.5 LB-FT Updated cost from Volland Electric Equipment Corp: $237.51 *This is a saving of almost $235.00 from the original estimate

  23. V-Drive Selection • ER #2 – Vibration of Luminaire • ER #4 – Isolate Motor from Oil Spills All information was gathered from the Dodge catalog For the given gear ratio of 1.75, Type A, 1-Groove Driver Datum Diameter: 3.4” Outer Diameter= 3.4”+.37”= Approx. 3.75” Driven Datum Diameter: 6.2” Outer Diameter= 6.2”+.37”= Approx. 6.55” Driver Taper Lock Bushing (1210), .5” Shaft Diameter Driven Taper Lock Bushing (1610), 1” Shaft Diameter Distance from center shaft to center shaft using donated belt guard: 9.5” *Unable to locate actual Dodge belt. A very similar belt will be purchased through AutoZone.

  24. Motor Mount to Frame

  25. Encoder Placement The current shaft has to be machined down to a smaller size at the very end to add a coupling for the encoder. *Encoder to be discussed further in electrical systems

  26. Electrical / Control System

  27. Component Placement at CCH

  28. Flow Diagram

  29. Power Connection Schematic

  30. Power Supply • VGS-25-5 • 25 Watt 5V AC-DC converter • 5Amax delivered current • 3.1 x 1.11 x 2.03 inches *Refer to appendix for power calculations

  31. Encoder TRD-N1024-RZWD • ER #2 – Vibration of Luminaire • ER #13 – Display System Status • Resolution: 1024 Pulses Per Revolution (PPR) • Max frequency: 100 kHz • Max RPM detection: 100 kHz / 1024 PPR * 60 = 5859 RPM

  32. ER # 10 – Max voltage of Motor

  33. Enclosure • AMP1426CCLF • Polycarbonate enclosure with metal snap latch • 14 x 12 x 6 inches

  34. Control System Pseudo Code • Initial delay to allow sufficient startup time for motor • Repeat (loop) the following until Timer_A value reads 35 hrs • Wait for appropriate delay time to avoid overworking MCU CPU • Use Timer_A capture from pin 11 of MCU to retrieve digital encoder signal • Read and store timer value upon rising edge of signal into var "A" • Read and store timer value upon next rising edge into var "B" • Period = B - A • Frequency = 1 / Period • Resolution = 1024 • Speed of vibration in RPM = Frequency / Resolution * 60 • ; Dimensions = (rev / min) = (pulses/sec) / (pulses/rev) * (60 sec/min) • Send RPM and elapsed time (also from Timer_A) to LCD display via pinouts • if RPM exists above safety threshold (2000 RPM + threshold) • exit loop with error code set high • Update VFD with new RPM information to step up or down accordingly • Send signal to alert VFD to bring motor to a complete stop • if error code set high • Write "Test Ended Abruptly: High RPM" to LCD display • else • Write "Test Completed Successfully" to LCD display

  35. Launchpad and Display Encasing • ER # 3 – Duration of Vibration Test • ER #13 – Display System Status

  36. Safety

  37. Polycarbonate Guards • ER # 8 – Crankshaft Enclosure is Guarded • ER # 17 – Minimize Pinch Points • Top and rear guard • Clear, Polycarbonate ½’’ • Excellent impact resistance • Warning labels • Replace existing top guard • Move mounting holes away from edge • Increases strength, but slight overhang • Modify rear guard • Add access hole to decrease setup time

  38. Belt Guard • ER # 17 – Minimize Pinch Points • Protects operator from 2000 RPM belt • Donated • Modifications required: • Convert to “split” type • Weld existing halves together • Cut guard in half in other direction • Change existing mounting brackets

  39. Lock Out, E-stop • ER # 8 – Crankshaft Enclosure is Guarded • Lock out during maintenance • On electrical box, after power is isolated • Lock out procedure to be written in MSDII • ER # 9 – Completely Stop Machine with E-Stop • E-stop • Located on machine • Manually cuts power immediately

  40. Engineering Analysis: Sound • ER # 16 – Low Sound • Hearing Protection / Engineering Intervention • To be determined in MSD II with Test Plan • Based on sound “dosage” • Dosage Calculation: • L = dBA Sound Level • T = 8 hour exposure limit • C = actual exposure hours • D = 100 * (C1/T1 + C2/T2 + C3/T3 +…) • D > 50% requires hearing protection • D > 80% requires engineering intervention https://www.osha.gov/pls/oshaweb/owadisp.show_document?p_table=STANDARDS&p_id=9736 http://www.industrialnoisecontrol.com/comparative-noise-examples.htm http://www.coopersafety.com/noisereduction.aspx

  41. Safety Checklist • ER # 8 – Machine Guarding • ER # 9 – Emergency Stop • ER # 16 – Low Sound

  42. Improvements from P13471

  43. Setup Improvements • ER # 11 – Minimize number of operators • ER # 14 – Steps to set up • ER # 15 – Setup time

  44. Setup Improvements • Current setup procedure: • Measure displacement with dial gauge • Lockout machine • Remove top guard (8 screws) • Remove rear guard (4 screws) • Remove collars (2) • Remove connecting plate • Loosen locking bolts (2) • Adjust set screw • Perform 2-7 in reverse • Repeat 1-9 until 1/32’’ reached ~ 5x • Approximately 60 minutes to setup 2x 10 minutes

  45. Setup Improvements • Displacement adjustment without removing rear guard, collars, or connecting plate • Also, U-bolt prevents block from rotating • Changes required: • Add 2 access holes to connecting plate • Add 4 holes total for u-bolt • Add 1 access hole to rear guard • Doesn’t impact safety, .2’’

  46. Setup Improvements • Finer set screw • Before: • 11 threads per inch • 1 turn = 290% of displacement! • After: • 100 threads per inch • 1 turn = 33% of displacement • Changes required: • Machine new set screw plate • Requires threaded bushing for set screw

  47. Set Up Improvements • Set screw • Account for excess space between conduit and collar • Flange • Dimensioned to be placed in same location every time • Blocks on the C channel • ER # 11 – Minimize number of operators • ER # 6, 19-21 – Mount 4 configuration types • ER # 13, 14 – Setup time, number of steps Flange Collar – crankshaft connection Collar – set screws

  48. Test Plan

  49. Test Plan • Displacement Test • Date Completed: ______________________ • Performed By: _______________________________

More Related