1 / 18

The Distinction between Large-Scale and Mesoscale Contribution to Severe Convection

This case study explores the dynamic and thermodynamic features of a tornadic severe thunderstorm in Topeka, Kansas in 1983. It analyzes the roles of large-scale and mesoscale processes in convective initiation and highlights the need for forecasting mesoscale processes.

jeanrsmith
Download Presentation

The Distinction between Large-Scale and Mesoscale Contribution to Severe Convection

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The Distinction between Large-Scale and Mesoscale Contribution to Severe Convection: A Case Study Example A summary of Charles A. Doswell III’s: By Matt Gough

  2. OVERVIEW • Why did Doswell choose this event? • Large-Scale setting • “subsynoptic” setting • Define large-scale and mesoscale processes • Dynamic/Thermodynamic features • Conclusions

  3. Late in the day of May 6, 1983 a tornadic severe thunderstorm struck Topeka, Kansas. • F3 • 1 fatality • 25 injuries

  4. So, why did Doswell choose this storm? • No widespread intense convection as in the case of previous case studies. • Here he can separate out the synoptic scale from the mesoscale. • Mesoscale processes hard to predict. “… one never proves hypothesis…” - Doswell

  5. Large scale: cyclogenesis 12Z 850mb map

  6. 12Z 500mb

  7. Surface analysis: • Dryline • Developing cold front

  8. Two major obstacles to convective development: • Capping inversion • Modest low-level moisture • Note CAPE

  9. Sub-synoptic features • By 2130Z strong convection over Nebraska and isolated thunderstorms over western Kansas. • Cold front intensifies and approaches the dryline. • By 000Z front intersects dryline and a squall line developes (includes the Topeka tornado)

  10. Doswell believed that it was not coincidental that deep convection began with the arrival of the cold front. • How intense was the lifting associated with the front? • Is this lifting enough to initiate convection despite the capping inversion?

  11. Defining the roles of large-scale and mesoscale processes • 3 ingredients of Deep Moist Convection: • Moisture, Conditional instability, lift • “If large scale lifting were the main initiating mechanism, deep convection would be expected to begin as relatively extensive cloudiness before breaking down into individual convective elements” • “one can conclude that the lift needed to start deep convection is generally a product of MESOSCALE processes”.

  12. So, how do you separate mesoscale from large-scale???? • large scale = quasi-geostrophic • mesoscale – defined as “between” scales. Must consider both large-scale and microscale parameters.

  13. Q-G forcing for vertical motion • Forcing in Iowa and Missouri decrease w/ht • Forcing in CO, WY, Mont., increase w/ht. This tilting supports cyclogenesis (Holton 9.2.1)

  14. Barotropic = no temp gradient wrt. Pressure • For upward forcing, must have convergence of Q: negative Horizontal variation in geostrophic wind Horizontal temp/thck gradient wrt. pressure

  15. But, (Hoskins and Pedder, 1980) the equation above shows no large-scale frontogenesis in west Kansas at both 00z and 12z where the cold front formed. Can’t explain frontogenesis completely with Q-G.

  16. “we must look elsewhere for the lifting”

  17. Summary and Discussion • “Large scale flows create a favorable environment while mesoscale processes provide the lift needed for convective initiation.” • Mesoscale processes must be coupled with large scale analysis by forecasters. • How to forecast meso-scale processes remains unanswered.

More Related