1 / 13

Politics 201

Politics 201. Top Level Considerations. Politics and fiat Public and/versus congressional perception Perception of and tradeoff between issues Spin—who controls perception of the plan, and thus shapes public/congressional reaction Media Opposition Party White House

jessamine-frye
Download Presentation

Politics 201

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Politics 201

  2. Top Level Considerations • Politics and fiat • Public and/versus congressional perception • Perception of and tradeoff between issues • Spin—who controls perception of the plan, and thus shapes public/congressional reaction • Media • Opposition Party • White House • Members of president’s party

  3. Credit and Blame • Does ‘normal means’ require congressional involvement/action • Obama tends to get credit and blame • Visibility • Psychological needs of the electorate (leadership) • Overstatement of importance in policymaking • Perceptual unitary nature of presidency vs. other branches • Teams often use alternate agents (agencies, congress, courts, other countries) to avoid politics links • Key Question—who will the hurt / benefitting groups blame

  4. Internal Link: Coop/Bipart/Olive Branch • THESIS: gestures that appeal to the other party increase the probability that other legislation will pass • Bipart: Plan fosters cooperation, this spills over to other issues • Olive Branch: Plan is a sop to the GOP, invites horse-trading • Logrolling: Passing one policy “breaks the logjam” that prevents other policies from passing… fosters momentum that transfers between legislative initiatives

  5. Internal Link: Flip Flops • THESIS: Presidents lose credibility when they are seen to change positions on important issues • Most ‘flip flop’ links describe Bush’s rolling of Kerry in the ‘04 presidential campaign: “I voted for war funding before I voted against it” • Has weaknesses as an internal link argument—easier to challenge uniqueness

  6. Internal Link: Political Capital • Is the GOLD STANDARD of politics internals—most internal links can be explained and described in terms of political capital • Describes the president’s overall ability to get their way with Congress—twist arms, offer favors, issue threats • Key considerations include • Is it limited? • Does it cross over between issues? • Is it replenishable

  7. Internal Link: Public Popularity • THESIS: Presidents with public approval are more likely to get their way with congress—congress is afraid to challenge popular presidents • This is backed up by a ton of social science-esque research (Edwards et al.) • Argument applies to both the POLICY and the PRESIDENT • Interest groups can shape public reaction to a policy

  8. Internal Link: Winning & Losing • THESIS: Winners Win—presidents that push through contentious policies as being successful (winners), decreasing the chance that congress will challenge them in the future • Health care reform (ACA) is a decent example • Thesis was originally proposed by Norman Ornstein • Argument also works in reverse—presidents who lose have a more difficult time forcing congress into line on future votes

  9. Internal Link: Legislative Blocks • THESIS: The reactions of like-minded lawmakers to the plan influence the chance of passage of future legislation • At the most basic level • Democrats (unity) • Republicans (cooperation) • Other groups • Dem moderates • Blue dogs • New Democrats • GOP moderates

  10. Internal Link: Specific Legislators • McConnell (GOP senate leader) • Boehner (GOP house leader) • Reid (Dem senate leader) • Pelosi (Dem house leader) • McCain, Collins(GOP senators, centrists)

  11. Link Genre: Lobby Backlash • THESIS: organized groups react to the plan in ways that impacts the future political process • This can include rewarding or punishing politicians through the use of campaign funding, directing advertising, and other means of exerting influence • Are VERY powerful link arguments, especially because the media and academics like to talk about their relative power • Are KEY on this topic because public reaction to most cases will be pretty minimal • Who are important lobbies on this topic?

  12. Politics in **this** Congress • Control of House (GOP) and Senate (Dems) is split between the two major parties • House: 234 GOP / 201 Dems • Senate: 54(55) Dems / 45 GOP • Probability of passage of *any* meaningful legislation is very low • Hastert Rule (House) • Filibuster (Senate) • Passage of any major legislation requires at least some GOP support • GOP-acceptable bills likely alienate more liberal Democrats • Election-season starts this fall and compromises a lot of potential politics arguments

  13. Scenarios on this topic • Immigration Reform • Climate Change (EPA authority) • Budget • Gun Control • Transatlantic Trade/TPA

More Related