140 likes | 291 Views
Establishing a Structured and More Patient-Centered System for Reporting Complications Associated With Intrathecal Baclofen Therapy: A Systematic Review. Nestor D. Tomycz M.D., Raj Nangunoori B.S., Joseph Hobbs M.D., Donald M. Whiting M.D., Michael Y. Oh M.D.
E N D
Establishing a Structured and More Patient-Centered System for Reporting Complications Associated With Intrathecal Baclofen Therapy: A Systematic Review Nestor D. Tomycz M.D., Raj Nangunoori B.S., Joseph Hobbs M.D., Donald M. Whiting M.D., Michael Y. Oh M.D. Department of Neurosurgery, Allegheny General Hospital, Pittsburgh, PA, U.S.A.
Introduction • Baclofen: an analogue of γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) • Oral baclofen • In 1984, Penn and Kroin demonstrated the effectiveness of intrathecal baclofen • Intrathecal baclofen (ITB) has become routine in the management of spasticity and dystonia arising from either spinal or cerebral origin
Objective • Dearth of literature which effectively characterizes complications related to ITB therapy • No coherent system for reporting ITB complications • To better characterize complications related to ITB therapy and to devise a simple, comprehensive, and more patient-centered scheme for complication reporting
Methods • MEDLINE search: January 1985 to May 2010 • N≥10 and if complications were reported • Articles were excluded if N<10 and if there were multiple articles by the same author with an overlap in patient populations • 310 articles found, 28 met criteria • Reclassified complications into 4 categories: technique, device, drug, and infection
Methods • Technique: due to the operative procedure itself • CSF-related complications (CSF wound leaks, pseudomeningoceles), hematoma/seroma, and wound dehiscence • Drug: subjective complaints and symptoms related to baclofen • Nausea, vomiting, somnolence, hypotonia, hypertonia, gastrointestinal disturbances, respiratory depression, and coma, overdose and withdrawal • Device: problems with the hardware itself • pump (flipping, failure), catheter (kinks, breaks, tears, and migration) • Infections: related to the pump or catheter incision • Wound infection/dehiscence was categorized here due the cause and effect relationship to the two, “wound dehiscence” was otherwise categorized as a complication of surgical technique.
Results • 28 papers met criteria for systematic review and included prospective trials, retrospective studies, and case series • 2,623 unique patients, 1,637 complications • Combined complication incidence: 62.4% • Range in total complication incidence: 10-570% • Device complications (n=587, 35.5%) were the most frequent followed by drug (n=544, 33.2%) followed by technique (n=293, 17.8%), and infection (n=213, 13.4%)
Results • Among technique complications, CSF-related complications (n = 113, 6.9%) were the most common followed by hematoma/seroma (n = 14, 0.9%) • Among drug complications, non-postural headache, nausea, vomiting, dizziness, and drowsiness were the most commonly reported (n = 212, 13.0%) • Baclofen overdose/withdrawal: n = 28, 1.7% • Among device complications, catheter-related problems were the most common (n = 193, 11.8%) • 8/28 studies (28.6%) reported no drug complications
Discussion • Our primary objective: report the combined incidence of complications related to ITB therapy and to devise a classification scheme that is more patient-centered • We selected the 4 categories for classification for their simplicity and comprehensiveness • We found a combined complication incidence of 62.4%
Conclusion • The incidence of complications related to ITB remains high • Much of the reporting on ITB complications has neglected patient-centered complaints (especially drug complications) • Although ITB has been touted as having a lower side effect profile than oral baclofen, drug complications from ITB are not rare • Improvements in ITB may be prompted by better complication reporting • The 4-tiered complication scheme for ITB will help patients better appreciate the risks of ITB