460 likes | 620 Views
http://www.bbc.co.uk/bbcthree/imagedump/7185.jpg. Summary. In Northern Ireland, two communities, namely the Protestants and Catholics , have been fighting with each other over religious and political differences
E N D
Summary In Northern Ireland, two communities, namely the Protestants and Catholics, have been fighting with each other over religious and political differences - Catholics and Protestants belong to two different main divisions of Christianity
United Kingdom Northern Ireland Britain England Scotland Wales Present State Republic of Ireland
Historical Background • Before the 12th century: Northern Ireland and Republic of Ireland were one country called Ireland • 12th century: Ireland conquered and colonised by England • 17th century: Protestant Scottish and English settlers brought into Ireland • increase Protestant population
Map of UK and Ireland http://www.shunya.net/Pictures/Edinburgh/uk-map.jpg
Historical Background • Newcomers mostly settled in the northern part of Ireland • pushing out many local Irish Catholic farmers • those that stayed behind were given the least fertile land • thus northern part of Ireland became predominantly Protestant
Historical Background • For years, Irish fought against the Scottish and English settlers without success • 1800: Ireland became part of the United Kingdom (UK) • Hostilities between the local Catholics and Protestants continued • local Irish demanded Home Rule in late 1800s and fighting often broke out
Home Rule • Home Rule: An arrangement where the Irish could make their own laws concerning local issues (e.g. education and taxation) while allowing Britain to keep control of external issues (e.g. defence and foreign affairs) • Similar to self-governance
Historical Background • 1921: Ireland divided into two separate parts • based on majority religion of each part • Northern Ireland: largely Protestant, remained part of UK • Irish Free State: largely Catholic • 1941: Cut ties with Britain and became Republic of Ireland
Protestant - Catholic Tension 1. Divided Loyalties 2. Education System 3. Employment 4. Housing 5. Voting Rights
Protestant - Catholic Tension Divided Loyalties: • In Northern Ireland: Protestants regard themselves as British and wish to be a part of the UK • Many were afraid of union with Republic of Ireland • as Catholic government would be intolerant to their Protestant beliefs
Protestant - Catholic Tension Divided Loyalties: • In Northern Ireland: Catholics see themselves as Irish and would like to be reunited with Ireland • resent the past history of English conquest and the harsh treatment to the Catholics • remembered the struggle for Home Rule http://www.indybay.org/uploads/ireland.jpg
Protestant - Catholic Tension Divided Loyalties: Sense of loyalty to different countries make the Protestants and Catholics intolerant of each other
Protestant - Catholic Tension Education System: • Existence of public schools catering for Protestants or Catholics only • Protestant children - taught British history, play British sports (e.g. rugby, hockey and cricket) • Catholic children - taught Irish history, take up Irish sports (e.g. Hurling), and Irish language and culture • tend to regard British as a foreign country
Protestant - Catholic Tension Education System: • Mixed schools to cater for both Protestants and Catholics • set up by private individuals • not as popular as the school which cater to just one religious group • Protestant and Catholic rarely get to meet and know each other • increased distrust and hostility among each other
Protestant - Catholic Tension Employment: • Competition of jobs is one of the cause of the conflict • Catholics: feel that although they may be academically qualified as the Protestants, but they do not have the same opportunity in getting the jobs they want
Protestant - Catholic Tension Employment: • 1971: Population survey revealed that Catholic males were 2.5 times more likely to be jobless than Protestant males • Number of Catholic engineers and civil servants not proportional to their numbers in the country • Relative fewer Catholics in seniors positions in the public as well as private sectors
Protestant - Catholic Tension Housing: • Irish Catholics: unhappy with the provision of public housing by city councils • public houses are partly paid by the government • councils usually consist largely of Protestants
Protestant - Catholic Tension Housing: • Large Catholic families in need of housing are delayed in getting their houses: • 1968: 71% of the local houses in Dungannon were given to Protestants • although 53% of the people there were Catholics • thus the Catholics find the provision of housing unfair
Protestant - Catholic Tension Voting Rights: • Prior to 1968: Each household entitled to two votes • companies entitled to more votes depending on their size • more companies were owned by richer Protestants, they ended up with more votes • Catholics were unhappy as voting districts were often drawn up to include large proportion of Protestants
Protestant - Catholic Tension Voting Rights: • Since 1968: Everyone is entitled to one vote as long as he or she is • a British subject and • is above 18 years old • has to be born in Northern Ireland or has lived in the United Kingdom for seven years • Voting districts redrawn to ensure fairness
How did the Catholics Make Their Demands? • Mid 1960s: Civil Rights Movement emerged • to demand for equal rights • and to protest against unfair treatment of the Catholics • made peaceful demands for basic rights such as housing, jobs, education and voting
How did the Catholics Make Their Demands? • Met with hostility and violence from some Protestants: • including the police force who thought that the movement was an attempt to weaken the government • The Civil Rights Movement in 1968 marked the beginning of the period known as The Troubles
How did the Catholics Make Their Demands? • Worsened situation: Government called for more help • Aug 1969: British Army units sent to Northern Ireland to help keep order • welcomed by Catholics as first as they thought they would be protected • however loss faith in them when they began searching their homes and arresting suspects
How did the Catholics Make Their Demands? • Bloody Sunday - 1972: • Peaceful civil rights march was shot at by the British soldiers • 13 civilians shot dead • many more were wounded • this incident was a turning point for the Protestant-Catholic ties
How did the Catholics Make Their Demands? • After 1972: • more violence between the Protestants and Catholics • destruction of Catholics’ property by Protestant mobs • British Army often raiding Catholic homes • witnessed by local police force which did not do anything to stop them
How did the Catholics Make Their Demands? • Catholics turned to Irish Republican Army (IRA) for help • IRA: An illegal organisation formed largely of Northern Irish Catholics • aim to use violence to drive British Army and representatives of the British government out of Northern Ireland
How did the Catholics Make Their Demands? • Gained substantial support in the Catholic community • during the rioting of the 1960s as they were perceived as defending communities against Protestants and police attacks • 1970s onwards: IRA engaged in armed confrontations with the British army • killing over 100 British soldiers by 1972 and carrying out more than 1300 explosions
Sunningdale Agreement • 1974: • mainstream Catholic and Protestant parties, along with the British and Irish governments, negotiated the Sunningdale Agreement • providing Power Sharing between Catholics and Protestants and a Council of Ireland • designed to encourage cross border co-operation • However, this agreement was opposed by extremists from both sides
Sunningdale Agreement • Brought down by mass action of Protestants: • organised general strikes that stopped all business on the province • and cut off water and electrical supplies • Catholics blamed British government for not doing enough to break the strike and uphold the agreement • agreement collapsed due to withdrawal of support
The Long War • IRA declared ceasefire in 1974 • returned to violence in 1976 • developing a strategy called the Long War • less intense, yet more sustained campaign of violence
Long War: Hunger Strikes • 1980 - 1981: • aimed at restoration of political status of paramilitary groups • 1981 Irish Hunger Strike: 10 Catholic prisoners starved to death • proved highly emotive for the Catholic community, 100 000 people attended their funeral • demonstrated high level of support among the Catholics
The Long War • 1976 -1994: Paramilitary violence continued on both sides • negative psychological effect on North Irish society • IRA was further boosted by large donation of arms from Libya in 1986 • now killing fewer British soldiers, they now directed their targets at Protestants
The Long War • 1976 -1994: Paramilitary violence continued on both sides • Protestant paramilitaries: imported arms from South Africa • and stepped up their killing of Catholics • Security forces were also alleged to operate a policy of “Shoot to Kill”, killing rather than arresting IRA suspects
Peace Process • Late 1980s: • Sinn Fein (political wing of IRA) sought a negotiated end to conflict • Aug 1994: IRA declared a ceasefire • 1998: Belfast Agreement produced
Belfast Agreement • Self-government restored to Northern Ireland on the bases of ‘power sharing’: • The government (the Northern Ireland Executive) must contain both the largest Protestant party and the largest Catholic party • All bills passed in the Northern Ireland Assembly must have the support of a majority of both Catholics and Protestants • Disbandment of the Protestant Police Force and replacement with the Police Service of Northern Ireland, which must have a quota of Catholic recruits
Peace Process • 2001: Agreement suspended • Protestants withdrawing from Power Sharing agreement • until IRA destroyed its weapons • Although IRA decommissioning has since taken place (since September 2005), the Protestant party still refuse to accept the Catholic claims that “the war is over”
Casualties • 1969-2001: • more than 3 523 people were killed in the Protestant-Catholic conflict • IRA was responsible for two-thirds of the deaths • also responsible for the killing innocent Protestants
Casualties • Majority of them were civilians (1857 civilians) • Security forces (1121 members), Members of Catholic groups (392 members) • Members of Protestant groups (151 members)
Implications • Since the agreement, relatively moderate parties have been slowly eclipsed by more extremist parties • Although political violence has been greatly reduced, religious animosity is still present • residential areas are still largely segregated between Catholics and Protestants
Implications • Northern Ireland, especially Belfast, has areas for Catholics and Protestants • Protestant parades has marched into the Catholic area and sparked violence and deaths of civilians • Progress towards the Belfast Agreement seems unlikely
Implications • Major churches in Northern Ireland have condemned violence throughout the Troubles • emphasized that religion do not figure in the political ideologies of the contending parties • Regions are also split regarding ideologies • areas like South Armagh being hardline Catholic • while areas like Portadown, Derry and Antrim being staunch Protestant in nature
References - BBC History – The Troubles (http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/war/troubles/) - Conflict Archive on the Internet (http://cain.ulst.ac.uk/) - Longman Upper Secondary Social Studies, Northern Ireland: A Troubled Land (Pg. 60-66)